[
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "preamble",
    "before": "FRANCIS FRANCH BAHAMONDE HEAD OF THE SPANISH STATE, GENERALISM OF NATIONAL ARRANGEMENTS Since, on 24 September 1970, the Plenipotentiary of Spain signed in Brussels, together with the Plenipotentiary of Belgium, appointed in good and due form to that effect, a Convention between Spain and Belgium to prevent double taxation and to regulate certain matters relating to income and property taxes, the certified text of which is inserted below: The Spanish Head of State and His Majesty the King of the Belgians, in order to avoid double taxation and regulate certain matters relating to income and property taxes, have decided to conclude an agreement and have designated Plenipotentiaries to that effect: THE Spanish Head of State: H.E. Mr. D. Jaime Alba Delibes, Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of Spain in Belgium; His Majesty the King of the Belgians; H.E. Sir. Pierre Harmel, Minister for Foreign Affairs. Those who, having exchanged their plenipotentiaries and found them in good and proper form, have agreed as follows:\n[heading] I. SCOPE OF THE CONVENTION",
    "after": "FRANCISCO FRANCO BAHAMONDE — HEAD OF THE SPANISH STATE, GENERALISSIMO OF THE NATIONAL ARMED FORCES Whereas on 24 September 1970 the Plenipotentiary of Spain signed at Brussels, together with the Plenipotentiary of Belgium, appointed in good and due form for that purpose, a Convention between Spain and Belgium for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Regulation of Certain Matters concerning Taxes on Income and on Capital, the certified text of which is set out below: The Head of the Spanish State and His Majesty the King of the Belgians, wishing to avoid double taxation and regulate certain matters concerning taxes on income and on capital, have decided to conclude a Convention and have appointed as their Plenipotentiaries: The Head of the Spanish State: His Excellency Jaime Alba Delibes, Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of Spain in Belgium. His Majesty the King of the Belgians: His Excellency Pierre Harmel, Minister for Foreign Affairs. Who, having exchanged their full powers and found them in good and due form, have agreed as follows:\nI. SCOPE OF THE CONVENTION",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-1",
    "before": "Article 1. Personal scope. This Convention applies to persons resident in one or both Contracting States.",
    "after": "Article 1. Scope as regards persons. This Convention shall apply to persons who are residents of one or both Contracting States.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-2",
    "before": "Article 2. Target area. §1. This Convention applies to income and property taxes payable by each Contracting State, its political subdivisions and local authorities, irrespective of the levy system. §2. Income and property taxes are those which tax all or any part of the income or property, including taxes on profits resulting from the disposal of movable or immovable property, taxes on the amount of salaried property paid by undertakings (not including social security contributions), as well as capital gains taxes, § 3. The current taxes to which this Convention specifically applies are: 1. or In Spain: (a) General Income Tax for Physical Persons; (b) The General Income Tax on Companies and Other Legal Entities, including the special levy established by article 104 of Law 41/1964 of 11 June; (c) The following taxes on account: the Territorial Contribution on Rustic and Pecuaria Wealth, the Territorial Contribution on Urban Wealth, the Income Tax on Personal Work, the Capital Income Tax and the Tax on Commercial and Industrial Activities and Benefits; (d) In Sahara and Ifni, income taxes (labour and property) and taxes on the profits of enterprises: (e) For undertakings governed by the Act of 26 December 1958 engaged in the investigation and exploitation of hydrocarbons, in addition to the other taxes listed in this article, the area tax, the gross product tax and the excise duty on the profits of those companies; (f) Local taxes, income or property taxes and capital gains. 2. or In Belgium: (a) Tax on natural persons; (b) Corporate tax; (c) Tax on legal persons; (d) Tax on non-residents; including account taxes and their supplements, surcharges on the above, as well as the local additional tax on natural persons' tax. §4. This Convention shall also apply to future taxes of an identical or similar nature which are added to or replaced by existing taxes. Each year, the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall notify each other of any amendments made to their respective tax laws,\n[heading]II. DEFINITIONS",
    "after": "Article 2. Taxes covered. § 1. This Convention shall apply to taxes on income and on capital imposed by either Contracting State, its political subdivisions and local authorities, irrespective of the manner in which they are levied. § 2. Taxes on income and on capital include taxes on total income or capital or any part thereof, including taxes on gains from alienating movable or immovable property, taxes on the total amount of salaries paid by enterprises (excluding social security contributions), and taxes on capital appreciation. § 3. The existing taxes to which this Convention specifically applies are: (1) In Spain: (a) general tax on the income of individuals; (b) general tax on the income of companies and other legal entities, including the special levy under Article 104 of Law 41/1964 of 11 June; (c) the following taxes on account: land tax on rural and livestock property, land tax on urban property, tax on earned income, tax on capital income and tax on commercial and industrial activities and profits; (d) in Sahara and Ifni, taxes on income from work and property and taxes on business profits; (e) for enterprises governed by the Law of 26 December 1958 engaged in exploring for and exploiting hydrocarbons, in addition to the other taxes listed here, the surface charge, gross-output tax and special tax on their profits; (f) local taxes on income or capital and on capital appreciation. (2) In Belgium: (a) tax on individuals; (b) corporation tax; (c) tax on legal persons; (d) tax on non-residents; including taxes on account and their supplements, surcharges on those taxes, and local tax additional to tax on individuals. § 4. This Convention shall also apply to future identical or substantially similar taxes added to or replacing the existing taxes. Each year the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall notify each other of changes made to their respective tax laws.\nII. DEFINITIONS",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-3",
    "before": "Article 3. General definitions. §1. This Convention, unless otherwise interpreted: 1. or The term ‘Belgium’, used geographically, means the territory of the Kingdom of Belgium; the term ‘Spain’, used in the same sense, means the Spanish State (Spain peninsular, the Balearic Islands and the Canary Islands and the Spanish squares and provinces in Africa); 2. The words ‘one Contracting State’ and ‘the other Contracting State’ mean Spain or Belgium, as derived from the text; 3.° The term ‘person’ includes natural persons, corporations and any other grouping of persons; 4. the term 'company' means any legal person or any entity that is considered a legal person for tax purposes in the State of which it is resident; 5. The terms 'undertaking of one Contracting State' and 'undertaking of the other Contracting State' mean, respectively, an undertaking operated by a resident of one Contracting State and an undertaking operated by a resident of the other Contracting State; 6. The expression ‘competent authority’ means: (a) in Belgium, the competent authority in accordance with its national law; and (b) in Spain, the Minister of Finance, the Director-General of Direct Taxes or any other authority to which the Minister delegates. §2. For the purposes of the application of this Convention by a Contracting State, any expression not otherwise defined shall, unless the text requires a different interpretation, have the meaning attributed to it by the law of that Contracting State, relating to the taxes which are the subject of this Convention.",
    "after": "Article 3. General definitions. § 1. In this Convention, unless the text requires a different interpretation: (1) “Belgium”, used geographically, means the territory of the Kingdom of Belgium; “Spain”, used in the same sense, means the Spanish State (mainland Spain, the Balearic and Canary Islands, and the Spanish enclaves and provinces in Africa). (2) “A Contracting State” and “the other Contracting State” mean Spain or Belgium, as the text requires. (3) “Person” includes individuals, companies and any other body of persons. (4) “Company” means any legal person or entity treated as a legal person for tax purposes in its State of residence. (5) “Enterprise of a Contracting State” and “enterprise of the other Contracting State” mean respectively an enterprise carried on by a resident of a Contracting State and an enterprise carried on by a resident of the other Contracting State. (6) “Competent authority” means: (a) in Belgium, the authority competent under its national law; (b) in Spain, the Minister of Finance, Director-General of Direct Taxes or any other authority to whom the Minister delegates. § 2. For application of this Convention by a Contracting State, an otherwise undefined term shall, unless the text requires a different interpretation, have its meaning under that State’s law concerning the taxes covered by this Convention.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-4",
    "before": "Article 4. Tax address. §1. For the purposes of this Convention, any person who, under the law of that State, is subject to taxation in that State by reason of his domicile, residence, place of address or any other criterion of a similar nature is considered a ‘resident of a Contracting State’. §2. Where, under the provisions of paragraph 1, a natural person is resident in both Contracting States, the case shall be settled according to the following rules: (a) This person shall be considered a resident of the Contracting State where he or she has a permanent dwelling at his or her disposal. If he has a permanent dwelling at his disposal in both Contracting States, he shall be considered a resident of the Contracting State with which he has closer personal and economic relations (centre of vital interests); (b) If the Contracting State in which that person has the centre of his or her vital interests cannot be determined, or if he or she does not have permanent housing at his or her disposal in any of the Contracting States, he or she shall be considered a resident of the Contracting State in which he or she normally lives; (c) If he or she is habitually resident in both Contracting States or does not live in either Contracting State, he or she shall be considered a resident of the Contracting State of which he or she is a national; (d) If he is a national of either Contracting State or is not a national of either Contracting State, the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall decide the case by mutual agreement. § 3. Where, under the provisions of paragraph 1, a person, excluding natural persons, is a resident of both Contracting States, he or she shall be considered a resident of the Contracting State in which his or her place of effective management is located.",
    "after": "Article 4. Tax domicile. § 1. For this Convention, “resident of a Contracting State” means any person liable to tax under that State’s law by reason of domicile, residence, place of management or any similar criterion. § 2. Where paragraph 1 makes an individual a resident of both Contracting States, the case shall be determined as follows: (a) The individual shall be deemed a resident of the State in which a permanent home is available. If one is available in both States, the individual shall be deemed a resident of the State with which personal and economic relations are closer (centre of vital interests). (b) If the State in which the centre of vital interests is situated cannot be determined, or no permanent home is available in either State, the individual shall be deemed a resident of the State of habitual abode. (c) If the individual has a habitual abode in both States or neither, the individual shall be deemed a resident of the State of nationality. (d) If the individual is a national of both States or of neither, the competent authorities shall settle the case by mutual agreement. § 3. Where paragraph 1 makes a person other than an individual a resident of both Contracting States, that person shall be deemed a resident of the State in which its place of effective management is situated.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-5",
    "before": "Article 5. Permanent establishment. §1. For the purposes of this Agreement, the term ‘permanent establishment’ means a fixed place of business in which an undertaking carries out all or part of its activity. §2. The term ‘permanent establishment’ includes in particular: (a) the head offices; (b) branches; (c) Offices; (d) factories; (e) Workshops; (f) mines, quarries or any other place of exploitation of natural resources; (g) construction or assembly works lasting more than 12 months. § 3. The term ‘permanent establishment’ does not include: (a) the use of facilities for the sole purpose of storing, displaying or delivering goods belonging to the undertaking; (b) the maintenance of a warehouse of goods belonging to the undertaking for the sole purpose of storing, displaying or delivering them; (c) the maintenance of a warehouse of goods belonging to the undertaking for the sole purpose of processing by another undertaking; (d) the maintenance of a fixed place of business for the sole purpose of purchasing goods or collecting information for the undertaking; (e) the maintenance of a fixed place of business for the sole purpose of advertising, providing information; conducting scientific research or other similar activities which are preparatory or auxiliary in nature provided that such activities are carried out for the undertaking itself. §4. A person acting in a Contracting State on behalf of an undertaking of the other Contracting State, except in the case of an independent agent covered by paragraph 5, is considered to constitute a permanent establishment in the State first mentioned if he has and habitually exercises in that State powers to conclude contracts on behalf of the undertaking, unless his activities are limited to the purchase of goods for that undertaking. § 5. An undertaking of one Contracting State is not considered to have a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State merely because it carries out activities in that other State through a broker, a general commissioner or any other mediator enjoying an independent status, provided that these persons act within the ordinary framework of their activity, The mediator acting on behalf of an insurance undertaking and habitually concluding contracts on behalf of an insurance undertaking is not covered by this provision. § 6. The fact that a company resident of a Contracting State controls a company that is resident of the other Contracting State or that carries out activities in that other State (whether by permanent establishment or otherwise), does not in itself make any of these companies permanent establishment of the other State.\n[heading] III. IMPOSITION ON RENT",
    "after": "Article 5. Permanent establishment. § 1. “Permanent establishment” means a fixed place of business in which an enterprise carries on all or part of its business. § 2. It includes in particular: (a) places of management; (b) branches; (c) offices; (d) factories; (e) workshops; (f) mines, quarries or other places of exploiting natural resources; (g) building sites or assembly projects lasting more than twelve months. § 3. It does not include: (a) facilities used solely to store, display or deliver merchandise belonging to the enterprise; (b) a stock of such merchandise maintained solely for storage, display or delivery; (c) a stock of such merchandise maintained solely for processing by another enterprise; (d) a fixed place maintained solely to purchase merchandise or collect information for the enterprise; (e) a fixed place maintained solely for advertising, supplying information, scientific research or similar preparatory or auxiliary activities, provided they are carried on for the enterprise itself. § 4. A person acting in a Contracting State on behalf of an enterprise of the other Contracting State, other than an independent agent covered by paragraph 5, shall be deemed a permanent establishment in the first State if that person has and habitually exercises there authority to conclude contracts in the enterprise’s name, unless the activities are limited to purchasing merchandise for the enterprise. § 5. An enterprise of a Contracting State shall not be deemed to have a permanent establishment in the other State merely because it carries on business there through a broker, general commission agent or other independent intermediary, provided such persons act in the ordinary course of their business. An intermediary acting for an insurance enterprise who habitually concludes contracts in its name is not covered by this provision. § 6. A company resident in a Contracting State controlling a company resident in the other State or carrying on business there through a permanent establishment or otherwise does not of itself make either company a permanent establishment of the other.\nIII. TAXATION OF INCOME",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-6",
    "before": "Article 6. Real estate rent. §1. Income from immovable property may be taxed in the Contracting State in which such property is situated. §2. The term ‘real property’ shall be defined in accordance with the law of the Contracting State in which the property is situated. In any event, this term includes accessories, livestock and equipment used on agricultural and forestry holdings, rights to which the provisions of private law relating to territorial property, the use of immovable property and rights to variable or fixed fees for the exploitation or concession of the exploitation of mineral deposits, sources or other land wealth apply. Credits secured by mortgage on the above-mentioned assets, as well as ships, ships and aircraft, are not considered real property. § 3. The provisions of paragraph 1 apply to income derived from the direct use, lease or any other form of exploitation of immovable property. §4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 3 also apply to income derived from immovable property of undertakings and immovable property used for the pursuit of professional services.",
    "after": "Article 6. Income from immovable property. § 1. Income from immovable property may be taxed in the Contracting State where the property is situated. § 2. “Immovable property” shall be defined under the law of the State where it is situated. It includes in any event accessories, livestock and equipment used in agriculture and forestry, rights governed by private-law provisions concerning landed property, usufruct of immovable property, and rights to variable or fixed royalties for exploiting, or the right to exploit, mineral deposits, sources or other resources of the soil. Debt-claims secured by mortgage on that property, and ships, boats and aircraft, shall not be regarded as immovable property. § 3. Paragraph 1 applies to income from direct use, letting or any other exploitation of immovable property. § 4. Paragraphs 1 and 3 also apply to income from immovable property of enterprises and property used to perform professional services.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-7",
    "before": "Article 7. Benefits of companies. §1. The profits of an undertaking in a Contracting State may be taxed only in that State unless the undertaking carries out operations in the other State by means of a permanent establishment situated in that State. In the latter case, the profits of the company may be taxed in the other State, but only to the extent that they can be attributed to the permanent establishment. §2. Without prejudice to paragraph 3, where an undertaking of one Contracting State engages in business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated therein, in each Contracting State the permanent establishment shall be credited with the profits it would obtain if it were a separate undertaking carrying out the same or similar activities under the same or similar conditions and acting entirely independently. § 3. For the purpose of determining the benefit of the permanent establishment, the deduction of expenses for the purposes of the permanent establishment shall be allowed, duly demonstrated, including management and general administrative expenses for the same purposes, equally demonstrated, whether incurred in the State in which the permanent establishment is located or elsewhere. §4. In the absence of sufficient accounting to determine the amount of profits of an undertaking of one Contracting State attributable to its permanent establishment situated in the other State, the tax may be determined in that other State in accordance with its own law. However, the method applied should be such that the result obtained is in accordance with the principles set out in this article. § 5. No benefit shall be attributed to a permanent establishment merely because it buys goods for the undertaking. § 6. Where the profits of an undertaking comprise income regulated separately in other articles of this Convention, the provisions of those articles shall not be affected by those of this Article, with regard to the taxation of such income.",
    "after": "Article 7. Business profits. § 1. Profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State shall be taxable only in that State unless it operates in the other State through a permanent establishment situated there. In that case its profits may be taxed in the other State only to the extent attributable to that establishment. § 2. Subject to paragraph 3, where an enterprise carries on business in the other State through a permanent establishment there, each State shall attribute to that establishment the profits it would earn as a distinct and separate enterprise carrying on the same or similar activities under the same or similar conditions and acting wholly independently. § 3. Duly substantiated expenses for the purposes of the permanent establishment, including equally substantiated executive and general administrative expenses for those purposes, shall be deductible in determining its profits, whether incurred in the State where it is situated or elsewhere. § 4. If accounts are insufficient to determine the enterprise’s profits attributable to its permanent establishment in the other State, tax may be determined in that other State under its own law. The method used must nevertheless produce a result consistent with this Article’s principles. § 5. No profits shall be attributed merely because the permanent establishment purchases merchandise for the enterprise. § 6. Where enterprise profits include income dealt with separately in other Articles, those Articles shall not be affected by this Article concerning taxation of that income.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-8",
    "before": "Article 8. Shipping and air transport. §1. Notwithstanding Article 7, paragraphs 1 to 5, profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic may be taxed only in the Contracting State where the place of effective management of the enterprise is located. §2. If the place of effective management of a shipping company in international traffic is on board a ship, this seat shall be deemed to be in the Contracting State where the port-base of this ship is located, and if there is no such port-base, in the Contracting State in which the person operating the ship resides. § 3. The provisions of paragraph 1 also apply to the profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State from a pool of a joint holding or from an International Agency for the Exploitation of Maritime or Air Navigation.",
    "after": "Article 8. Shipping and air transport. § 1. Notwithstanding Article 7(1) to (5), profits from operating ships or aircraft in international traffic shall be taxable only in the Contracting State where the enterprise’s place of effective management is situated. § 2. If the place of effective management of an international shipping enterprise is aboard a ship, it shall be deemed situated in the State of the ship’s home harbour or, if none, in the State where its operator is resident. § 3. Paragraph 1 also applies to profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State from a pool, joint operation or international operating agency for shipping or air transport.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-9",
    "before": "Article 9. Associated enterprises. When: an undertaking of a Contracting State participates, directly or indirectly, in the direction, control or financing of an undertaking of the other Contracting State; or the same persons participate, directly or indirectly, in the direction, control or financing of an undertaking of a Contracting State and of an undertaking of the other Contracting State, and in either case the two companies are; in their commercial or financial relations, bound by terms, accepted or imposed; which differ from those to be agreed by independent undertakings, the profits that one of the companies would have obtained in the absence of these conditions, and which in fact have not occurred because of them, may be included in the profits of this undertaking and subject to taxation accordingly.",
    "after": "Article 9. Associated enterprises. Where an enterprise of a Contracting State participates directly or indirectly in the management, control or financing of an enterprise of the other State; or the same persons participate directly or indirectly in the management, control or financing of enterprises of both States; and in either case conditions accepted or imposed between the enterprises in their commercial or financial relations differ from those independent enterprises would agree, profits which one enterprise would have earned but for those conditions, and has not earned because of them, may be included in its profits and taxed accordingly.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-10",
    "before": "Article 10. Dividends. §1. Dividends paid by a company resident of one Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in the latter State. §2. However, such dividends may be taxed in the Contracting State in which the company paying the dividends resides, and in accordance with the law of that State, but the tax thus required may not exceed 15 per 100 of the gross amount of such dividends. This paragraph does not affect the company's taxation of profits from which dividends are paid. § 3. The term ‘dividend’ used in this Article includes the income from shares, shares or enjoyment bonds, parts of mines, parts of founders or other rights, except credit rights, which permit participation in profits, as well as income from other social participations subject to the same regime as the income from shares under the tax law of the State in which the distribution company resides; This term also covers income — including those paid in the form of interest — which may be taxed as income derived from capital invested by members of companies, other than shares, resident in Belgium. §4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 do not apply if the beneficiary of the dividends, resident of one Contracting State, has in the other Contracting State, of which the company that pays the dividends is resident, a permanent establishment with which the share generated by the dividends is effectively linked. In this case, dividends may be taxed in this other State in accordance with its legislation. § 5. Where a company resident of one Contracting State obtains profits or income from the other Contracting State, that other State may not require any tax on dividends paid outside its territory by that company to persons who are not residents of that other State or subject the undistributed profits of the company to any additional tax, even if dividends paid or profits not distributed consist, in whole or in part, of profits or income from that other State; this provision does not prevent that other State from imposing dividends corresponding to a participation actually linked to a permanent establishment operated in that other State by a resident of the first State.",
    "after": "Article 10. Dividends. § 1. Dividends paid by a company resident in a Contracting State to a resident of the other State may be taxed in that other State. § 2. They may also be taxed under the law of the State where the paying company is resident, but the tax so charged shall not exceed 15 per cent of the gross dividends. This does not affect taxation of the company on the profits out of which they are paid. § 3. “Dividends” includes income from shares, jouissance shares or rights, mining shares, founders’ shares or other profit-participating rights other than debt-claims, and income from other corporate interests subject to the same treatment as share income under the tax law of the paying company’s State of residence. It also includes income, even if paid as interest, taxable as income from capital invested by partners in companies resident in Belgium other than companies limited by shares. § 4. Paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply where the recipient, resident in a Contracting State, has in the other State of which the paying company is resident a permanent establishment effectively connected with the holding generating the dividends. Those dividends may then be taxed there under its law. § 5. Where a resident company derives profits or income from the other State, that other State may not tax dividends paid outside its territory by the company to persons not resident in that other State, nor impose a supplementary tax on its undistributed profits, even if those dividends or profits consist wholly or partly of profits or income from that other State. This does not prevent that other State taxing dividends from a holding effectively connected with a permanent establishment carried on there by a resident of the first State.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-11",
    "before": "Article 11. Interest. §1. Interest from a Contracting State paid to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in the latter State. §2. However, these interests may be subject to taxation in the Contracting State from which they come, and in accordance with the law of that State, but the tax thus required may not exceed 15 per cent of the amount of interest. § 3. The term ‘interest’ used in this Article includes income from public debt, from obligations with or without a mortgage guarantee and entitled or not to participate in profits and, without prejudice to paragraph 4, credit or deposits of any kind, as well as lots of borrowings and any other income which the tax legislation of the State from which the interest comes subject to the same regime as the income from the amounts lent or deposited. §4. This article does not apply. (a) interest treated as dividends pursuant to Article 10(3)(2); (b) interest on commercial claims — including those represented by trade effects — arising from the deferment of payment for the delivery of goods or products or the provision of services by an undertaking of a Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State; (c) interest on current accounts or advances made between banks of the two Contracting States. The interests referred to in subparagraphs (b) and (c) above shall be governed by the provisions of article 7. § 5. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 do not apply if the beneficiary of the interest, resident of one Contracting State, has in the other Contracting State, from which the interest derives a permanent establishment with which the credit or deposit generated by the interest is effectively linked. In this case, interest may be taxed in this other State in accordance with its law. § 6. Interests are considered to come from a Contracting State where the debtor is the State itself, one of its political subdivisions, one of its local entities or a resident thereof. However, where the debtor of interest, whether or not he is resident of a Contracting State, has in the other Contracting State a permanent establishment in respect of which the debt has been incurred, which gives rise to the interest, and this establishment supports the payment thereof, the interest shall be deemed to have come from the Contracting State where the permanent establishment is located. § 7. Where, due to special relationships between the debtor and the creditor or depositor or between the debtor and any other person, the amount of interest paid, taking into account the receivable or deposit for which it is paid, exceeds the amount that would have been agreed upon by the debtor and the creditor or depositor in the absence of such relationships, the limitation provided for in paragraph 2 shall apply only to the latter amount. In this case, the excess of interest may be subject to taxation in the Contracting State from which the interest comes and in accordance with its legislation.",
    "after": "Article 11. Interest. § 1. Interest arising in a Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other State may be taxed in the latter State. § 2. It may also be taxed under the law of its State of source, but the tax so charged shall not exceed 15 per cent of the amount of the interest. § 3. “Interest” includes income from public debt, bonds with or without mortgage security and with or without a right to participate in profits, and, subject to paragraph 4, debt-claims or deposits of any kind, loan prizes and any other return treated under source-State tax law as income from money lent or deposited. § 4. This Article shall not apply to: (a) interest assimilated to dividends under Article 10(3), second subparagraph; (b) interest on commercial credits, including those represented by commercial bills, arising from deferred payment for deliveries of merchandise or products or services supplied by an enterprise of a Contracting State to a resident of the other State; (c) interest on current accounts or nominative advances between banking enterprises of both States. Interest under (b) and (c) shall be governed by Article 7. § 5. Paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply if the recipient, resident in a Contracting State, has in the source State a permanent establishment effectively connected with the debt-claim or deposit generating the interest. The interest may then be taxed there under its law. § 6. Interest is deemed to arise in a Contracting State where the payer is that State, a political subdivision, local authority or resident thereof. Where the payer, resident in a Contracting State or not, has in the other Contracting State a permanent establishment in connection with which the debt was incurred and which bears the interest, the interest is deemed to arise in the State where that establishment is situated. § 7. Where, because of a special relationship between the payer and creditor or depositor, or between both and another person, the interest exceeds, having regard to the debt-claim or deposit, what they would have agreed without that relationship, paragraph 2’s limit applies only to the latter amount. The excess may be taxed in the source State under its law.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-12",
    "before": "Article 12. Royalties. §1. The previous fees of one Contracting State paid to a resident of the other Contracting State may be subject to and imposed in the latter State. §2. However, these fees may be subject to taxation in the Contracting State from which they come, and in accordance with the law of that State, but the tax thus required may not exceed 5 per 100 of the gross amount of the fees. § 3. The term ‘royalties’ used in this Article includes amounts of any kind paid for the use or granting of copyright on literary, artistic or scientific works, including cinematographic, patent, trademark or trade mark films, designs, plans, formulas or secret procedures, as well as for the use or granting of use of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment, which do not constitute immovable property listed in Article 6, and amounts paid for information relating to industrial, commercial or scientific experience. §4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 do not apply if the beneficiary of the royalties, resident of one Contracting State, has in the other Contracting State, from which the royalties come, a permanent establishment with which the right or ownership for which the royalties are paid is effectively linked. In this case the fees may be subject to taxation in this other State, in accordance with its legislation, § 5. The fees are considered to come from a Contracting State where the debtor is the State itself, one of its political subdivisions, one of its local entities or a resident thereof. However, where the debtor of the royalties, whether or not he is a resident of a Contracting State, has in a Contracting State a permanent establishment for which the contract giving rise to the payment of the royalties has been concluded and this establishment supports the payment thereof, the royalties shall be deemed to have come from the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment is situated. § 6. Where, due to special relations between the debtor and the beneficiary of the royalties, or between the two and any other person, the amount of the royalties paid, taking into account the benefit for which they are paid, exceeds the amount that would have been agreed by the debtor and the beneficiary in the absence of such relationships, the limitation provided for in paragraph 2 shall apply only to the latter amount. In this case, the excess of the fees may be taxed in the Contracting State from which the fees come and in accordance with its legislation.",
    "after": "Article 12. Royalties. § 1. Royalties arising in a Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other State may be taxed in the latter State. § 2. They may also be taxed under the law of their State of source, but the tax so charged shall not exceed 5 per cent of their gross amount. § 3. “Royalties” includes payments of any kind for the use of, or the right to use, copyright in literary, artistic or scientific works, including cinematograph films; patents, trademarks, designs or models, plans, secret formulae or processes; industrial, commercial or scientific equipment not constituting immovable property under Article 6; and information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience. § 4. Paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply where the recipient, resident in a Contracting State, has in the source State a permanent establishment effectively connected with the right or property generating the royalties. They may then be taxed there under its law. § 5. Royalties are deemed to arise in a Contracting State where the payer is that State, a political subdivision, local authority or resident thereof. Where the payer, resident in a Contracting State or not, has in a Contracting State a permanent establishment for which the contract generating the royalty payment was concluded and which bears that payment, they are deemed to arise in the State where that establishment is situated. § 6. Where, because of a special relationship between the payer and recipient or between both and another person, royalties exceed, having regard to what they are paid for, what they would have agreed without that relationship, paragraph 2’s limit applies only to the latter amount. The excess may be taxed in the source State under its law.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-13",
    "before": "Article 13. Capital gains. §1. Profits arising from the disposal of immovable property, as defined in article 6, paragraph 2, may be taxed in the Contracting State in which they are located. §2. Gains from the disposal of movable property forming part of the assets of a permanent establishment held by an undertaking of one Contracting State in the other Contracting State, or from movable property belonging to a fixed base held by a resident of one Contracting State in the other Contracting State for the pursuit of a professional activity, including gains arising from the disposal of the permanent establishment (only or with the enterprise as a whole) or the fixed base, may be taxed in that other State. For the determination of the amount of these gains, the rules provided for in article 7, paragraphs 2 and 3, apply. However, the proceeds from the disposal of movable property referred to in article 22, paragraph 3, may be taxed only in the Contracting State to which, according to that article, the right to tax them belongs. § 3. Profits arising from the disposal of any other property, including holdings — which are not part of the assets of a permanent establishment referred to in paragraph 2(1) — in a share company may be taxed only in the State in which the transferor resides,",
    "after": "Article 13. Capital gains. § 1. Gains from alienating immovable property as defined in Article 6(2) may be taxed in the State where it is situated. § 2. Gains from alienating movable property forming part of the assets of a permanent establishment which an enterprise has in the other State, or movable property pertaining to a fixed base available to a resident in the other State for professional activities, including gains from alienating that establishment, alone or with the whole enterprise, or that fixed base, may be taxed in that other State. Article 7(2) and (3) shall apply to determine those gains. However, gains from alienating movable property mentioned in Article 22(3) shall be taxable only in the State entitled under that Article to tax it. § 3. Gains from alienating any other property, including interests in a company limited by shares not forming part of the assets of a permanent establishment mentioned in paragraph 2, first subparagraph, shall be taxable only in the transferor’s State of residence.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-14",
    "before": "Article 14. Independent professions. §1. Income obtained by a resident of a Contracting State through the provision of professional services or the pursuit of other independent activities of a similar nature may only be taxed in that State unless that resident normally has a fixed basis in the other Contracting State for the pursuit of his or her activity. In the latter case, such income may be taxed in the other State, but only to the extent that it precedes attributing it to the fixed base. §2. The term \"professional services\" includes, in particular, independent scientific, literary, artistic, educational or teaching activities, as well as independent activities of doctors, lawyers, engineers, architects, dentists and accountants.",
    "after": "Article 14. Independent professions. § 1. Income derived by a resident of a Contracting State from professional services or similar independent activities shall be taxable only in that State unless a fixed base is habitually available in the other State for those activities. In that case it may be taxed there only to the extent attributable to the fixed base. § 2. “Professional services” includes in particular independent scientific, literary, artistic, educational or teaching activities and the independent activities of physicians, lawyers, engineers, architects, dentists and accountants.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-15",
    "before": "Article 15. Dependent work. §1. Without prejudice to the provisions of Articles 16, 18, 19, 20 and 21, salaries, salaries and similar remuneration obtained by a resident of a Contracting State on account of employment may only be subject to taxation in that State, unless the employment is exercised in the other Contracting State. If employment is exercised in the latter State the remuneration derived therefrom may be subject to taxation in that State, §2. Notwithstanding paragraph 1 and without prejudice to the reference contained therein, remuneration obtained by a resident of a Contracting State on account of employment, not covered by paragraph 3, exercised in the other Contracting State, may only be taxed in the former State if: (a) are paid for the activity carried out in the other State for a period or periods — including normal work breaks — not exceeding a total of one hundred and eighty-three days during the calendar year; (b) remuneration is paid for or on behalf of a person who is not a resident of the other State; and (c) Remuneration is not borne by a permanent establishment or a fixed basis which the person for whom work is performed has in the other State. § 3. By way of derogation from paragraph 1, remunerations earned on account of employment on board a ship or aircraft in international traffic are deemed to be obtained by reason of an activity carried out in the Contracting State where the company's effective headquarters are located and may be subject to taxation in that State.",
    "after": "Article 15. Income from employment. § 1. Subject to Articles 16, 18, 19, 20 and 21, salaries, wages and similar remuneration derived by a resident of a Contracting State from employment shall be taxable only in that State unless the employment is exercised in the other State. If so exercised, the remuneration may be taxed there. § 2. Notwithstanding paragraph 1 and subject to the references therein, remuneration derived by a resident from employment not covered by paragraph 3 exercised in the other State shall be taxable only in the first State if: (a) it is paid for activity exercised in the other State for a period or periods, including normal interruptions of work, not exceeding in total 183 days during the calendar year; (b) it is paid by or on behalf of a person not resident in the other State; and (c) it is not borne by a permanent establishment or fixed base which the person for whom the work is performed has in the other State. § 3. Notwithstanding paragraph 1, remuneration for employment aboard a ship or aircraft in international traffic is deemed derived from activity exercised in the State where the enterprise’s place of effective management is situated and may be taxed in that State.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-16",
    "before": "Article 16. Participations of members and company commissioners. §1. Participations, attendance allowances and similar remunerations which a resident of a Contracting State obtains as a member of a Board of Directors or Supervisory Board or of another similar body of a company for shares resident of the other Contracting State may be subject to taxation in that other State. This provision also applies to the remuneration of a co-mandatory partner of a share company. §2. The remuneration which the persons referred to in paragraph 1 receive in any other way shall be governed, according to its nature, by the provisions of article 14 or article 15.",
    "after": "Article 16. Directors’ and company commissioners’ fees. § 1. Directors’ fees, attendance allowances and similar remuneration derived by a resident of a Contracting State as a member of a board of directors, supervisory board or similar organ of a company limited by shares resident in the other State may be taxed in that other State. This also applies to remuneration of a limited partner in a partnership limited by shares. § 2. Remuneration received by the persons in paragraph 1 in any other capacity shall be governed, according to its nature, by Article 14 or 15.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-17",
    "before": "Article 17. Entertainers and sportspersons. Notwithstanding the provisions of Articles 14 and 15, the rents obtained by the professionals of the spectacle, such as theatre, cinema, radio or television artists and musicians, as well as by sportsmen, for their personal activities in this regard, may be subject to taxation in the Contracting State in which they act.",
    "after": "Article 17. Entertainers and sportspersons. Notwithstanding Articles 14 and 15, income derived by professional entertainers such as theatre, motion picture, radio or television artistes and musicians, and by sportspersons, from their personal activities in that capacity may be taxed in the State where they perform.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-18",
    "before": "Article 18. Pensions. Without prejudice to the provisions of Article 19, pensions and similar remuneration paid, in consideration of previous employment, to a resident of a Contracting State, may only be taxed in that State.",
    "after": "Article 18. Pensions. Subject to Article 19, pensions and similar remuneration paid to a resident of a Contracting State for past employment shall be taxable only in that State.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-19",
    "before": "Article 19. Public benefits and pensions. §1. Remuneration, including pensions, paid by a Contracting State, one of its political subdivisions or local entities, either directly or from funds constituted by them, to a natural person in consideration of services provided to that State or to one of its political subdivisions or local entities, may be subject to taxation only in that State. This provision does not apply where the beneficiary of these income possesses the nationality of the other Contracting State without, at the same time, possessing the nationality of the first State. §2. Paragraph 1 does not apply to remuneration or pensions paid in consideration of services rendered, in a commercial or industrial activity carried out by a Contracting State or by a political subdivision or local entity of that State.",
    "after": "Article 19. Public remuneration and pensions. § 1. Remuneration, including pensions, paid by a Contracting State or one of its political subdivisions or local authorities, directly or from funds created by them, to an individual for services to that State, subdivision or authority shall be taxable only in that State. This does not apply where the recipient has the other State’s nationality without also having the first State’s nationality. § 2. Paragraph 1 does not apply to remuneration or pensions for services in a commercial or industrial activity carried on by a State or one of its political subdivisions or local authorities.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-20",
    "before": "Article 20. Teachers and students. 1. The remuneration of teachers and other members of teaching staff, residents of a Contracting State, who temporarily remain for a period not exceeding two years in the other Contracting State to teach or engage in scientific research at a university or other officially recognized scientific teaching or research institution, may be subject to taxation only in the first State. §2. The amounts which a student or a trainees, who is or has previously been a resident of a Contracting State and who is in the other Contracting State for the sole purpose of continuing his studies or completing his training, receive to cover his costs of maintenance, studies or training, shall not be subject to taxation in the latter State, provided that such amounts come from sources outside that State.",
    "after": "Article 20. Teachers and students. 1. Remuneration of teachers and other teaching staff resident in a Contracting State who stay temporarily for no more than two years in the other State to teach or carry out scientific research at a university or other officially recognised teaching or scientific research institution shall be taxable only in the first State. § 2. Payments received for maintenance, studies or training by a student or trainee who is or was formerly a resident of a Contracting State and is in the other State solely to pursue studies or complete training shall not be taxed in that other State, provided they arise from sources outside it.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-21",
    "before": "Article 21. Incomes not expressly mentioned. The income of a resident of a Contracting State, subject to taxation in that State and which is of a nature or comes from sources not mentioned in the previous articles of this Convention, may only be taxed in that State.\n[heading] IV. IMPOSITION ON THE PATRIMONY",
    "after": "Article 21. Income not expressly mentioned. Income of a resident of a Contracting State which is subject to tax there and is of a nature or from sources not mentioned in the preceding Articles shall be taxable only in that State.\nIV. TAXATION OF CAPITAL",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-22",
    "before": "Article 22 §1. Property constituted by immovable property, as defined in article 6, paragraph 2, may be taxed in the Contracting State in which the property is located. §2. Without prejudice to paragraph 3, assets consisting of movable property forming part of the assets of a permanent establishment of an undertaking, or movable property belonging to a fixed base used for the pursuit of a professional activity, may be taxed in the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment or fixed base is situated. § 3. Ships and aircraft operated in international traffic, as well as movable property affected by their operation, may be subject to taxation only in the Contracting State in which the place of effective management of the undertaking is situated. §4. All other assets of a resident of a Contracting State — including shareholdings — may only be taxed in that State.\n[heading] V. ARRANGEMENTS FOR AVOIDING DOUBLE IMPOSITION",
    "after": "Article 22. Capital. § 1. Capital represented by immovable property as defined in Article 6(2) may be taxed in the State where it is situated. § 2. Subject to paragraph 3, capital represented by movable property forming part of a permanent establishment’s business assets or pertaining to a fixed base used for professional activities may be taxed in the State where that establishment or base is situated. § 3. Ships and aircraft operated in international traffic and movable property pertaining to their operation shall be taxable only in the State where the enterprise’s place of effective management is situated. § 4. All other capital of a resident of a Contracting State, including interests in companies limited by shares, shall be taxable only in that State.\nV. AVOIDANCE OF DOUBLE TAXATION",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-23",
    "before": "Article 23 §1. Where a resident of a Contracting State obtains income not covered by paragraphs 3 and 4 below, which, in accordance with the provisions of the Convention, may be taxed in the other Contracting State, the former State shall exempt such income; but in order to calculate the tax corresponding to the remaining income of that resident, it may apply the tax rate which would correspond without such exemption. §2. Where, under the law of one Contracting State, losses suffered by a permanent establishment of an enterprise of that Contracting State, situated in the other State, have actually been deducted from the profits of the enterprise for taxation in the first State, the exemption provided for in paragraph 1 does not apply in that State, to the profits of that establishment corresponding to the other tax periods, to the extent that such profits have also been exempted in the other State for compensation for such losses. § 3. Without prejudice to the following paragraph 4, where a resident of a Contracting State obtains income which, in accordance with Article 10, paragraph 2; Article 11, paragraphs 2 and 7, or Article 12, paragraphs 2 and 6, may be subject to taxation in the other Contracting State, the first State shall grant, from the tax due on the said income by that resident, a deduction calculated on the amount of such income forming part of the taxable base of that resident and the rate of which shall not be lower than that of the tax levied on the said income in the other Contracting State, in accordance with Article 10, paragraph 2; Article 11, paragraph 2, or Article 12, paragraph 2, as the case may be. For residents of Spain, the provision of this paragraph applies to both general and account taxes. §4. Where a company resident of a Contracting State owns shares or shares in a company resident of the other Contracting State, the dividends paid to it by the latter company are subject in the first State for the purpose of applying the tax referred to in Article 2, paragraph 3, 1. or (b) or 2(b), as the case may be, under the same scheme as dividends paid by a company resident of the former State. § 5. For the purposes of applying paragraph 3 above, interest on a reduction in the Spanish tax, pursuant to Article 1° of the Decree-Law of 19 October 1961, which grants reductions on certain taxes applicable to loans issued by Spanish companies and loans granted to them by foreign financial institutions to finance new investments, is considered to have paid the tax provided for in Article 11, paragraph 2.\n[heading] VI. SPECIAL PROVISIONS",
    "after": "Article 23. Avoidance of double taxation. § 1. Where a resident of a Contracting State derives income outside paragraphs 3 and 4 which may be taxed in the other State under this Convention, the first State shall exempt it, but may apply to the resident’s remaining income the tax rate that would apply without that exemption. § 2. Where under a State’s law losses of an enterprise’s permanent establishment in the other State have actually been deducted from the enterprise’s profits for taxation in the first State, paragraph 1’s exemption shall not apply there to that establishment’s profits in other tax periods insofar as those profits have also been exempted in the other State by offset against those losses. § 3. Subject to paragraph 4, where a resident derives income taxable in the other State under Article 10(2), 11(2) and (7), or 12(2) and (6), the first State shall grant a deduction from the tax due on that income, calculated on the amount included in the resident’s taxable base, at a rate no lower than the rate of tax charged on that income in the other State under Article 10(2), 11(2) or 12(2), as applicable. For residents of Spain, this paragraph applies both to general taxes and to taxes on account. § 4. Where a company resident in a State owns shares or interests in a company resident in the other State, dividends paid by the latter to the former shall, for the tax mentioned in Article 2(3)(1)(b) or (2)(b), as applicable, receive in the first State the same treatment as dividends paid by a company resident there. § 5. For paragraph 3, interest benefiting from a Spanish tax reduction under Article 1 of the Decree-Law of 19 October 1961, granting reductions of specified taxes on borrowings issued by Spanish enterprises and loans granted to them by foreign financial institutions to finance new investments, shall be deemed to have borne the tax provided in Article 11(2).\nVI. SPECIAL PROVISIONS",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-24",
    "before": "Article 24. Non-discrimination. §1. Nationals of a Contracting State shall not be subject in the other Contracting State to any taxes or obligations relating thereto which are not or are more burdensome than those to which nationals of that Contracting State who are or may be subject under the same conditions are subject. §2. The term ‘national’ means: (a) all natural persons possessing the nationality of a Contracting State; (b) all legal persons, companies of persons and associations established under the laws in force in a Contracting State. § 3. Stateless persons shall not be subject in a Contracting State to any tax or obligation relating thereto, which is not required or more burdensome than those to which nationals of that State are or may be subject, who are in the same conditions. §4. A permanent establishment which an undertaking of one Contracting State has in the other Contracting State shall not be subject to taxation in that State in a less favourable manner than undertakings of the latter State carrying out the same activities. This provision does not oblige a Contracting State to grant to residents of the other Contracting State the personal deductions, allowances and tax reductions it grants to its own residents in view of their marital status or family burdens. This provision does not prevent profits attributable to the permanent establishment available in a Contracting State to a company resident of the other Contracting State or to a group of persons having its effective head office in the latter State from being subject to taxation in the first State at the rate fixed by its national law, provided that the latter does not exceed the maximum rate applicable to all or part of the profits of companies resident in the former State, § 5. Without prejudice to the provisions of Article 9, interest, royalties and any other expenses paid by an undertaking of one Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State may be deducted, for the purpose of determining the taxable profits of that Company, under the same conditions as if they had been paid to a resident of the former Contracting State. Similarly, debts owed by an undertaking of a Contracting State to a resident other than the Contracting State may be deducted for the purpose of determining the taxable assets of that undertaking under the same conditions as if they had been incurred with a resident of the former State. § 6. Undertakings of a Contracting State whose capital is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by one or more residents of the other Contracting State shall not be subject in the Contracting State referred to above to any tax or obligation relating thereto which is not or is more burdensome than those to which the like undertakings of the first Contracting State are or may be subject. § 7. The term ‘tax’ in this Article covers all taxes, whatever their nature or name.",
    "after": "Article 24. Non-discrimination. § 1. Nationals of a Contracting State shall not be subjected in the other State to taxation or connected requirements other or more burdensome than those to which nationals of that other State in the same circumstances are or may be subjected. § 2. “Nationals” means: (a) all individuals possessing a Contracting State’s nationality; (b) all legal persons, partnerships and associations constituted under the laws in force in a Contracting State. § 3. Stateless persons shall not be subjected in a Contracting State to taxation or connected requirements other or more burdensome than those to which its nationals in the same circumstances are or may be subjected. § 4. Taxation of an enterprise’s permanent establishment in the other State shall not be less favourable there than taxation of enterprises of that State carrying on the same activities. This does not oblige a State to grant residents of the other State personal deductions, allowances or tax reductions granted to its own residents for civil status or family responsibilities. It does not prevent profits attributable to a permanent establishment available in a State to a company resident in the other State, or a body of persons whose place of effective management is in that other State, being taxed in aggregate in the first State at the rate under its national law, provided it does not exceed the maximum rate applicable to all or part of the profits of companies resident in the first State. § 5. Subject to Article 9, interest, royalties and other expenses paid by an enterprise of a State to a resident of the other State may be deducted in determining its taxable profits under the same conditions as if paid to a resident of the first State. Similarly, its debts to a resident of the other Contracting State may be deducted in determining its taxable capital under the same conditions as if contracted with a resident of the first State. § 6. Enterprises of a State whose capital is wholly or partly owned or controlled, directly or indirectly, by residents of the other State shall not be subjected in the first State to taxation or connected requirements other or more burdensome than those to which similar enterprises of that first State are or may be subjected. § 7. “Taxation” in this Article includes taxes of every kind and description.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-25",
    "before": "Article 25. Mutual agreement procedure. §1. Where a resident of a Contracting State considers that the measures taken by one or both Contracting States imply or may entail for him a double taxation that is not in conformity with this Convention, irrespective of the remedies provided for by the national law of those States, he may address a written and reasoned request to the competent authority of the Contracting State of which he is resident requesting a review of this taxation. The application must be made within two years of notification or the requirement at the source of the second charge. §2. The competent authority referred to in paragraph 1, if the claim appears to it to be well founded and if it is not in a position to adopt a satisfactory solution, shall make every effort to resolve the matter by amicable agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State, in order to avoid double taxation not in conformity with this Convention. § 3. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall endeavour to resolve difficulties or to dispel doubts arising from the application of this Convention by amicable agreement. §4. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall agree on the administrative measures necessary for the implementation of the provisions of the Convention and in particular on the supporting documents to be submitted by the residents of each State in order to enjoy in the other State the tax exemptions or reductions provided for in this Convention.",
    "after": "Article 25. Mutual agreement procedure. § 1. A resident who considers that measures of one or both States result or may result in double taxation contrary to this Convention may, irrespective of national-law remedies, submit a written, reasoned request to the competent authority of the State of residence seeking review. It must be submitted within two years of notification or imposition at source of the second taxation. § 2. If the objection appears justified and that authority cannot itself reach a satisfactory solution, it shall endeavour to resolve the matter by mutual agreement with the other State’s competent authority to avoid double taxation contrary to this Convention. § 3. The competent authorities shall endeavour by mutual agreement to resolve difficulties or doubts arising from application of this Convention. § 4. They shall agree on administrative measures needed to implement it, particularly the evidence residents of each State must produce to obtain the exemptions or reductions in the other State.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-26",
    "before": "Article 26. Exchange of information. §1. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall exchange the information necessary for the application of this Convention and of the internal laws of the Contracting States relating to taxes covered by this Convention, to the extent that the taxation provided for therein is in accordance with the Convention. The information thus exchanged shall be kept secret and may not be disclosed, other than to the taxpayer or his representative, other than to the persons or authorities responsible for the settlement or collection of the taxes covered by this Agreement and for the settlement of claims and remedies relating thereto. §2. In no case shall the provisions of paragraph 1 oblige a Contracting State: (a) take administrative measures contrary to its legislation or administrative practice or those of the other Contracting State; (b) to provide information which cannot be obtained on the basis of their own legislation or normal administrative practice or that of the other Contracting State; (c) to transmit information revealing a commercial, industrial or professional secret or a commercial procedure, or information whose communication is contrary to public policy. 27 Other provisions. §1. The provisions of this Convention do not affect the tax privileges enjoyed by members of a diplomatic or consular mission, in accordance with the general principles of international law or under provisions of special agreements. §2. With regard to Belgian resident companies, the provisions of the Convention do not prevent them from being subject to taxation under Belgian law in the event of the purchase of their own shares or shares or division of share capital. § 3. The Ministers of Finance of the Contracting States or their delegates for this purpose may agree directly between themselves to fulfil the purposes provided for in the Convention.\n[heading]VII. FINAL PROVISIONS",
    "after": "Article 26. Exchange of information. § 1. The competent authorities shall exchange information necessary to apply this Convention and the States’ domestic laws concerning its covered taxes insofar as the taxation under those laws accords with the Convention. The information shall be kept secret and may be disclosed, apart from to the taxpayer or representative, only to persons or authorities concerned with assessment or collection of covered taxes and determination of related claims and appeals. § 2. Paragraph 1 shall in no case oblige a State to: (a) carry out administrative measures contrary to its law or administrative practice or those of the other State; (b) supply information not obtainable under its own law or normal administrative practice or those of the other State; (c) transmit information disclosing a trade, industrial or professional secret or commercial process, or information contrary to public policy. Article 27. Other provisions. § 1. This Convention does not affect tax privileges of members of diplomatic or consular missions under general international-law principles or special agreements. § 2. For Belgian resident companies, the Convention does not prevent taxation under Belgian law on purchase of their own shares or interests or division of share capital. § 3. The Ministers of Finance or their delegates for this purpose may communicate directly to fulfil the Convention’s aims.\nVII. FINAL PROVISIONS",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-28",
    "before": "Article 28. Entry into force. §1. This Convention shall be ratified and the instruments of ratification shall be exchanged in Madrid as soon as possible. §2. The Convention shall enter into force on the fifteenth day following the exchange of instruments of ratification, and its provisions shall apply: 1. or To source taxes on income paid or payable from 1 January of the year, in the course of which instruments of ratification are exchanged. 2. Other income taxes for tax periods ending on 31 December of the year in which instruments of ratification are exchanged. 3. However, paragraphs 1 and 2 above, in respect of article 8, to profits earned in closed accounting periods as from 31 December 1960.",
    "after": "Article 28. Entry into force. § 1. This Convention shall be ratified and the instruments of ratification exchanged at Madrid as soon as possible. § 2. It shall enter into force on the fifteenth day following exchange of the instruments, and apply: (1) To taxes accruing at source on income paid or payable on or after 1 January of the year in which the instruments are exchanged. (2) To other taxes on income for tax periods ending on or after 31 December of the year in which the instruments are exchanged. (3) Notwithstanding (1) and (2), in respect of Article 8, to profits earned in accounting periods ending on or after 31 December 1960.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1972-1535",
    "section": "art-29",
    "before": "Article 29. Termination. This Convention shall remain in force indefinitely; but each Contracting State may denounce it to the other Contracting State in writing and through diplomatic channels until 30 June, including any calendar year, from the fifth year of the exchange of instruments of ratification, If it is withdrawn before 1 July of that year, the Convention shall last apply: 1. To taxes accruing from the source on income paid or payable at the latest on 31 December of that year. 2. To other taxes required on income corresponding to tax periods ending at the latest on 30 December of the calendar year following that year. In faith, the Plenipotentiaries of States have signed and sealed this Convention. Done at Brussels, 24 September 1970, in duplicate, in the Spanish, French and Dutch languages, attesting to the three texts as well. For the Spanish State, For the Kingdom of Belgium, JAIME ALBA DELIBES PERRE HARMEL\n[heading] ADDITIONAL PROTOCOL At the time of the signing of the Convention to Prevent Double Taxation and to regulate certain matters relating to income and property taxes, concluded today between Spain and Belgium, the undersigned Plenipotentiaries have agreed on the following provisions, which form an integral part of this Convention: (1) Ad Article 2, § 3, 2. or : ‘The right of establishment’ in Spanish is included in sub-paragraph (f) of this provision. (2) Ad Article 3, § 1st, 1st: (a) In the event that the Belgian legal provisions are taken to this effect, the term ‘Belgium’ also covers the seabed and the subsoil of the North Sea, adjacent to the Belgian territorial sea, on which Belgium shall exercise sovereign rights of exploration and exploitation; in this case, the delimitation of this region shall be notified to Spain by diplomatic means, as soon as the agreements with the United Kingdom, France and Holland allow it to be established. (b) The term ‘Spain’ also includes any region adjacent to the territorial sea of Spain, which is or may subsequently be considered under the legislation of Spain concerning the continental shelf, as a region within whose limits the rights of Spain relating to the seabed and the subsoil of the underwater regions and their natural resources may be exercised. (3) Ad Article 4, first paragraph: The term ‘resident of a Contracting State’ also means companies — other than shares companies — which have chosen to subject their profits to the tax of natural persons. (4) Ad Article 11, § 4: Spain retains the right to tax on capital income tax, interest covered by sub-paragraph (b) of this provision, which is paid to the permanent establishment held by a Belgian company in Spain. (5) Ad Article 23, § 4: (a) With regard to dividends paid to a company resident in Belgium by a company resident in Spain, this provision does not preclude the enforceability of the transferable tax under Belgian law. (b) With regard to dividends paid to a company resident in Spain by a company resident in Belgium, this provision does not preclude the enforceability of Spanish capital income tax, it being understood that double taxation is avoided in accordance with Article 23, § 3. Therefore, having seen and examined the 29 articles that make up that Convention and its Additional Protocol, having heard the Committee on Treaties of the Spanish Courts, in compliance with article 14 of its Organic Law, I come to approve and ratify as provided for, as I hereby approve and ratify it, promising to comply with it, observe it and ensure that it is implemented and observed in a timely manner in all its parts, for the purpose of its further validation and firmness, Command to issue this instrument of ratification, signed by Me, duly sealed and endorsed by the undersigned Minister of Foreign Affairs. Given in Madrid on 28 May, one thousand nine hundred and seventy-one, FRANCE FRANCE The Minister for Foreign Affairs, GREGORIO LOPEZ BRAVO DE CASTRO The Exchange of Instruments of Ratification took place in Madrid on 23 September 1971. This Convention shall enter into force on 9 October 1972, in accordance with Article 28. What is made public for general knowledge. [ignore]Madrid, October 13, 1972.-The Technical General Secretary of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Enrique Thomas de Carranza.",
    "after": "Article 29. Termination. This Convention shall remain in force indefinitely; either State may give the other written notice of termination through diplomatic channels up to and including 30 June of any calendar year from the fifth year of exchange of the instruments of ratification. If notice is given before 1 July of that year, it shall apply for the last time: (1) To taxes accruing at source on income paid or payable no later than 31 December of that year. (2) To other taxes on income for tax periods ending no later than 30 December of the following calendar year. In witness whereof, the States’ Plenipotentiaries have signed and sealed this Convention. Done in duplicate at Brussels on 24 September 1970 in Spanish, French and Dutch, all three texts being equally authentic. For the Spanish State: JAIME ALBA DELIBES. For the Kingdom of Belgium: PIERRE HARMEL.\nADDITIONAL PROTOCOL At the signing of the Convention concluded today between Spain and Belgium for the avoidance of double taxation and regulation of certain matters concerning taxes on income and on capital, the signatory Plenipotentiaries agreed upon the following provisions forming an integral part of it: (1) With reference to Article 2, § 3, (2): the Spanish “arbitrio de radicación” (business-location levy) is included in subparagraph (f) of that provision. (2) With reference to Article 3, § 1, (1): (a) if Belgian legislation is enacted to that effect, “Belgium” shall also include the seabed and subsoil of the North Sea adjacent to its territorial sea over which it will exercise sovereign exploration and exploitation rights. The area’s delimitation shall then be notified to Spain diplomatically as soon as agreements with the United Kingdom, France and the Netherlands permit it to be established; (b) “Spain” also includes any area adjacent to its territorial sea which is or may later be considered under its continental-shelf law an area within which Spain may exercise rights over the seabed, subsoil and natural resources of submarine areas. (3) With reference to Article 4, § 1: “resident of a Contracting State” also means companies other than companies limited by shares which have elected to subject their profits to tax on individuals. (4) With reference to Article 11, § 4: Spain retains the right to levy capital income tax on interest under subparagraph (b) paid to a Belgian enterprise’s permanent establishment in Spain. (5) With reference to Article 23, § 4: (a) for dividends paid by a Spanish resident company to a Belgian resident company, this does not prevent Belgian withholding tax on movable income becoming due under Belgian law; (b) for dividends paid by a Belgian resident company to a Spanish resident company, it does not prevent Spanish capital income tax becoming due, it being understood that double taxation is avoided under Article 23, § 3. Therefore, having seen and examined the Convention’s 29 Articles and its Additional Protocol, and having heard the Treaties Committee of the Cortes Españolas under Article 14 of its Organic Law, I approve and ratify all their provisions, as I hereby do approve and ratify them, undertaking to comply with and observe them and ensure their full and exact compliance and observance. To give them greater validity and force, I order the issue of this Instrument of Ratification, signed by Me, duly sealed and countersigned by the undersigned Minister for Foreign Affairs. Given at Madrid on 28 May 1971. FRANCISCO FRANCO. The Minister for Foreign Affairs: GREGORIO LÓPEZ BRAVO DE CASTRO. The instruments of ratification were exchanged at Madrid on 23 September 1972. This Convention shall enter into force on 8 October 1972 under Article 28. Published for general information. Madrid, 13 October 1972. The Technical Secretary-General of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs: Enrique Thomas de Carranza.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1973-325",
    "section": "preamble",
    "before": "Two errors in the text submitted for the publication of the instrument of ratification of the Convention between Spain and Belgium to prevent double taxation and to regulate certain matters relating to income and property taxes, done at Brussels on 24 September 1970 (Official Gazette of the State No 258 of 27 October 1972), are reproduced below: For: ‘The exchange of instruments of ratification took place in Madrid on 23 September 1971’, read: ‘The exchange of instruments of ratification took place in Madrid on 23 September 1972’. For: ‘This Convention shall enter into force on 9 October 1972 in accordance with Article 28’, read: ‘This Convention shall enter into force on 8 October 1972, in accordance with Article 28’. What is made public for general knowledge. Madrid, 22 February 1973.—The Technical Secretary General, Enrique Thomas de Carranza.",
    "after": "Two errors having been found in the text submitted for publication of the Instrument of Ratification of the Convention between Spain and Belgium for the avoidance of double taxation and regulation of certain matters concerning taxes on income and on capital, done at Brussels on 24 September 1970 (BOE No. 258 of 27 October 1972), the following corrections are made: For “The instruments of ratification were exchanged at Madrid on 23 September 1971”, read “The instruments of ratification were exchanged at Madrid on 23 September 1972”. For “This Convention shall enter into force on 9 October 1972 under Article 28”, read “This Convention shall enter into force on 8 October 1972 under Article 28”. Published for general information. Madrid, 22 February 1973. The Technical Secretary-General: Enrique Thomas de Carranza.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "preamble",
    "before": "JUAN CARLOS I KING OF SPAIN For what? on 6 March 1990, the Plenipotentiary of Spain signed in Sofia, together with the Plenipotentiary of the People's Republic of Bulgaria, the Convention between Spain and the People's Republic of Bulgaria on the prevention of double taxation and tax evasion in respect of income and property taxes, Viewed and examined the twenty-seven articles of the Convention and the Protocol thereto, Granted by the Cortes Generales the authorization provided for in Article 94.1 of the Constitution, I come to approve and ratify what it provides for, as I hereby approve and ratify it, promising to comply with it, observe it and ensure that it is fulfilled and observed in a timely manner in all its parts, to the end of which, for further validation and firmness, I order issue this Instrument of Ratification signed by Me, duly sealed and endorsed by the undersigned Minister for Foreign Affairs. Done at Madrid on 14 June 1991. JUAN CARLOS R. The Minister for Foreign Affairs, FRANCISCO FERNÁNDEZ ORDÓÑEZ CONVENTION BETWEEN SPAIN AND THE POPULARY REPUBLIC OF BULGARIA TO AVOID DOUBLE IMPOSITION AND PREVENT TAX EVASION ON RENT AND PATRIMONY IMPOSSES The Kingdom of Spain and the People's Republic of Bulgaria, driven by the desire to promote and strengthen economic relations and economic cooperation between the two countries, wishing to conclude a convention to prevent double taxation and to prevent tax evasion in the area of income and property taxes, have agreed as follows:",
    "after": "JUAN CARLOS I — KING OF SPAIN Whereas on 6 March 1990 the Plenipotentiary of Spain signed at Sofia, together with the Plenipotentiary of the People’s Republic of Bulgaria, both duly appointed for that purpose, the Convention between Spain and the People’s Republic of Bulgaria for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with respect to Taxes on Income and on Capital; Having seen and examined the Convention’s twenty-seven Articles and its Protocol; the Cortes Generales having granted the authorisation under Article 94.1 of the Constitution; I approve and ratify all its provisions, as I hereby do approve and ratify them, undertaking to comply with and observe them and to ensure their full and exact compliance and observance. To give them greater validity and force, I order the issue of this Instrument of Ratification, signed by Me, duly sealed and countersigned by the undersigned Minister for Foreign Affairs. Given at Madrid on 14 June 1991. JUAN CARLOS R. The Minister for Foreign Affairs: FRANCISCO FERNÁNDEZ ORDÓÑEZ. CONVENTION BETWEEN SPAIN AND THE PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF BULGARIA FOR THE AVOIDANCE OF DOUBLE TAXATION AND THE PREVENTION OF FISCAL EVASION WITH RESPECT TO TAXES ON INCOME AND ON CAPITAL The Kingdom of Spain and the People’s Republic of Bulgaria, wishing to promote and strengthen economic relations and cooperation between the two countries and to conclude a Convention for the avoidance of double taxation and prevention of fiscal evasion with respect to taxes on income and on capital, have agreed as follows:",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-1",
    "before": "Article 1. Personal scope. 1. This Convention applies to persons resident in one or both Contracting States. 2. For the purposes of this Convention, the following are considered residents: (a) In the case of Bulgaria, natural persons who are nationals of the People's Republic of Bulgaria and legal persons who have their head office in Bulgaria or who are registered there. (b) In the case of Spain, persons who are subject to taxation under Spanish law in Spain by reason of their domicile, residence, address or any other criterion of a similar nature. 3. Where, under the provisions of paragraph 2, a natural person is resident in both Contracting States, he or she shall be considered a resident of the State with which he or she has closer personal and economic relations (centre of vital interests). 4. If the State in which that person has the centre of his vital interests cannot be determined, the competent authorities of the Contracting States shall settle the case by amicable agreement. 5. Where under the provisions of paragraph 2, a person other than a natural person is a resident of both Contracting States, he or she shall be considered a resident of the State in which his or her place of effective management is located.",
    "after": "Article 1. Scope as regards persons. 1. This Convention shall apply to persons who are residents of one or both Contracting States. 2. For this Convention, residents are: (a) in Bulgaria, individuals who are nationals of the People’s Republic of Bulgaria and legal persons having their head office in Bulgaria or registered there; (b) in Spain, persons liable to tax in Spain under Spanish law by reason of domicile, residence, place of management or any similar criterion. 3. Where paragraph 2 makes an individual a resident of both States, that individual shall be deemed a resident of the State with which personal and economic relations are closer (centre of vital interests). 4. If that State cannot be determined, the competent authorities shall settle the case by mutual agreement. 5. Where paragraph 2 makes a person other than an individual a resident of both States, that person shall be deemed a resident of the State in which its place of effective management is situated.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-2",
    "before": "Article 2. Taxes covered. 1. This Convention applies to income and property taxes payable by each of the Contracting States. 2. The current taxes to which this Convention specifically applies are: (a) In Spain: (i) Personal Income Tax; (ii) Corporate tax; (iii) Property Tax; and (iv) Local income and property taxes. (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Spanish tax’). (b) Bulgaria: (i) Total income tax; (ii) Income Tax for single persons, widows, divorced persons and spouses without children; (iii) Profit Tax; and (iv) Building Tax. (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Bulgarian tax’). 3. This Convention shall also apply to taxes of an identical or similar nature which are established after the date of signature of this Convention and which are added to or replaced by current taxes. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall notify each other of any relevant amendments to their respective tax laws. If the competent authorities of the two Contracting States disagree on the application of the first sentence of this paragraph, discussions will begin on whether to amend the Convention for the inclusion of the new tax in question.",
    "after": "Article 2. Taxes covered. 1. This Convention shall apply to taxes on income and on capital imposed by either Contracting State. 2. The existing taxes to which it specifically applies are: (a) In Spain: (i) personal income tax; (ii) corporation tax; (iii) capital tax; (iv) local taxes on income and capital (hereinafter “Spanish tax”). (b) In Bulgaria: (i) total income tax; (ii) income tax on single, widowed and divorced persons and spouses without children; (iii) profits tax; (iv) buildings tax (hereinafter “Bulgarian tax”). 3. The Convention also applies to identical or substantially similar taxes imposed after signature in addition to or in place of the existing taxes. The competent authorities shall notify each other of relevant changes in their tax laws. If they disagree on application of the first sentence, discussions shall begin on whether to amend the Convention to include the new tax.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-3",
    "before": "Article 3. General definitions. 1. For the purposes of this Convention, unless the context of the Convention is different: (a) The term ‘Spain’ means the territory of the Spanish State, including any area outside its territorial sea in which the Spanish State, under international law and under its domestic law, exercises or may exercise in the future sovereign jurisdiction or rights. (b) The term ‘Bulgaria’ means the territory of the People's Republic of Bulgaria to which the sovereignty of the State extends, as well as the continental shelf over which the People's Republic of Bulgaria exercises sovereign rights under international law. (c) The terms ‘one Contracting State’ and ‘the other Contracting State’ mean Spain or Bulgaria, depending on the context. (d) The term ‘person’ includes natural persons, groups of persons, legal persons, including Companies, and any Entity that is considered a legal person for tax purposes. (e) The terms ‘Company of one Contracting State’ and ‘Company of the other Contracting State’ mean, respectively, an Enterprise operated by a resident of a Contracting State and an Enterprise operated by a resident of the other Contracting State. (f) “International traffic” means any transport carried out by a ship, aircraft or road transport vehicle operated by an Enterprise whose place of effective management is located in a Contracting State, except where the ship, aircraft or road transport vehicle is operated only between points situated in the other Contracting State. (g) ‘competent authority’ means: (i) In the case of Spain, the Minister of Economy and Finance or any other authority to which the Minister delegates. (ii) In the case of Bulgaria, the Minister of Finance or his authorized representative. 2. For the purposes of the application of this Convention by a Contracting State, any expression not defined in this Convention shall have, unless its context indicates a different interpretation, the meaning attributed to it by the law of that Contracting State concerning taxes which are the subject of the Convention.",
    "after": "Article 3. General definitions. 1. Unless the context otherwise requires: (a) “Spain” means the Spanish State’s territory, including any area beyond its territorial sea in which it exercises or may in future exercise jurisdiction or sovereign rights under international law and its domestic law. (b) “Bulgaria” means the territory of the People’s Republic of Bulgaria to which State sovereignty extends and the continental shelf over which it exercises sovereign rights under international law. (c) “A Contracting State” and “the other Contracting State” mean Spain or Bulgaria as the context requires. (d) “Person” includes individuals, bodies of persons, legal persons including companies, and any entity treated as a legal person for tax purposes. (e) “Enterprise of a Contracting State” and “enterprise of the other Contracting State” mean respectively an enterprise carried on by a resident of a Contracting State and one carried on by a resident of the other State. (f) “International traffic” means any transport by a ship, aircraft or road transport vehicle operated by an enterprise whose place of effective management is in a Contracting State, except operation solely between places in the other State. (g) “Competent authority” means: (i) in Spain, the Minister for the Economy and Finance or any authority to whom the Minister delegates; (ii) in Bulgaria, the Minister of Finance or authorised representative. 2. For application by a Contracting State, an undefined term shall, unless the context otherwise requires, have the meaning it has under that State’s law concerning the taxes covered by the Convention.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-4",
    "before": "Article 4. Permanent establishment. 1. For the purposes of this Convention, the term ‘permanent establishment’ means a fixed place where a resident of a Contracting State carries out all or part of his business activity in the other Contracting State. 2. The term ‘permanent establishment’ includes, in particular: (a) Management offices. (b) Branches. (c) Offices. (d) Factories. (e) Workshops. (f) Mines, oil or gas wells, quarries or any other natural resource extraction site. 3. Construction, installation or assembly works constitute a permanent establishment only if their duration exceeds 12 months. 4. The participation of a resident in Spain in a joint venture, constituted in accordance with Bulgarian law, shall be regarded as a permanent establishment situated in the People's Republic of Bulgaria. 5. Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article, it is considered that the term ‘permanent establishment’ does not include: (a) The use of facilities for the sole purpose of storing, displaying or delivering goods or goods belonging to the Enterprise. (b) The maintenance of a warehouse of goods or goods belonging to the Enterprise for the sole purpose of storing, displaying or delivering them. (c) The maintenance of a warehouse of goods exhibited by the Company at a trade fair or exhibition intended for sale at its closure. (d) The maintenance of a deposit of goods or goods belonging to the Enterprise for the sole purpose of their processing by another Company. (e) The maintenance of a fixed place of business for the sole purpose of purchasing goods or goods or collecting information for the Enterprise. (f) The maintenance of a fixed place of business for the sole purpose of carrying out, for the enterprise, any other activity of an auxiliary or preparatory nature. (g) The maintenance of a fixed place of business for the sole purpose of the combined exercise of the activities referred to in subparagraphs (a) to (f), provided that the activity of the fixed place of business as a whole retains its auxiliary or preparatory character. 6. By way of derogation from paragraphs 1 and 2, where a person, other than an agent enjoying an independent status to whom paragraph 7 applies, acts on behalf of an undertaking and habitually exercises in a contracting State powers to conclude contracts on behalf of the undertaking, that undertaking shall be deemed to have a permanent establishment in that State in respect of all activities carried out by that person on behalf of the undertaking, unless the activities of that person are limited to those referred to in paragraph 5 which, if carried out through a fixed place of business, have not determined that such place of business should be regarded as a permanent establishment in accordance with the provisions of that paragraph. 7. An Enterprise is not considered to have a permanent establishment in a Contracting State merely because it carries out activities in that State through a broker, a general commissioner or any other agent enjoying an independent status, provided that such persons act within the ordinary framework of their activity. 8. The fact that a company resident of a Contracting State participates in a company of the other Contracting State, or engages in activities in that other State (whether by permanent establishment or otherwise), does not in itself make any of the companies a permanent establishment of the other State.",
    "after": "Article 4. Permanent establishment. 1. “Permanent establishment” means a fixed place where a resident of a Contracting State carries on all or part of business activities in the other Contracting State. 2. It includes in particular: (a) places of management; (b) branches; (c) offices; (d) factories; (e) workshops; (f) mines, oil or gas wells, quarries or other places of extracting natural resources. 3. Construction, installation or assembly projects constitute a permanent establishment only if they last more than twelve months. 4. Participation by a resident of Spain in a joint venture constituted under Bulgarian law shall be regarded as a permanent establishment in the People’s Republic of Bulgaria. 5. Notwithstanding the preceding provisions, the term does not include: (a) facilities used solely to store, display or deliver goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise; (b) a stock of such goods or merchandise maintained solely for storage, display or delivery; (c) a stock of merchandise displayed by the enterprise at a trade fair or exhibition for sale at its close; (d) a stock of goods or merchandise maintained solely for processing by another enterprise; (e) a fixed place maintained solely to purchase goods or merchandise or collect information for the enterprise; (f) a fixed place maintained solely for any other preparatory or auxiliary activity for the enterprise; (g) a fixed place maintained solely for a combination of (a) to (f), provided its overall activity remains preparatory or auxiliary. 6. Notwithstanding paragraphs 1 and 2, a person other than an independent agent covered by paragraph 7 acting for an enterprise who has and habitually exercises in a State authority to conclude contracts in its name shall cause the enterprise to be deemed to have a permanent establishment there for all activities undertaken for it, unless those activities are limited to paragraph 5 activities which, if carried on through a fixed place, would not make it a permanent establishment under that paragraph. 7. An enterprise shall not be deemed to have a permanent establishment in a State merely because it operates there through a broker, general commission agent or other independent agent acting in the ordinary course of business. 8. A company resident in a State participating in a company of the other State, or carrying on business there through a permanent establishment or otherwise, does not of itself make either company a permanent establishment of the other.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-5",
    "before": "Article 5. Income from immovable property. 1. The income that a resident of one Contracting State obtains from immovable property situated in the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State. 2. The term ‘real property’ shall have the meaning attributed to it by the law of the Contracting State in which the goods in question are situated.",
    "after": "Article 5. Income from immovable property. 1. Income derived by a resident of a Contracting State from immovable property situated in the other State may be taxed in that other State. 2. “Immovable property” shall have the meaning under the law of the State where the property is situated.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-6",
    "before": "Article 6. Business profits. 1. The profits of an Enterprise of a Contracting State may be taxed only by that State, unless the Enterprise carries out its business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated therein. If the Enterprise does so, the profits of the Enterprise may be taxed in the other State, but only to the extent that they can be attributed to that permanent establishment. 2. Without prejudice to the provisions of paragraph 3, where an Enterprise of one Contracting State carries out its activity in the other Contracting State by means of a permanent establishment situated therein, in each Contracting State the profits which it would have obtained from being a separate and separate Enterprise carrying out the same or similar activities under the same or similar conditions and dealing entirely independently with the Enterprise from which it is a permanent establishment shall be attributed to that establishment. 3. The determination of the benefits of the permanent establishment shall allow the deduction of the expenses incurred for the realization of the purposes of the permanent establishment, including management expenses and general administration expenses for the same purposes, whether incurred in the State in which the permanent establishment is located or elsewhere. 4. Benefits shall not be attributed to a permanent establishment merely because it purchases goods or goods for the Enterprise. 5. Where profits include regular income separately in other articles of this Convention, the provisions of those articles shall not be affected by those of this Article.",
    "after": "Article 6. Business profits. 1. Profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State shall be taxable only in that State unless it carries on business in the other State through a permanent establishment there. If it does, its profits may be taxed there only to the extent attributable to that establishment. 2. Subject to paragraph 3, each State shall attribute to that permanent establishment the profits it might earn as a distinct and separate enterprise carrying on the same or similar activities under the same or similar conditions and dealing wholly independently with the enterprise of which it is a permanent establishment. 3. Expenses incurred for its purposes, including executive and general administrative expenses for those purposes, shall be deductible in determining its profits, whether incurred in the State where it is situated or elsewhere. 4. No profits shall be attributed merely because the establishment purchases goods or merchandise for the enterprise. 5. Where profits include income dealt with separately in other Articles, those Articles shall not be affected by this Article.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-7",
    "before": "Article 7. International transport. 1. The profits from operating ships, aircraft or road transport vehicles in international traffic may be taxed only in the Contracting State in which the effective head office of the Enterprise is located. 2. If the place of effective management of a Navigational Enterprise is on board a ship, it shall be deemed to be in the Contracting State where the base port of the ship is located, and if there is no such base port, in the Contracting State of which the person operating the ship is resident. 3. The provisions of paragraph 1 also apply to the benefits of participation in a pool, on a joint holding or in an international holding body.",
    "after": "Article 7. International transport. 1. Profits from operating ships, aircraft or road transport vehicles in international traffic shall be taxable only in the State where the enterprise’s place of effective management is situated. 2. If a shipping enterprise’s place of effective management is aboard a ship, it shall be deemed situated in the State of its home harbour or, if none, in the State of which the operator is a resident. 3. Paragraph 1 also applies to profits from participation in a pool, joint business or international operating agency.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-8",
    "before": "Article 8. Dividends. 1. Dividends paid by a Company resident of one Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State. 2. However, such dividends may also be subject to taxation in the Contracting State of which the dividend paying company is resident and in accordance with the law of that State, but if the dividend receiving company is its beneficial owner, the tax thus required may not exceed: (a) 5 per cent of the gross amount of dividends if the beneficial owner is a company, excluding the Companies of Persons (Partnerships), which owns directly or indirectly at least 25 per cent of the company's capital that pays the dividends; (b) 15 per cent of the gross amount of dividends in other cases. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall, by common agreement, determine how these limits are to be applied. This paragraph does not affect the company's taxation of the profits from which dividends are paid. 3. The term ‘dividends’ used in this Article means the income from shares, as well as the income from other social shares subject to the same tax regime as the income from shares under the law of the State of which the distribution company is resident. 4. The provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 do not apply if the beneficial owner of the dividends resident in one Contracting State, in the other Contracting State, from which the Company paying the dividends is resident, is an industrial or commercial activity through a permanent establishment located in that other State or provides independent personal services through a fixed base situated therein, and to which the share generated by the dividends is effectively linked. In such a case, the provisions of article 6 or article 12, as appropriate, apply. 5. Where a Company resident of a Contracting State obtains profits or income from another Contracting State, that other State may not require any tax on dividends paid by the Company, except to the extent that such dividends are paid to a resident of that other State, or the share generated by the dividends is effectively linked to a permanent establishment or a fixed base situated in that other State, or subject the undistributed profits of the Society to a tax on them, even if dividends paid or undistributed profits consist, in whole or in part, of profits or income from that other State.",
    "after": "Article 8. Dividends. 1. Dividends paid by a company resident in a Contracting State to a resident of the other State may be taxed in that other State. 2. They may also be taxed under the law of the paying company’s State of residence, but if the recipient is their beneficial owner the tax so charged shall not exceed: (a) 5 per cent of gross dividends if the beneficial owner is a company, excluding partnerships, directly or indirectly owning at least 25 per cent of the paying company’s capital; (b) 15 per cent of gross dividends in other cases. The competent authorities shall agree how these limits are applied. This does not affect taxation of the company on the profits out of which dividends are paid. 3. “Dividends” means income from shares and from other corporate interests subject to the same tax treatment as share income under the paying company’s State of residence law. 4. Paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not apply if the beneficial owner, resident in a State, carries on an industrial or commercial activity in the other State of which the paying company is resident through a permanent establishment there, or performs independent personal services through a fixed base there, and the holding generating the dividends is effectively connected with that establishment or base. Article 6 or 12, as appropriate, then applies. 5. Where a resident company derives profits or income from the other State, that other State may not tax dividends paid by it except insofar as they are paid to a resident of that other State or the holding is effectively connected with a permanent establishment or fixed base there; nor may it tax the company’s undistributed profits, even if the dividends paid or undistributed profits consist wholly or partly of profits or income from that other State.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-9",
    "before": "Article 9. Interest. 1. Interest from one Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed only in that other State. 2. The term ‘interest’ used in this Article means income from claims of any kind, with or without a mortgage guarantee or a benefit-sharing clause of the debtor, and in particular income from public funds and bonds or bonds, including premiums and lots attached to such securities. Penalties for late payment are not considered interest for the purposes of this article. 3. The provisions of paragraph 1 shall not apply if the beneficial owner of the interest, resident of a Contracting State, performs in the other Contracting State, from which the interest is derived, an industrial or commercial activity through a permanent establishment situated in that other State or provides independent personal services through a fixed base situated therein, and the credit generated by the interest is effectively linked to that permanent establishment or fixed base. In such a case, the provisions of article 6 or article 12, as appropriate, apply.",
    "after": "Article 9. Interest. 1. Interest arising in a Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other State shall be taxable only in that other State. 2. “Interest” means income from debt-claims of every kind, secured by mortgage or not, carrying a right to participate in the debtor’s profits or not, and particularly income from government securities and bonds or debentures, including premiums and prizes attaching to them. Penalties for late payment are not interest for this Article. 3. Paragraph 1 shall not apply if the beneficial owner, resident in a State, carries on an industrial or commercial activity in the source State through a permanent establishment there or performs independent personal services through a fixed base there, and the debt-claim generating the interest is effectively connected with that establishment or base. Article 6 or 12, as appropriate, then applies.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-10",
    "before": "Article 10. Royalties. 1. Fees from one Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed only in that other State. 2. The term ‘royalties’ used in this Article means the quantities of any kind received for the use, or right to use, of copyright, patents, trademarks, designs, formulas or secret procedures, as well as for the use, or right to use, of industrial, commercial or scientific equipment and information relating to industrial, commercial or scientific experiences, and includes quantities of any kind paid for by film and video films or tapes for use in connection with television. 3. The provisions of paragraph 1 do not apply if the beneficial owner of the royalties, resident in a Contracting State, carries out in the other Contracting State from which the royalties come an industrial or commercial activity by means of a permanent establishment situated in that other Contracting State or provides independent personal services through a fixed base situated therein, and the right or for which the royalties are paid is effectively linked to that permanent establishment or fixed base. In such a case, the provisions of article 6 or article 12, as appropriate, apply.",
    "after": "Article 10. Royalties. 1. Royalties arising in a Contracting State and paid to a resident of the other State shall be taxable only in that other State. 2. “Royalties” means payments of any kind received for the use of, or the right to use, copyright, patents, trademarks, designs or models, plans, secret formulae or processes; industrial, commercial or scientific equipment; and information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience. It includes payments of any kind for cinematograph films and films or videotapes for use in connection with television. 3. Paragraph 1 shall not apply if the beneficial owner, resident in a State, carries on an industrial or commercial activity in the source State through a permanent establishment there or performs independent personal services through a fixed base there, and the right or property generating the royalties is effectively connected with that establishment or base. Article 6 or 12, as appropriate, then applies.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-11",
    "before": "Article 11. Capital gains. 1. Profits that a resident of one Contracting State obtains from the disposal of immovable property, as defined in Article 5, located in the other Contracting State, may be taxed in that other State. 2. Gains from the disposal of movable property forming part of the assets of a permanent establishment held by an Enterprise of one Contracting State in the other Contracting State, or from movable property having a fixed basis that a resident of one Contracting State has in the other Contracting State for the provision of independent personal services, including gains from the disposal of such permanent establishment (only or with the enterprise as a whole) or from that fixed basis, may be taxed in that other State. 3. Profits resulting from the disposal of ships, aircraft or road transport vehicles operated in international traffic, or from movable property affected by the operation of such ships, aircraft or road transport vehicles, may only be taxed in the Contracting State where the effective head office of the Enterprise is located. 4. Profits resulting from the disposal of any goods other than those referred to in paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 may be taxed only in the Contracting State of which the transferor is resident.",
    "after": "Article 11. Capital gains. 1. Gains derived by a resident of a State from alienating immovable property, as defined in Article 5, situated in the other State may be taxed there. 2. Gains from alienating movable property forming part of the assets of an enterprise’s permanent establishment in the other State, or pertaining to a fixed base available to a resident in the other State for independent personal services, including gains from alienating that establishment, alone or with the whole enterprise, or that fixed base, may be taxed in that other State. 3. Gains from alienating ships, aircraft or road transport vehicles operated in international traffic, or movable property pertaining to their operation, shall be taxable only in the State where the enterprise’s place of effective management is situated. 4. Gains from alienating any other property shall be taxable only in the transferor’s State of residence.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-12",
    "before": "Article 12. Professional services. 1. Revenues obtained by a resident of a Contracting State from the provision of professional services and other activities of an independent nature may only be taxed in that State unless such resident normally has a fixed basis for carrying out his or her activities in the other Contracting State. If it has such a fixed base, income may be taxed in that other State, but only to the extent that it can be attributed to that fixed base. 2. The term “professional services” includes, in particular, independent scientific, literary, artistic, educational or pedagogical activities, as well as independent activities of Physicians, Lawyers, Engineers, Architects, Dentistry and Accountants.",
    "after": "Article 12. Professional services. 1. Income derived by a resident of a State from professional services or other independent activities shall be taxable only in that State unless a fixed base is habitually available in the other State for those activities. If so, the income may be taxed there only to the extent attributable to that fixed base. 2. “Professional services” includes in particular independent scientific, literary, artistic, educational or teaching activities and those of physicians, lawyers, engineers, architects, dentists and accountants.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-13",
    "before": "Article 13. Salaries and salaries. 1. Without prejudice to the provisions of articles 14, 16 and 17, salaries, wages and similar remuneration obtained by a resident of a Contracting State on account of employment may be subject to taxation only in that State, unless the employment is exercised in the other Contracting State. If the employment is exercised there, the remuneration received for this purpose may be subject to taxation in that other State. 2. Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, remunerations obtained by a resident of a Contracting State on the basis of employment in the other Contracting State may be taxed only in the State referred to above if: (a) The recipient does not remain in total in that other State, for one or more periods, more than one hundred and eighty-three days during the fiscal year concerned; (b) Remuneration is paid by, or on behalf of, an employer who is not a resident of the other State; and (c) Remuneration is not borne by a permanent establishment or a fixed basis which the employer has in the other State. 3. Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this Article, remunerations obtained on account of employment on board a ship, aircraft or road transport vehicle operated in international traffic may be taxed in the Contracting State in which the effective head office of the Enterprise is situated. 4. Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this Article, remunerations obtained by a resident of a Contracting State on the basis of employment in the other Contracting State may be subject to taxation in the State referred to first in the first three years of employment in that other State only if: (a) Employment is exercised in a representation that is not commercial or industrial in nature; (b) Remuneration is paid by an employer resident of the above-mentioned State; and (c) Remuneration is not borne by a permanent establishment held by the employer in that other State.",
    "after": "Article 13. Salaries and wages. 1. Subject to Articles 14, 16 and 17, salaries, wages and similar remuneration derived by a resident of a State from employment shall be taxable only there unless the employment is exercised in the other State. If so exercised, the remuneration may be taxed in that other State. 2. Notwithstanding paragraph 1, remuneration for employment exercised in the other State shall be taxable only in the first-mentioned State if: (a) the recipient is present in the other State for one or more periods not exceeding in total 183 days during the fiscal year concerned; (b) the remuneration is paid by or on behalf of an employer not resident in the other State; and (c) it is not borne by a permanent establishment or fixed base the employer has there. 3. Notwithstanding the preceding provisions, remuneration for employment aboard a ship, aircraft or road transport vehicle operated in international traffic may be taxed in the State where the enterprise’s place of effective management is situated. 4. Notwithstanding the preceding provisions, remuneration derived by a resident from employment exercised in the other State shall be taxable only in the first-mentioned State during the first three years of employment there if: (a) the employment is exercised in a representative office not commercial or industrial in character; (b) the remuneration is paid by an employer resident in the first-mentioned State; and (c) it is not borne by a permanent establishment the employer has in the other State.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-14",
    "before": "Article 14. Directors’ fees. Participations, attendance allowances and other similar remunerations which a resident of a Contracting State obtains as a member of a Board of Directors and similar body of a Company resident of the other Contracting State may be subject to taxation in that other State.",
    "after": "Article 14. Directors’ fees. Directors’ fees, attendance allowances and similar remuneration derived by a resident of a State as a member of a board of directors or similar organ of a company resident in the other State may be taxed in that other State.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-15",
    "before": "Article 15. Entertainers and sportspersons. 1. Notwithstanding the provisions of Articles 12 and 13, any income which a resident of a Contracting State obtains from the exercise of his personal activity in the other Contracting State, as a performing artist, theatre, cinema, radio or television actor or musician, or as an athlete, may be subject to taxation in that other State. 2. Where the income obtained from personal activities carried out by an artist or athlete as such is attributed not to the artist or athlete himself, but to another person, such income may, notwithstanding the provisions of Articles 6, 12 and 13, be subject to taxation in the Contracting State in which the activities of the artist or athlete are carried out. 3. Income obtained by artists or sportsmen resident in a Contracting State on account of their activities in the other Contracting State as a result of cultural exchanges carried out within the framework of cultural agreements signed by the two Contracting States or of intergovernmental cooperation programmes in cultural or sporting matters may be taxed only in the Contracting State mentioned above.",
    "after": "Article 15. Entertainers and sportspersons. 1. Notwithstanding Articles 12 and 13, income derived by a resident from personal activities in the other State as an entertainer, theatre, motion picture, radio or television actor, musician or sportsperson may be taxed in that other State. 2. Where income from personal activities exercised by an entertainer or sportsperson in that capacity accrues to another person, it may, notwithstanding Articles 6, 12 and 13, be taxed in the State where the activities are exercised. 3. Income derived by entertainers or sportspersons resident in a State from activities in the other State resulting from cultural exchanges under cultural agreements signed by both States or intergovernmental programmes of cultural or sporting cooperation shall be taxable only in the first-mentioned State.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-16",
    "before": "Article 16. Pensions. Without prejudice to the provisions of Article 17(2), pensions and other similar remuneration paid to a resident of a Contracting State on account of previous employment may only be taxed in that State.",
    "after": "Article 16. Pensions. Subject to Article 17(2), pensions and similar remuneration paid to a resident of a State for past employment shall be taxable only in that State.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-17",
    "before": "Article 17. Public functions. 1. (a) Remuneration, with the exception of pensions, paid by a Contracting State or one of its political subdivisions or local entities to a natural person, for the purpose of services rendered to that State or to that subdivision or entity, may be subject to taxation only in that State. (b) Such remuneration may, however, be subject to taxation in the other Contracting State only if the services are provided in that State and the natural person is a resident of that State who: (i) possesses the nationality of that State; or (ii) It has not acquired the resident status of that State only for the provision of services. 2. (a) Pensions paid by a Contracting State or one of its political subdivisions or local entities, either directly or from constituted funds, to a natural person on account of services rendered to that State or to that subdivision or entity may be subject to taxation in that State only. (b) However, such pensions may be subject to taxation in the other Contracting State only if the natural person is a resident and national of that other State. 3. The provisions of Articles 13, 14 and 16 apply to remuneration and pensions paid for services rendered in the context of an industrial or commercial activity carried out by a Contracting State or one of its political subdivisions or local entities.",
    "after": "Article 17. Government service. 1. (a) Remuneration other than pensions paid by a State or one of its political subdivisions or local authorities to an individual for services to it shall be taxable only in that State. (b) However, it shall be taxable only in the other State if services are rendered there and the individual is a resident there who: (i) is its national; or (ii) did not become a resident solely to render the services. 2. (a) Pensions paid by a State or one of its political subdivisions or local authorities, directly or from funds created, to an individual for services to it shall be taxable only in that State. (b) However, they shall be taxable only in the other State if the individual is its resident and national. 3. Articles 13, 14 and 16 apply to remuneration and pensions for services in an industrial or commercial activity carried on by a State, political subdivision or local authority.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-18",
    "before": "Article 18. Teachers and students. 1. Education professionals who visit a Contracting State for a period not exceeding two years, for the purpose of teaching or conducting research at a University or other officially recognized educational institution of that Contracting State and who are residents of the other Contracting State, shall be exempt from taxation in the Contracting State referred to above in respect of the remuneration of such education or research. This paragraph shall not apply to income derived from research where it is not in the public interest, but primarily for the private benefit of a particular person or persons. 2. The amounts received to cover their costs of maintenance, study or practical training, a student or a person in practice who visits a Contracting State for the sole purpose of conducting studies or acquiring practical training and who is a resident of the other Contracting State, may not be taxed in the State referred to in the first instance, provided that such payments come from sources outside that State.",
    "after": "Article 18. Teachers and students. 1. Teaching professionals visiting a State for no more than two years to teach or research at its university or other officially recognised educational institution, who are residents of the other State, shall be exempt in the first-mentioned State on remuneration for that teaching or research. This does not apply to research income where the research is undertaken primarily for a particular person’s or persons’ private benefit rather than in the public interest. 2. Payments for maintenance, studies or practical training received by a student or trainee visiting a State solely to study or obtain practical training, who is a resident of the other State, shall not be taxed in the first-mentioned State if they arise from sources outside it.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-19",
    "before": "Article 19. Other income. The income of a resident of a Contracting State, whatever its source, not mentioned in the previous articles of this Convention, may be taxed only in that State.",
    "after": "Article 19. Other income. Income of a resident of a State, wherever arising, not mentioned in the preceding Articles shall be taxable only in that State.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-20",
    "before": "Article 20. Capital. 1. Property constituted by immovable property as defined in Article 5, belonging to a resident of one Contracting State and situated in the other Contracting State, may be taxed in that other State. 2. Property consisting of movable property forming part of the assets of a permanent establishment which an Enterprise of one Contracting State has in the other Contracting State, or of movable property having a fixed basis that a resident of one Contracting State has in the other Contracting State for the provision of professional services, may be taxed in the Contracting State in which the permanent establishment or the fixed base is situated. 3. Assets consisting of ships, aircraft or road transport vehicles operated in international traffic, as well as movable property affected by the operation of such vessels, aircraft or road transport vehicles, may be subject to taxation only in the Contracting State in which the effective head office of the Enterprise is situated. 4. All other assets of a resident of a Contracting State may be subject to taxation only in that State.",
    "after": "Article 20. Capital. 1. Capital represented by immovable property as defined in Article 5 owned by a resident of a State and situated in the other State may be taxed in that other State. 2. Capital represented by movable property forming part of the business assets of an enterprise’s permanent establishment in the other State or pertaining to a fixed base available to a resident in the other State for professional services may be taxed in the State where that establishment or base is situated. 3. Capital represented by ships, aircraft or road transport vehicles operated in international traffic and movable property pertaining to their operation shall be taxable only in the State where the enterprise’s place of effective management is situated. 4. All other capital of a resident of a State shall be taxable only in that State.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-21",
    "before": "Article 21. Elimination of double taxation. 1. In Spain double taxation will be avoided as follows: (a) Where a resident of Spain obtains income or possesses assets which, in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, may be taxed in Bulgaria, Spain shall permit: (i) The deduction of the income tax of that resident from an amount equal to the tax paid in Bulgaria. (ii) The deduction of the property tax of that resident from an amount equal to the property tax paid in Bulgaria. However, in either case, such deduction may not exceed the part of the Income or Property Tax calculated before making the corresponding deduction, as the case may be, to the income or assets which may be taxed in Bulgaria. (b) Where, in accordance with any provision of the Convention, the income obtained by a resident of Spain or the assets he possesses are exempt from taxation in Spain, Spain may, however, take into account the income or assets exempted for the purpose of calculating the amount of the tax on the rest of the income or assets of that resident. 2. In Bulgaria, double taxation will be avoided as follows: (a) Where a resident of Bulgaria obtains income or possesses assets which, in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, may be taxed in Spain, Bulgaria shall exempt such income or property from taxation. (b) However, the exempt income or wealth may be taken into account for the purposes of calculating the amount of the tax on the rest of the income or assets of that resident. (c) Notwithstanding the provisions of subparagraphs (a) and (b), where a resident of Bulgaria obtains dividends which, in accordance with the provisions of Article 8, may be taxed in Spain, Bulgaria shall allow an amount equivalent to the tax paid in Spain to be deducted from the income tax of that resident. However, this deduction may not exceed the part of the tax, calculated before deduction, corresponding to the income obtained in Spain.",
    "after": "Article 21. Elimination of double taxation. 1. In Spain double taxation shall be avoided as follows: (a) Where a resident of Spain derives income or owns capital taxable in Bulgaria under this Convention, Spain shall allow: (i) a deduction from that resident’s income tax of an amount equal to the tax paid in Bulgaria; (ii) a deduction from that resident’s capital tax of an amount equal to the capital tax paid in Bulgaria. In each case the deduction shall not exceed the part of the income or capital tax, computed before deduction, attributable to the income or capital taxable in Bulgaria. (b) Where this Convention exempts a Spanish resident’s income or capital from Spanish tax, Spain may nevertheless take it into account in calculating tax on the remaining income or capital. 2. In Bulgaria double taxation shall be avoided as follows: (a) Where a resident of Bulgaria derives income or owns capital taxable in Spain under this Convention, Bulgaria shall exempt it from tax. (b) The exempt income or capital may nevertheless be taken into account in calculating tax on the resident’s remaining income or capital. (c) Notwithstanding (a) and (b), where a Bulgarian resident derives dividends taxable in Spain under Article 8, Bulgaria shall allow a deduction from that resident’s income tax of an amount equal to the tax paid in Spain. It shall not exceed the part of the tax, computed before deduction, attributable to the income derived in Spain.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-22",
    "before": "Article 22. Non-discrimination. 1. Nationals of a Contracting State shall not be subject in the other Contracting State to any taxes or obligations relating thereto which are not or are more onerous than those to which nationals of that other State who are under the same conditions are or may be subject. Notwithstanding the provisions of article 1, this provision shall also apply to nationals of any of the Contracting States who are not residents of any of them. This paragraph shall also apply to legal persons or other entities which derive their status as such from the legislation in force in a Contracting State. 2. Permanent establishments held by an Enterprise of one Contracting State in the other Contracting State shall not be subject to taxation in that State in a less favourable manner than undertakings of that other State carrying out the same activities. This provision may not be interpreted as obliging a Contracting State to grant to residents of the other Contracting State the personal deductions, reliefs and tax reductions it grants to its own residents in consideration of their civil state or family burdens. 3. Undertakings of a Contracting State in which one or more residents of the other Contracting State participate shall not be subject in the State referred to above to any taxes or obligations relating thereto which are not or are more onerous than those to which other similar undertakings of the State referred to above are or may be subject. 4. Interest, royalties and other expenses paid by an Enterprise of one Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State shall be deductible, in order to determine the profits subject to taxation of that undertaking, under the same conditions as if they had been paid to a resident of the State referred to in the first instance. Similarly, the debts of an enterprise of one Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State shall be deductible for the determination of the assets subject to taxation of that Company under the same conditions as if they had been contracted with a resident of the State referred to in the first instance. 5. Notwithstanding the provisions of Article 2, the provisions of this Article are subject to all taxes irrespective of their nature or name.",
    "after": "Article 22. Non-discrimination. 1. Nationals of a State shall not be subjected in the other State to taxation or connected requirements other or more burdensome than those imposed or imposable on its nationals in the same circumstances. Notwithstanding Article 1, this also applies to nationals of either State resident in neither. It also applies to legal persons or other entities deriving their status from a State’s law in force. 2. Taxation of an enterprise’s permanent establishment in the other State shall not be less favourable than taxation of that State’s enterprises carrying on the same activities. This does not oblige a State to grant residents of the other State personal deductions, reliefs or tax reductions granted to its residents for civil status or family responsibilities. 3. Enterprises of a State in which residents of the other State participate shall not be subjected in the first State to taxation or connected requirements other or more burdensome than those imposed or imposable on similar enterprises of that first State. 4. Interest, royalties and other expenses paid by an enterprise of a State to a resident of the other State shall be deductible in determining its taxable profits under the same conditions as if paid to a resident of the first State. Similarly, debts contracted with a resident of the other State shall be deductible in determining its taxable capital under the same conditions as if contracted with a resident of the first State. 5. Notwithstanding Article 2, this Article applies to taxes of every kind and description.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-23",
    "before": "Article 23. Mutual agreement procedure. 1. Where a resident of a Contracting State considers that the measures taken by one or both Contracting States imply or may entail for him an imposition that is not in conformity with the provisions of this Convention, irrespective of the remedies provided for by the domestic law of those States, he may submit his case to the competent authority of the Contracting State of which he is resident, or, if Article 22 (1) applies, to that of the Contracting State of which he is a national. The case shall be brought within three years of the first notification of the measure involving an imposition not in accordance with the provisions of this Convention. 2. The competent authority, if it considers the complaint well founded, and if it is not in a position to adopt a satisfactory solution, shall endeavour to resolve the matter by amicable agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting State, in order to avoid a position not in conformity with the Convention. 3. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall endeavour to resolve difficulties or to dispel doubts arising from the interpretation or application of the Convention by amicable agreement. They may also agree to try to avoid double taxation in cases not covered by the Convention. 4. The competent authorities of the Contracting States may communicate directly with each other in order to reach agreement on the terms of the preceding paragraphs. Where it is considered that this agreement may be facilitated by personal contacts, the exchange of views may take place within a committee composed of representatives of the competent authorities of the Contracting States.",
    "after": "Article 23. Mutual agreement procedure. 1. A resident who considers that actions by one or both States result or may result in taxation contrary to this Convention may, irrespective of domestic-law remedies, present the case to the competent authority of the State of residence or, if Article 22(1) applies, the State of nationality. The case must be presented within three years of first notification of the action resulting in taxation contrary to the Convention. 2. If the objection appears justified and the authority cannot itself reach a satisfactory solution, it shall endeavour to resolve the matter by mutual agreement with the other State’s authority to avoid taxation contrary to the Convention. 3. The competent authorities shall endeavour by mutual agreement to resolve difficulties or doubts concerning interpretation or application. They may also consult to avoid double taxation in cases not provided for in the Convention. 4. They may communicate directly to reach agreement under these paragraphs. If personal contacts may facilitate agreement, views may be exchanged in a commission of their representatives.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-24",
    "before": "Article 24. Exchange of information. 1. The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall exchange the information necessary to implement the provisions of this Convention or of the domestic law of the Contracting States relating to taxes covered by the Convention, to the extent that the taxation required under that Convention is not contrary to the Convention. The exchange of information is not limited by Article 1. Information received by a Contracting State shall be kept secret in the same way as information obtained under the national law of that State and shall be communicated only to the persons or authorities (including the judicial authorities) responsible for the management or collection of taxes covered by the Convention, to the declaratory or executive procedures relating to such taxes or to the resolution of appeals relating thereto. Such persons or authorities shall use the information only for such purposes. 2. In no case may the provisions of paragraph 1 be interpreted as obliging a Contracting State to: (a) To take administrative measures contrary to its legislation or administrative practice or those of the other Contracting State. (b) Provide information that cannot be obtained on the basis of its own legislation or in the exercise of its normal administrative practice or that of the other Contracting State. (c) Provide information revealing a commercial, industrial or professional secret or a commercial procedure or information whose communication is contrary to public policy.",
    "after": "Article 24. Exchange of information. 1. The competent authorities shall exchange information necessary to apply this Convention or the States’ domestic laws concerning the taxes it covers insofar as taxation under those laws is not contrary to it. Exchange is not restricted by Article 1. Information received shall be kept secret in the same manner as information obtained under domestic law and disclosed only to persons or authorities, including judicial authorities, concerned with assessment or collection of covered taxes, declaratory or enforcement proceedings concerning them, or determination of related appeals. They shall use the information only for those purposes. 2. Paragraph 1 shall in no case oblige a State to: (a) take administrative measures contrary to its law or administrative practice or those of the other State; (b) supply information not obtainable under its law or normal administrative practice or those of the other State; (c) supply information disclosing a trade, industrial or professional secret or commercial process, or information whose disclosure is contrary to public policy.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-25",
    "before": "Article 25. Members of diplomatic or consular missions. The provisions of this Convention do not affect the tax privileges of members of diplomatic and consular missions recognized under the general principles of international law or the provisions of special agreements.",
    "after": "Article 25. Members of diplomatic or consular missions. This Convention does not affect tax privileges of members of diplomatic and consular missions recognised under general principles of international law or special agreements.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-26",
    "before": "Article 26. Entry into force. 1. This Convention will be ratified and instruments of ratification will be exchanged in Madrid as soon as possible. 2. This Convention shall enter into force at the time of the exchange of instruments of ratification and its provisions shall take effect with respect to taxes relating to tax periods beginning on or after 1 January of the calendar year following the year in which the Convention enters into force.",
    "after": "Article 26. Entry into force. 1. This Convention shall be ratified and the instruments of ratification exchanged at Madrid as soon as possible. 2. It shall enter into force on exchange of the instruments and take effect for taxes relating to tax periods beginning on or after 1 January of the calendar year following its entry into force.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "art-27",
    "before": "Article 27. Termination. This Convention shall remain in force until it is denounced by one of the Contracting States. Any Contracting State may denounce the Convention by diplomatic notification at least six months before the end of any calendar year after a period of three years from the date of entry into force of the Convention. In such a case, the Convention shall cease to have effect in respect of taxes relating to tax periods beginning on or after 1 January of the calendar year following that in which the complaint occurred.",
    "after": "Article 27. Termination. This Convention shall remain in force until terminated by a Contracting State. Either State may give diplomatic notice of termination at least six months before the end of any calendar year after a period of three years from entry into force. It shall then cease to have effect for taxes relating to tax periods beginning on or after 1 January of the calendar year following that in which notice is given.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-18006",
    "section": "protocol",
    "before": "PROTOCOL At the time of the signing of the Convention between Spain and the People's Republic of Bulgaria on the prevention of double taxation and tax evasion in the area of income and property taxes, the undersigned have agreed on the following provisions which form an integral part of the Convention. 1. The participation of a resident of Spain in a Joint Venture referred to in Article 4(4) means participation in socially constituted enterprises having the status of a legal person established under Decree 535/80 of the Council of State of the People's Republic of Bulgaria. 2. In the case of Spain, Article 8(2) shall not apply to the income attributable, whether distributed or not, to the shareholders of the Companies and Entities referred to in Article 12(2) of Law 44/1978 of 8 September and Article 19 of Law 61/1978 of 27 December, as long as that income is not subject to Spanish Company Tax. Such income may be taxed in Spain under its domestic law. 3. In order to promote economic cooperation between the two Contracting States, the competent authorities of the two Contracting States, in cases where, in order to promote economic development, a reduced rate of taxation is established in respect of the rate in force generally in a Contracting State, shall determine by amicable agreement, notwithstanding the provisions of Article 21, the method of avoiding double taxation which contributes to that purpose. 4. Each Contracting State shall apply its domestic transfer pricing legislation. Any dispute arising in this matter shall be settled by mutual agreement procedure. In testimony of which the undersigned, duly authorized to do so, sign this Protocol. Done at Sofia on 6 March 1990 in duplicate in the Spanish and Bulgarian languages, both texts being equally authentic. For the Kingdom of Spain, For the People's Republic of Bulgaria, FRANCIS FERNÁNDEZ ORDOÑEZ, BOYKO DIMITROV, Minister for Foreign Affairs Minister for Foreign Affairs This Convention entered into force on 14 June 1991, the date of the exchange of instruments of ratification, as set out in Article 26.2. What is made public for general knowledge. Madrid, 18 June 1991. Acting Technical Secretary General Aquilino González Hernando.",
    "after": "PROTOCOL At the signing of the Convention between Spain and the People’s Republic of Bulgaria for the avoidance of double taxation and prevention of fiscal evasion with respect to taxes on income and on capital, the undersigned agreed upon the following provisions forming an integral part of it: 1. Participation by a Spanish resident in a joint venture under Article 4(4) means participation in enterprises constituted in corporate form with legal personality under Decree 535/80 of the Council of State of the People’s Republic of Bulgaria. 2. For Spain, Article 8(2) shall not apply to income attributable, distributed or not, to shareholders of the companies and entities under Article 12.2 of Law 44/1978 of 8 September and Article 19 of Law 61/1978 of 27 December insofar as it is not subject to Spanish corporation tax. It may be taxed in Spain under domestic law. 3. To promote economic cooperation, where a reduced tax rate compared with the generally applicable rate is established in a State to encourage economic development, the competent authorities shall determine by mutual agreement, notwithstanding Article 21, a method of avoiding double taxation contributing to that purpose. 4. Each State shall apply its domestic transfer-pricing law. Disputes arising in that matter shall be resolved by mutual agreement procedure. In witness whereof, the undersigned, duly authorised, have signed this Protocol. Done in duplicate at Sofia on 6 March 1990 in Spanish and Bulgarian, both texts being equally authentic. For the Kingdom of Spain: FRANCISCO FERNÁNDEZ ORDÓÑEZ, Minister for Foreign Affairs. For the People’s Republic of Bulgaria: BOYKO DIMITROV, Minister for Foreign Affairs. The Convention entered into force on 14 June 1991, the date of exchange of the instruments of ratification, under Article 26.2. Published for general information. Madrid, 18 June 1991. Acting Technical Secretary-General: Aquilino González Hernando.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-1991-23675",
    "section": "preamble",
    "before": "Mistakes in the publication of the Convention between Spain and the People's Republic of Bulgaria on the prevention of double taxation and tax evasion in the field of income and property taxes and the Protocol forming an integral part thereof, done at Sofia on 6 March 1990, inserted in the Official Gazette of the State No. 166 of 12 July 1991 (pages 23243-23247), are then corrected accordingly: Article 1.3, second line, which states: ‘resident in both’, should read ‘resident in both’. Article 2, second line, which reads: “and heritage”, should read: “and heritage”. Article 4.4. first line, where it says. ‘resident in Spain’ should read ‘resident in Spain’. Article 6.1. second line, which reads: ‘imposition of that State’, should read ‘imposition in that State’. Article 6.5, first line, which reads: ‘regular grants’, should read ‘regulated grants’. Article 8.4, second line, for ‘resident dividend’, read ‘resident dividend’. Article 8.5. second line, which reads: 'of another State', should read 'of the other State'. Article 12.1, second line, reading: 'professionals and others', should read 'professionals or others'. Article 14, third line, reading: ‘Administration and organ’, should read ‘Administration. or organ’. Article 14, fourth line, which states: ‘contractor may’, should read ‘contractor may’. Article 15(2), second line, where it reads: ‘attribute no’, should read ‘attribute no’. Article 16, third indent, where it reads: ‘previous only’, should read ‘previous only’. Article 17(2)(a), fourth line, which reads ‘or Entity only’, should read ‘or Entity only’. Article 20(1), third line, where it reads: ‘situated in the other’, should read ‘situated in the other’. Article 20(3), fourth line, which states: ‘by road only’, should read ‘by road only’. Article 21(2)(e), second line, which reads: ‘dividends from’ means ‘dividends from’. Article 22(5), second line, where it reads: ‘applicable’. Article 23(2), fifth line, which states: ‘a position’ means ‘an imposition’. Article 24(1), fourth line: replace the Spanish words “relativos a” (plural) with “relativo a” (singular). Article 24(1), first line, which reads: ‘taxes or taxes’, should read ‘taxes, or taxes’. Protocol 3, fourth line, for: ‘are established’, should read ‘is established’.",
    "after": "Errors having occurred in the publication of the Convention between Spain and the People’s Republic of Bulgaria for the avoidance of double taxation and prevention of fiscal evasion with respect to taxes on income and on capital and its integral Protocol, done at Sofia on 6 March 1990, in BOE No. 166 of 12 July 1991 (pages 23243–23247), the following corrections are made: Article 1.3, second line: for “residente en ambos”, read “residente de ambos”. [English explanation: resident in both → resident of both.] Article 2, second line: for “y el patrimonio”, read “y sobre el patrimonio”. [English explanation: and capital → and on capital.] Article 4.4, first line: for “residente en España”, read “residente de España”. [English explanation: resident in Spain → resident of Spain.] Article 6.1, second line: for “imposición de ese Estado”, read “imposición en ese Estado”. [English explanation: taxation of that State → taxation in that State.] Article 6.5, first line: for “rentas regulares”, read “rentas reguladas”. [English explanation: regular income → income dealt with.] Article 8.4, second line: for “dividendos residente”, read “dividendos, residente”. [English explanation: comma inserted after dividends.] Article 8.5, second line: for “de otro Estado”, read “del otro Estado”. [English explanation: from another State → from the other State.] Article 12.1, second line: for “profesionales y otras”, read “profesionales u otras”. [English explanation: professional services and other → professional services or other.] Article 14, third line: for “Administración y órgano”, read “Administración. u órgano”. [English explanation: and → or; printed replacement also contains a full stop after Administración.] Article 14, fourth line: for “contratante pueden”, read “contratante, pueden”. [English explanation: comma inserted after Contracting.] Article 15.2, second line: for “atribuyan no”, read “atribuyan, no”. [English explanation: comma inserted before not.] Article 16, third line: for “anterior solamente”, read “anterior, solamente”. [English explanation: comma inserted before only.] Article 17.2(a), fourth line: for “o Entidad sólo”, read “o Entidad, sólo”. [English explanation: comma inserted before only.] Article 20.1, third line: for “situado en el otro”, read “situados en el otro”. [English explanation: situated changed from singular to plural in Spanish.] Article 20.3, fourth line: for “por carretera solamente”, read “por carretera, solamente”. [English explanation: comma inserted before only.] Article 21.2(e), second line: for “dividendos que, de”, read “dividendos que de”. [English explanation: comma deleted after que; the printed cross-reference (e) is retained.] Article 22.5, second line: for “alicables”, read “aplicables”. [English explanation: misspelling corrected to applicable.] Article 23.2, fifth line: for “una posición”, read “una imposición”. [English explanation: a position → taxation.] Article 24.1, fourth line: for “relativos a”, read “relativo a”. [English explanation: relative changed from plural to singular in Spanish.] Article 24.1, third-last line: for “impuestos o de la”, read “impuestos, o de la”. [English explanation: comma inserted after taxes.] Protocol 3, fourth line: for “se establezcan”, read “se establezca”. [English explanation: are established → is established.]",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  },
  {
    "document": "BOE-A-2010-9956",
    "section": "preamble",
    "before": "By virtue of the Exchange of Verbal Notes between the Kingdom of Spain and the Republic of Armenia concerning the non-application in relations between the two countries of the Convention on the Prevention of Double Taxation between Spain and the USSR, signed in Madrid on 1 March 1985, done at Madrid on 6 June 2006 and 10 October 2007, the said Convention is not in force since the latter date. What is made public for general knowledge. Madrid, June 16, 2010. –The Technical Secretary General of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Cooperation, Antonio Cosano Pérez.",
    "after": "Under the exchange of notes verbales between the Kingdom of Spain and the Republic of Armenia concerning non-application in their bilateral relations of the Spain–USSR Convention for the avoidance of double taxation signed at Madrid on 1 March 1985, effected at Madrid on 6 June 2006 and 10 October 2007, that Convention has not been in force between the two countries since the latter date. Published for general information. Madrid, 16 June 2010. The Technical Secretary-General of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Cooperation: Antonio Cosano Pérez.",
    "reason": "Complete source-checked replacement; legal conditions, omissions, terminology, timing and source issues are explained in document-specific source questions.",
    "occurrences": 1
  }
]