The participation exemption
Law 27/2014, article 21: the exemption for dividends from, and gains on the sale of, holdings of at least 5 per cent held for a year, the 10 per cent foreign tax test and its treaty presumption, the 5 per cent of the exempt amount taxed as deemed management costs, losses on exempt holdings, and the three-year exception for small groups that set up a new subsidiary.
Why Spanish holding structures work
Article 21 is the reason a Spanish company can sit above operating subsidiaries without paying tax twice. Dividends from, and gains on selling, a holding of at least 5 per cent kept for a year are exempt — for a foreign subsidiary, provided it pays foreign tax at a nominal rate of at least 10 per cent, which is presumed for any treaty country. Two features catch people. Since 2021 only 95 per cent of the exempt income is actually exempt: paragraph 10 treats 5 per cent as management costs, so at the 25 per cent rate the effective charge is 1.25 per cent. And losses on a holding that would qualify for the exemption are not deductible either.
Title IV. The tax base
Chapter III. Exemptions
Article 21. Exemption for dividends and income from the transfer of securities representing the equity of entities resident and not resident in Spanish territory
1. Dividends or shares in profits of entities shall be exempt where the following requirements are met:
a) That the percentage holding, direct or indirect, in the capital or equity of the entity is at least 5 per cent.
The corresponding holding must be held without interruption during the year before the day on which the profit distributed becomes payable or, failing that, must be maintained subsequently for the time necessary to complete that period. In computing the period, the time during which the holding has been held without interruption by other entities meeting the circumstances referred to in article 42 of the Commercial Code to form part of the same group of companies, regardless of residence and of the obligation to draw up consolidated annual accounts, shall also be taken into account.
Where the investee entity obtains dividends, shares in profits or income from the transfer of securities representing the capital or equity of entities in more than 70 per cent of its income, the application of this exemption in respect of that income shall require the taxpayer to have an indirect holding in those entities meeting the requirements indicated in this letter. That percentage of income shall be calculated on the consolidated result for the financial year where the directly held entity is the parent of a group according to the criteria established in article 42 of the Commercial Code and draws up consolidated annual accounts. Nevertheless, the indirect holding in second- or lower-tier subsidiaries must respect the minimum percentage of 5 per cent, unless those subsidiaries meet the circumstances referred to in article 42 of the Commercial Code to form part of the same group of companies with the directly held entity and draw up consolidated accounting statements.
The requirement in the preceding paragraph shall not apply where the taxpayer shows that the dividends or shares in profits received have been included in the tax base of the directly or indirectly held entity as dividends, shares in profits or income from the transfer of securities representing the capital or equity of entities without being entitled to apply an exemption or a deduction for double taxation.
b) In addition, in the case of holdings in the capital or equity of entities not resident in Spanish territory, that the investee entity has been subject to, and not exempt from, a foreign tax of an identical or similar nature to this Tax at a nominal rate of at least 10 per cent in the financial year in which the profits distributed or shared in were obtained, regardless of the application of any exemption, rebate, reduction or deduction on them.
For these purposes, foreign taxes whose purpose has been to tax the income obtained by the investee entity shall be taken into account, regardless of whether the object of the tax is income, revenue or any other element indicative of it.
This requirement shall be deemed met where the investee entity is resident in a country with which Spain has signed a convention for the avoidance of international double taxation, which applies to it and contains an exchange of information clause.
In no case shall this requirement be deemed met where the investee entity is resident in a country or territory classified as a tax haven, unless it is resident in a Member State of the European Union and the taxpayer shows that its incorporation and operation respond to valid economic reasons and that it carries on economic activities.
Where the non-resident investee entity obtains dividends, shares in profits or income from the transfer of securities representing the capital or equity of entities, the application of this exemption in respect of that income shall require the requirement provided for in this letter to be met, at least, in the indirectly held entity.
Where the investee entity, whether or not resident in Spanish territory, obtains dividends, shares in profits or income from the transfer of securities representing the capital or equity of entities from two or more entities in respect of which the requirements indicated in letters a) or a) and b) above are met only in some of them, the application of the exemption shall refer to that part of the dividends or shares in profits received by the taxpayer in respect of entities in which those requirements are met.
The exemption provided for in this paragraph shall not apply in respect of the amount of those dividends or shares in profits whose distribution generates a tax-deductible expense in the paying entity.
For the application of this article, in the case of distribution of reserves, the designation contained in the corporate resolution shall be followed and, failing that, the last amounts credited to those reserves shall be deemed applied.
2. 1.º Dividends or shares in profits shall mean those arising from securities representing the capital or equity of entities, regardless of their accounting treatment.
2.º The remuneration corresponding to participating loans granted by entities forming part of the same group of companies according to the criteria established in article 42 of the Commercial Code, regardless of residence and of the obligation to draw up consolidated annual accounts, shall be regarded as exempt dividends or shares in profits, unless they generate a tax-deductible expense in the paying entity.
3.º The exemption provided for in paragraph 1 of this article shall not apply in relation to dividends or shares in profits received whose amount must be delivered to another entity under a contract relating to the securities from which they derive, an expense being recorded for that purpose.
The entity receiving that amount under that contract may apply the exemption provided for in that paragraph 1 to the extent that the following requirements are met:
a) That it retains the accounting record of those securities.
b) That it proves that the dividend has been received by the other contracting entity or an entity belonging to the same group of companies as either of the two entities, in the terms established in article 42 of the Commercial Code.
c) That the conditions established in the preceding paragraph for the application of the exemption are met.
3. Positive income obtained on the transfer of the holding in an entity shall be exempt where the requirements established in paragraph 1 of this article are met. The same regime shall apply to income obtained in cases of liquidation of the entity, withdrawal of the member, merger, total or partial division, reduction of capital, non-cash contribution or global transfer of assets and liabilities.
The requirement provided for in letter a) of paragraph 1 of this article must be met on the day on which the transfer takes place. The requirement provided for in letter b) of paragraph 1 must be met in each and every one of the financial years during which the holding is held.
Nevertheless, where the requirement provided for in letter b) of paragraph 1 was not met in one or more of the financial years during which the holding was held, the exemption provided for in this paragraph shall apply in accordance with the following rules:
a) In respect of that part of the income corresponding to a net increase in undistributed profits generated by the investee entity during the period of holding, that part corresponding to the profits generated in those financial years in which the requirement established in letter b) of paragraph 1 is met shall be regarded as exempt.
b) In respect of that part of the income not corresponding to a net increase in undistributed profits generated by the investee entity during the period of holding, it shall be deemed to have been generated on a straight-line basis, save proof to the contrary, during the period of holding, that part being regarded as exempt which corresponds proportionally to the holding in the financial years in which the requirement established in letter b) of paragraph 1 was met.
In the case of the transfer of the holding in the capital or equity of an entity, resident or not resident in Spanish territory, which in turn held two or more entities in respect of which the requirements provided for in letters a) or b) of paragraph 1 were met only in some of them, the exemption provided for in this paragraph shall apply in accordance with the following rules:
1.º In respect of that part of the income corresponding to a net increase in undistributed profits generated by the indirectly held entities during the period of holding, that part of the income corresponding to the profits generated by the entities in which the requirement established in letter b) of paragraph 1 is met shall be regarded as exempt.
2.º In respect of that part of the income not corresponding to a net increase in undistributed profits generated by the indirectly held entities during the period of holding, that part attributable proportionally to the entities in which the requirement established in letter b) of paragraph 1 has been met shall be regarded as exempt.
The part of the income not entitled to the exemption in the terms indicated in this paragraph shall be included in the tax base, with entitlement to the deduction established in article 31 of this Act where it applies, provided that the requirements necessary for it are met. Nevertheless, for the purposes of letter a) of paragraph 1 of that article, only the actual amount paid abroad by reason of a tax of an identical or similar nature to this Tax shall be taken, for the part corresponding proportionally to the income not entitled to the exemption corresponding to those financial years or entities in respect of which the requirement established in letter b) of paragraph 1 of this article has not been met, in relation to the total income obtained on the transfer of the holding.
4. In the following cases, the application of the exemption provided for in the preceding paragraph shall have the special features indicated below:
a) Where the holding in the entity had been valued in accordance with the rules of the special regime of Chapter VII of Title VII of this Act and the application of those rules had resulted in income not being included in the tax base of this Tax, or of Non-Resident Income Tax, arising from:
1.ª The contribution of the holding in an entity that does not meet the requirement of letter a) or, in whole or in part at least in some financial year, the requirement referred to in letter b) of paragraph 1 of this article.
2.ª The non-cash contribution of asset items other than holdings in the capital or equity of entities.
In this case, the exemption shall not apply to the income deferred in the transferring entity as a result of the contribution transaction, unless it is shown that the acquiring entity has included that income in its tax base.
b) Where the holding in the entity had been valued in accordance with the rules of the special regime of Chapter VII of Title VII of this Act and the application of those rules had resulted in income not being included in the tax base of Personal Income Tax, arising from the contribution of holdings in entities.
In this case, where those holdings are transferred in the two years after the date on which the contribution transaction was carried out, the exemption shall not apply to the positive difference between the tax value of the holdings received by the acquiring entity and the market value at the time of their acquisition, unless it is shown that the natural persons have transferred their holding in the entity during that period.
5. The exemption provided for in paragraph 3 of this article shall not apply:
a) To that part of the income from the transfer of the holding, direct or indirect, in an entity that is an asset-holding entity, in the terms established in paragraph 2 of article 5 of this Act, which does not correspond to an increase in undistributed profits generated by the investee entity during the period of holding.
b) To that part of the income from the transfer of the holding in a Spanish or European economic interest grouping which does not correspond to an increase in undistributed profits generated by the investee entity during the period of holding.
c) To income from the transfer of the holding, direct or indirect, in an entity meeting the requirements established in article 100 of this Act, provided that at least 15 per cent of its income is subject to the international tax transparency regime regulated in that article.
Where the circumstances indicated in letters a) or c) of this paragraph are met only in some of the tax periods during which the holding is held, the exemption shall not apply in respect of that part of the income referred to in those letters which corresponds proportionally to those tax periods.
The provisions of this paragraph shall likewise apply in cases of liquidation of the entity, withdrawal of the member, merger, total or partial division, reduction of capital, non-cash contribution or global transfer of assets and liabilities.
6. Negative income from the transfer of the holding in an entity in respect of which either of the following circumstances arises shall not be included in the tax base:
a) that the requirements established in paragraph 3 of this article are met. Nevertheless, the requirement relating to the percentage holding shall be deemed met where it has been reached at any time during the year before the day on which the transfer takes place.
b) in the case of a holding in the capital or equity of entities not resident in Spanish territory, that the requirement established in letter b) of paragraph 1 of article 21 of this Act is not met.
Where the requirements indicated are met partially, in the terms established in paragraph 3 of this article, the provisions of this paragraph shall be applied partially.
7. Negative income from the transfer of the holding in entities that is included in the tax base because none of the circumstances provided for in the preceding paragraph arises shall have the special features indicated below:
a) Where the holding had previously been transferred by another entity meeting the circumstances referred to in article 42 of the Commercial Code to form part of the same group of companies as the taxpayer, regardless of residence and of the obligation to draw up consolidated annual accounts, that negative income shall be reduced by the amount of the positive income generated in the preceding transfer to which an exemption or deduction regime for the elimination of double taxation was applied.
b) The amount of the negative income shall be reduced, where applicable, by the amount of the dividends or shares in profits received from the investee entity from the tax period beginning in 2009, provided that those dividends or shares in profits have not reduced the acquisition value and have been entitled to the application of the exemption provided for in paragraph 1 of this article.
8. Negative income generated in the event of the extinction of the investee entity shall be tax-deductible, unless the extinction is the result of a restructuring operation.
In this case, the amount of the negative income shall be reduced by the amount of the dividends or shares in profits received from the investee entity in the ten years before the date of extinction, provided that those dividends or shares in profits have not reduced the acquisition value and have been entitled to the application of an exemption or deduction regime for the elimination of double taxation, by the amount of the latter.
9. The exemption provided for in this article shall not apply:
a) To income distributed by the public mortgage market regulation fund.
b) To income obtained by Spanish and European economic interest groupings, and by temporary business associations, where at least one of their members is a natural person.
c) To foreign-source income that the entity includes in its tax base and in relation to which it opts to apply, where appropriate, the deduction established in articles 31 or 32 of this Act.
10. The amount of the dividends or shares in profits of entities, and the amount of the positive income obtained on the transfer of the holding in an entity and in the other cases referred to in paragraph 3 above, to which the exemption provided for in this article applies, shall be reduced, for the purposes of applying that exemption, by 5 per cent as management costs relating to those holdings.
11. The reduction applicable to dividends or shares in profits of entities referred to in the preceding paragraph shall not apply where the following circumstances concur:
a) the dividends or shares in profits are received by an entity whose net turnover for the immediately preceding tax period is less than 40 million euros.
For the purposes of determining net turnover, paragraph 2 of article 101 of this Act shall apply.
The entity referred to in this letter must meet the following requirements:
i) not be an asset-holding entity in the terms established in paragraph 2 of article 5 of this Act;
ii) not form part, prior to the incorporation of the entity referred to in letter b) of this paragraph, of a group of companies within the meaning of article 42 of the Commercial Code, regardless of residence and of the obligation to draw up consolidated annual accounts;
iii) not hold, prior to the incorporation of the entity referred to in letter b) of this paragraph, a direct or indirect percentage holding in the capital or equity of another entity equal to or greater than 5 per cent.
b) the dividends or shares in profits come from an entity incorporated after 1 January 2021 in which the whole of the capital or equity is held directly and since its incorporation.
c) the dividends or shares in profits are received in the tax periods ending in the 3 years immediately following the year of incorporation of the entity distributing them.
Where this sits
The next page translates chapter XIII of title VII, the special regime for holding companies of foreign securities (ETVE), which applies the same exemption to non-resident shareholders.
Related on voixa.es: Dutch holding over a Spanish subsidiary: what survives; EU substance and governance in Spain; The annual compliance calendar for a Spanish SL.
Nothing here is advice on your own position, and this reading is not the official text. Spain publishes no official English version of this Act; where the wording matters to a decision, read it against the Spanish original linked above.