E-Commerce Act (LSSI): infringements, fines and limitation periods
E-Commerce Act (LSSI), articles 37 to 45: who is liable, including advertising networks for cookies placed through advertising space; the very serious, serious and minor infringements; fines and accessory penalties; moderation of penalties and warnings instead of proceedings; the criteria for grading fines; provisional measures and coercive fines; the authorities competent to impose penalties; concurrence with criminal and sectoral penalties; and limitation periods.
Title VII. Infringements and penalties
Article 37. Liable persons
The following are subject to the penalty regime established in this title:
a) Information society service providers to which this Law applies.
b) Providers falling within the scope of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150.
c) Data intermediation service providers and recognised data altruism organisations falling within the scope of Regulation (EU) 2022/868.
Where the infringements provided for in articles 38.3 i) and 38.4 g) are due to the installation of data storage and retrieval devices as a consequence of the information society service provider making its own space available for displaying advertising, the advertising network or agent that deals directly with that provider for the placing of advertisements in that space shall be liable for the infringement, in addition to the information society service provider, if it has not adopted measures to require the provider to comply with the duties to inform and to obtain the user’s consent.
Article 38. Infringements
1. Infringements of the provisions of this Law shall be classified as very serious, serious and minor.
2. The following are very serious infringements:
a) (No content)
b) Failure to comply with the obligation to suspend transmission, data hosting, network access or the provision of any other equivalent intermediary service, when ordered by a competent administrative body under article 11.
c) (Repealed)
d) (Repealed)
3. The following are serious infringements:
a) (Repealed)
b) Significant failure to comply with points a) and f) of article 10.1.
c) The mass sending of commercial communications by e-mail or other equivalent means of electronic communication, or their insistent or systematic sending to the same recipient of the service, where those sendings do not meet the requirements laid down in article 21.
d) Significant failure to comply with the service provider’s obligation laid down in paragraph 1 of article 22 concerning the procedures for withdrawing the consent given by recipients.
e) Failure to make available to the recipient of the service the general terms and conditions to which the contract is subject, where applicable, in the manner provided for in article 27.
f) Habitual failure to comply with the obligation to confirm receipt of an acceptance, where its exclusion has not been agreed or the contract has been concluded with a consumer.
g) Resistance to, excuses for, or refusal of inspection by the bodies empowered to carry it out under this Law.
h) Significant failure to comply with paragraph 3 of article 10.
i) Repetition of the minor infringement provided for in paragraph 4 g), where so declared by a final decision issued in the three years immediately preceding the opening of the penalty proceedings.
j) Demanding payment of a fee for complying with the obligation laid down in article 12 ter, outside the cases provided for in article 12.5 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679.
k) Habitual failure to comply with the obligation laid down in article 12 ter.
l) Significant or repeated failure by online intermediation service providers to comply with any of the obligations laid down in articles 3 to 12 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150.
m) Significant or repeated failure by providers of online search engines to comply with any of the obligations laid down in articles 5 and 7 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150.
n) Significant or repeated failure by data intermediation service providers to comply with any of the obligations laid down in article 11 of Regulation (EU) 2022/868.
ñ) Significant or repeated failure by data intermediation service providers to comply with any of the conditions for providing data intermediation services laid down in article 12 of Regulation (EU) 2022/868.
o) Acting on the market as a data intermediation service provider using the common logo and the designation «data intermediation services provider recognised in the Union» without the competent authority having confirmed that it meets the necessary requirements as provided for in article 11.9 of Regulation (EU) 2022/868.
p) Significant or repeated failure by recognised data altruism organisations to comply with any of the requirements imposed under articles 18, 19, 20, 21 and 22 of Regulation (EU) 2022/868.
q) Acting on the market as a recognised data altruism organisation using the common logo and the designation «data altruism organisation recognised in the Union» without the competent authority having confirmed that it meets the necessary requirements provided for in article 18 of Regulation (EU) 2022/868.
r) Significant or repeated failure by data intermediation service providers and recognised data altruism organisations to comply with the obligations laid down in article 31 of Regulation (EU) 2022/868 concerning transfers of non-personal data to third countries.
4. The following are minor infringements:
a) Failure to comply with article 12 bis.
b) Failure to provide information in the manner prescribed by article 10.1 on the matters set out in points b), c), d), e) and g) of that article, or in points a) and f) where this does not constitute a serious infringement.
c) Failure to comply with article 20 for commercial communications, promotional offers and competitions.
d) The sending of commercial communications by e-mail or other equivalent means of electronic communication where those sendings do not meet the requirements laid down in article 21 and this does not constitute a serious infringement.
e) Failure to provide the information referred to in article 27.1, where the parties have not agreed to exclude it or the recipient is a consumer.
f) Failure to comply with the obligation to confirm receipt of a request on the terms laid down in article 28, where its exclusion has not been agreed or the contract has been concluded with a consumer, unless it constitutes a serious infringement.
g) Using data storage and retrieval devices where the information has not been provided or the consent of the recipient of the service has not been obtained on the terms required by article 22.2.
h) Failure to comply with the service provider’s obligation laid down in paragraph 1 of article 22 concerning the procedures for withdrawing the consent given by recipients, where this does not constitute a serious infringement.
i) Failure to comply with paragraph 3 of article 10, where this does not constitute a serious infringement.
j) Demanding payment of a fee for complying with the obligation laid down in article 12 ter, where article 12.5 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 so permits, if its amount exceeds the costs incurred.
k) Failure to comply with the obligation laid down in article 12 ter, where this does not constitute a serious infringement.
l) Failure by online intermediation service providers to comply with any of the obligations laid down in articles 3 to 12 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150, where this does not constitute a serious infringement.
m) Failure by providers of online search engines to comply with any of the obligations laid down in articles 5 and 7 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1150, where this does not constitute a serious infringement.
n) Failure by data intermediation service providers to comply with any of the obligations laid down in article 11 of Regulation (EU) 2022/868, where this does not constitute a serious infringement.
ñ) Failure by data intermediation service providers to comply with any of the conditions laid down in article 12 of Regulation (EU) 2022/868, where this does not constitute a serious infringement.
o) Failure by recognised data altruism organisations to comply with any of the requirements imposed under articles 18, 19, 20, 21 and 22 of Regulation (EU) 2022/868, where this does not constitute a serious infringement.
p) Failure by data intermediation service providers and recognised data altruism organisations to comply with the obligations laid down in article 31 of Regulation (EU) 2022/868 concerning transfers of non-personal data to third countries, where this does not constitute a serious infringement.
Article 39. Penalties
1. The following penalties shall be imposed for committing the infringements listed in the preceding article:
a) For committing very serious infringements, a fine of 150,001 to 600,000 euros.
The repetition within three years of two or more very serious infringements, penalised by final decision, may, depending on the circumstances, give rise to the penalty of a prohibition on operating in Spain for a maximum period of two years.
b) [For the] commission of serious infringements, a fine of 30,001 to 150,000 euros.
c) For committing minor infringements, a fine of up to 30,000 euros.
[The words “For the” in point b) are missing in the Spanish text of the BOE (“b) comisión de infracciones graves”); they are supplied by the translator.]
2. Where the infringements punishable under this Law have been committed by service providers established in States that are not members of the European Union or the European Economic Area, the body that imposed the corresponding penalty may order intermediary service providers to take the measures necessary to prevent access from Spain to the services offered by those providers for a maximum period of two years in the case of very serious infringements, one year in the case of serious infringements and six months in the case of minor infringements.
3. Without prejudice to any financial penalties that may be imposed under this Law, for committing the infringement provided for in point p) of paragraph 3 of article 38, or point o) of paragraph 4 of article 38, the entry in the national and Union public registers of recognised data altruism organisations shall be cancelled and the right to use the designation recognised data altruism organisation in the Union shall be revoked.
4. Infringements may carry one or more of the following accessory penalties:
a) Serious and very serious infringements may carry publication, at the expense of the person penalised, of the penalty decision in the “Boletín Oficial del Estado”, or in the official journal of the public administration that imposed the penalty, where applicable; in two newspapers whose circulation coincides with the area of activity of that public administration, or on the home page of the provider’s Internet site, once the decision has become final.
In imposing this penalty, account shall be taken of the social impact of the infringement committed, by the number of users or contracts affected, and of the seriousness of the offence.
b) Without prejudice to the financial penalties referred to in article 39.1 b), data intermediation service providers that have committed any of the serious infringements provided for in points n), ñ) and o) of article 38.3 may be subject, as an accessory penalty, to the definitive cessation of the activity of providing services on the terms laid down in article 14.4 of Regulation (EU) 2022/868.
Article 39 bis. Moderation of penalties
The penalising body shall set the amount of the penalty by applying the scale for the class of infringements immediately preceding in seriousness the class to which the infringement in question belongs, in the following cases:
a) Where there is a qualified reduction in the culpability of the accused or in the unlawfulness of the act as a result of the significant concurrence of several of the criteria set out in article 40.
b) Where the infringing entity has diligently regularised the irregular situation.
c) Where it can be found that the conduct of the person affected may have induced the commission of the infringement.
d) Where the offender has spontaneously admitted its culpability.
e) Where there has been a merger by absorption and the infringement preceded that process, not being attributable to the absorbing entity.
Article 39 ter. Warning
1. The bodies with penalising powers, having regard to the nature of the facts and the significant concurrence of the criteria laid down in articles 39 bis and 40, may decide not to open penalty proceedings and, instead, to issue a warning to the person responsible so that, within the period set by the penalising body, it proves that it has adopted the corrective measures appropriate in each case, provided that the facts constitute a minor or serious infringement under this Law.
2. If the warning is not heeded within the period set by the penalising body, the corresponding penalty proceedings shall be opened for that non-compliance.
Article 40. Grading of the amount of penalties
The amount of the fines imposed shall be graded according to the following criteria:
a) The existence of intent.
b) The period of time during which the infringement has been committed.
c) Repeat offending by committing infringements of the same nature, where so declared by final decision.
d) The nature and amount of the damage caused.
e) The profits obtained from the infringement.
f) The volume of turnover affected by the infringement committed.
g) Adherence to a code of conduct or an advertising self-regulation system applicable to the infringement committed, which complies with article 18 or the eighth final provision and has received a favourable report from the competent body or bodies.
h) The adoption of measures to mitigate or repair the damage caused by the infringement.
Article 41. Provisional measures
1. In penalty proceedings for serious or very serious infringements, the provisional measures provided for in Law 30/1992 of 26 November on the Legal Regime of Public Administrations and the Common Administrative Procedure, and its implementing rules, that are considered necessary to ensure the effectiveness of the final decision, the proper conduct of the proceedings, to prevent the effects of the infringement from continuing and to meet the requirements of the general interest may be adopted in accordance with those rules.
In particular, the following may be ordered:
a) Temporary suspension of the service provider’s activity and, where applicable, provisional closure of its establishments.
b) Sealing, deposit or seizure of records, media and computer files and of documents in general, and of computer equipment and apparatus of all kinds.
c) Warning the public of the existence of possible infringing conduct and of the opening of the penalty file concerned, and of the measures adopted to stop that conduct.
2. In adopting and complying with the measures referred to in the preceding paragraph, the guarantees, rules and procedures provided for in the legal order to protect the rights to personal and family privacy, to the protection of personal data, to freedom of expression or to freedom of information shall in all cases be respected, where these may be affected.
In all cases in which the Constitution, the rules governing the respective rights and freedoms or those applicable to the various matters confer competence on the courts to intervene in the exercise of activities or rights, only the competent judicial authority may adopt the measures provided for in this article.
3. In any event, the principle that the measure adopted must be proportionate to the objectives pursued in each case shall be respected.
4. In cases of urgency and for the immediate protection of the interests involved, the provisional measures provided for in this article may be ordered before the penalty file is opened. The measures must be confirmed, modified or lifted in the decision to open the proceedings, which must be made within the fifteen days following their adoption and may be the subject of the appropriate appeal.
In any event, those measures shall cease to have effect if the penalty proceedings are not opened within that period or if the decision to open them does not contain an express ruling on them.
Article 42. Coercive fine
The administrative body competent to decide the penalty proceedings may impose coercive fines of an amount not exceeding 6,000 euros for each day that passes without compliance with the provisional measures that have been ordered.
Article 43. Competence to impose penalties
1. Penalties for failure to comply with this Law shall be imposed, in the case of very serious infringements, by the head of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Digital Transformation and, in the case of serious and minor infringements, by the head of the Secretariat of State for Digitalisation and Artificial Intelligence.
Notwithstanding the above, penalties for failure to comply with the decisions issued by the bodies competent according to the subject matter or entity concerned, referred to in points a) and b) of article 38.2 of this Law, shall be imposed by the body that issued the decision not complied with. Likewise, the Data Protection Agency shall be responsible for imposing penalties for committing the infringements defined in articles 38.3 c), d) and i) and 38.4 d), g) and h) of this Law.
2. The penalising power regulated in this Law shall be exercised in accordance with Law 39/2015 of 1 October on the Common Administrative Procedure of Public Administrations and its implementing rules. The proceedings shall last a maximum of nine months from the date of the decision to open them. The maximum duration of the simplified procedure shall be three months.
Article 44. Concurrence of infringements and penalties
1. The penalising power referred to in this Law may not be exercised where a criminal penalty has been imposed, in cases where there is identity of person, facts and legal basis.
However, where criminal proceedings are being conducted for the same facts or for others that cannot reasonably be separated from those punishable under this Law, the proceedings shall be suspended in respect of them until the judicial authority has given a final ruling.
When the file is resumed, where applicable, the decision issued must respect the facts declared proven in the judicial decision.
2. The imposition of a penalty provided for in this Law shall not prevent the conduct and resolution of other penalty proceedings by the bodies or agencies competent in each case where the infringing conduct was committed using telematic or electronic techniques and means and is defined as an offence in another Law, provided that the protected legal interest is not the same.
3. Penalties shall not be imposed under this Law where the facts constituting the infringement also constitute another infringement defined in the sectoral legislation to which the service provider is subject and the protected legal interest is the same.
Where, as a result of penalising action, facts become known that may constitute infringements defined in other laws, they shall be reported to the bodies or agencies competent for their supervision and penalisation.
Article 45. Limitation
Very serious infringements shall become time-barred after three years, serious infringements after two years and minor infringements after six months; penalties imposed for very serious offences shall become time-barred after three years, those imposed for serious offences after two years and those imposed for minor offences after one year.
Where this sits
Previous: E-Commerce Act: commercial communications, cookies and electronic contracts. All translated laws: Spanish laws in English.
Related on voixa.es: Cookie consent in Spain: LSSI and AEPD; Email marketing opt-in rules in Spain; Setting up an online store in Spain.
Nothing here is advice on your own position, and this reading is not the official text. Spain publishes no official English version of this text; where the wording matters to a decision, read it against the Spanish original published in the BOE.