Spanish Unfair Competition Act: unfair consumer practices, actions and codes of conduct (articles 19 to 39)
Unfair Competition Act (Law 3/1991), articles 19 to 39 and the closing provisions: commercial practices with consumers deemed unfair in all circumstances (confusion, false codes and quality marks, bait and misleading promotions, pyramid schemes, covert practices, coercion, harassment, practices aimed at minors), the actions available, standing to sue and to be sued, limitation, preliminary measures, and codes of conduct. Also the definition of advertising in the sole additional provision and the transitional and repealing provisions.
Chapter III. Commercial practices with consumers or users
Article 19. Unfair commercial practices with consumers
1. Without prejudice to articles 19 and 20 of the consolidated text of the General Law for the Protection of Consumers and Users and other complementary laws, only the practices provided for in this chapter and in articles 4, 5, 7 and 8 of this Act shall be regarded as unfair commercial practices with consumers and users.
2. The commercial practices regulated in articles 21 to 31, inclusive, are in all cases and in all circumstances unfair commercial practices with consumers.
Article 20. Misleading practices by confusion for consumers
In relations with consumers and users, commercial practices, including comparative advertising, are deemed unfair which, in their factual context and taking into account all their features and circumstances, create confusion, including a likelihood of association, with any goods or services, registered trade marks, trade names or other distinctive marks of a competitor, provided that they are likely to affect the economic behaviour of consumers and users.
Article 21. Misleading practices concerning codes of conduct or other quality marks
1. Commercial practices are deemed unfair as misleading where they claim, when it is not true:
a) That the trader or professional is a signatory to a code of conduct.
b) That a code of conduct has been endorsed by a public body or has received any other type of accreditation.
c) That a trader or professional, the trader’s or professional’s commercial practices, or a good or service has been approved, accepted or authorised by a public or private body, or where they make that claim without complying with the terms of the approval, acceptance or authorisation.
2. Displaying a trust mark or quality mark or an equivalent mark without having obtained the necessary authorisation is likewise, in all cases, a commercial practice that is unfair as misleading.
Article 22. Bait practices and misleading promotional practices
The following are deemed unfair as misleading:
1. Making a commercial offer of goods or services at a specified price without disclosing the existence of any reasonable grounds the trader or professional may have for believing that those goods or services, or equivalent ones, will not be available at the price offered for a sufficient period and in reasonable quantities, having regard to the type of good or service, the scale of the advertising given to it and the price concerned.
2. Making a commercial offer of goods or services at a specified price and then, with the intention of promoting a different good or service, refusing to show the good or service offered, refusing to take orders or requests for supply, refusing to supply it within a reasonable period of time, demonstrating a defective sample of the good or service promoted, or disparaging it.
3. Commercial practices relating to closing-down sales where it is untrue that the trader or professional is in one of the situations provided for in article 30.1 of Law 7/1996 of 15 January on the Regulation of Retail Trade or which, in any other situation, claim that the trader or professional is about to cease trading or move premises when he or she is not going to do so.
4. Commercial practices offering a prize, automatically or in a competition or prize draw, without awarding the prizes described or others of equivalent quality and value.
5. Describing a good or service as “free”, “gift”, “without charge” or any equivalent wording if the consumer or user has to pay money for anything other than the unavoidable cost of responding to the commercial practice and collecting the product or paying for its delivery.
6. Creating the false impression, including by means of aggressive practices, that the consumer or user has already won, will win or will obtain a prize or any other equivalent benefit if he or she performs a particular act, when in fact:
a) There is no such prize or equivalent benefit.
b) Or performing the act relating to obtaining the prize or equivalent benefit is subject to the consumer or user being required to make a payment or incur a cost.
Article 23. Misleading practices concerning the nature and properties of goods or services, their availability and after-sales services
The following are deemed unfair as misleading:
1. Claiming, or otherwise creating the impression, that a good or service can legally be marketed when this is not true.
2. Claiming that the goods or services can facilitate winning prizes in games of chance.
3. Falsely claiming that a good or service can cure illnesses, dysfunctions or malformations.
4. Stating, when this is not true, that the good or service will be available only for a very limited period of time, or that it will be available on particular terms only for a very limited period of time, in order to induce the consumer or user to take an immediate decision, thereby depriving him or her of the opportunity or sufficient time to make an informed choice.
5. Undertaking to provide an after-sales service to consumers or users without clearly informing them, before the contract is concluded, that the language in which that service will be available is not the one used in the commercial transaction.
6. Creating the false impression that after-sales service in relation to the good or service promoted is available in a Member State other than the one in which its supply was contracted.
Article 24. Pyramid selling practices
Establishing, operating or promoting a pyramid selling scheme in which the consumer or user gives consideration in return for the opportunity to receive compensation derived primarily from the entry of other consumers or users into the scheme, rather than from the sale or supply of goods or services, is deemed unfair as misleading in all circumstances.
Article 25. Misleading practices by confusion
Promoting a good or service similar to one marketed by a particular trader or professional in such a way as deliberately to induce the consumer or user to believe that the good or service comes from that trader or professional, when it does not, is deemed unfair as misleading.
Article 26. Covert commercial practices
Practices are deemed unfair as misleading where they:
1. Include, as information in the media or in information society services or social networks, communications promoting a good or service, the trader or professional having paid for that promotion, without making it clear in the content, or by means of images and sounds clearly identifiable by the consumer or user, that it is advertising content.
2. Provide search results in response to a consumer’s or user’s online query without clearly disclosing any paid advertisement or payment specifically for achieving a higher ranking of goods or services within the search results, ranking meaning the relative prominence given to goods or services as presented, organised or communicated by the trader, irrespective of the technological means used for such presentation, organisation or communication.
Article 27. Other misleading practices
Practices are likewise deemed unfair as misleading where they:
1. Present rights given to consumers or users by law as if they were a distinctive feature of the trader’s or professional’s offer.
2. Make inaccurate or false statements as to the nature and extent of the danger to the personal safety of the consumer and user or his or her family if the consumer or user does not purchase the good or service.
3. Pass on inaccurate or false information about market conditions or the possibility of finding the good or service, with the intention of inducing the consumer or user to acquire it on terms less favourable than normal market conditions.
4. Include in marketing material an invoice or similar document seeking payment which gives the consumer or user the impression that he or she has already ordered the good or service marketed, when he or she has not requested it.
5. Fraudulently claim or create the false impression that a trader or professional is not acting for purposes relating to his or her business or professional activity, or fraudulently present oneself as a consumer or user.
6. Consist of reselling event tickets to consumers or users if the trader acquired them by using automated means to circumvent any limit imposed on the number of tickets a person can buy or any other rules applicable to the purchase of tickets.
7. State that reviews of a good or service are submitted by consumers and users who have actually used or purchased the good or service, without taking reasonable and proportionate steps to check that those reviews come from such consumers and users.
8. Submit, or commission another natural or legal person to submit, false consumer reviews or endorsements, or misrepresent reviews by consumers or users or social endorsements, in order to promote goods or services.
9. Are directed at consumers individually, having been personalised on the basis of automated decision-making, without information being given on the parameters used for that personalisation or on the data sources used, in the case of offers relating to contracts for products or services of the financial sector.
Article 28. Aggressive practices by coercion
Commercial practices that lead the consumer or user to believe that he or she cannot leave the trader’s or professional’s establishment or the premises where the commercial practice takes place until a contract has been concluded are deemed unfair as aggressive, unless such conduct constitutes a criminal offence.
Article 29. Aggressive practices by harassment
1. Making personal visits to the consumer’s or user’s home, ignoring the consumer’s or user’s requests that the trader or professional leave the home or not return, is deemed unfair as aggressive.
2. Making persistent and unwanted solicitations by telephone, fax, e-mail or other means of distance communication is likewise deemed unfair, except in the circumstances and to the extent legally justified in order to enforce a contractual obligation.
In these communications the trader or professional must use systems that allow the consumer to record his or her objection to receiving further commercial solicitations from that trader or professional.
So that the consumer or user can exercise the right to object to receiving unwanted commercial solicitations, where these are made by telephone the calls must be made from an identifiable telephone number.
This case shall be without prejudice to the legislation in force on personal data protection, information society services, telecommunications and distance contracting with consumers or users, including the distance contracting of financial services.
Article 30. Aggressive practices in relation to minors
Including in advertising a direct exhortation to children to buy goods or use services, or to persuade their parents or other adults to purchase the goods or services advertised, is deemed unfair as aggressive.
Article 31. Other aggressive practices
The following are deemed unfair as aggressive:
1. Requiring a consumer or user who, whether as policyholder, beneficiary or injured third party, wishes to claim compensation under an insurance contract, to produce documents which are not reasonably necessary to establish whether the insured event occurred and, where applicable, the amount of the resulting loss, or systematically failing to respond to the related correspondence, in order to dissuade the consumer or user from exercising his or her rights.
2. Demanding immediate or deferred payment for, or the return or safekeeping of, goods or services supplied by the trader but not requested by the consumer or user, except where the good or service in question is a substitute good or service supplied in accordance with the legislation in force on distance contracting with consumers and users.
3. Explicitly informing the consumer or user that the trader’s or professional’s job or livelihood will be in jeopardy if the consumer or user does not purchase the good or service.
4. Unsolicited visits made by the trader to the consumer’s or user’s home, or excursions organised by the trader, with the aim or effect of promoting or selling goods or services, where they do not respect the terms of the restrictions established under article 19.7 of the consolidated text of the General Law for the Protection of Consumers and Users and other complementary laws, approved by Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007 of 16 November.
Chapter IV. Actions arising from unfair competition
Article 32. Actions
1. The following actions may be brought against acts of unfair competition, including unlawful advertising:
1st. An action for a declaration that the conduct is unfair.
2nd. An action for cessation of the unfair conduct or for prohibition of its future repetition. An action for prohibition may also be brought if the conduct has not yet been put into practice.
3rd. An action for removal of the effects produced by the unfair conduct.
4th. An action for rectification of misleading, incorrect or false information.
5th. An action for compensation for the loss and damage caused by the unfair conduct, if there has been wilful misconduct or fault on the part of the perpetrator.
6th. An action for unjust enrichment, which shall lie only where the unfair conduct harms a legal position protected by an exclusive right or by another right of similar economic content.
2. In judgments upholding the actions provided for in numbers 1st to 4th of the preceding paragraph, the court may, if it considers it appropriate and at the defendant’s expense, order the publication of the judgment in whole or in part or, where the effects of the infringement may persist over time, a corrective statement.
In addition, at the court’s discretion and following referral for the purpose, such publication may be made through the Authority for Equal Treatment and Non-Discrimination and the observatories, or through the competent bodies of the national department or body with responsibility for equality between women and men or its equivalent at the level of the Autonomous Communities.
Article 33. Standing to sue
1. Any natural or legal person taking part in the market whose economic interests are directly harmed or threatened by the unfair conduct has standing to bring the actions provided for in article 32.1, 1st to 5th.
Against unlawful advertising, any natural or legal person affected and, in general, anyone with a subjective right or a legitimate interest has standing to bring the actions provided for in article 32.1, 1st to 5th.
The action for compensation for the loss and damage caused by the unfair conduct may also be brought by those with standing under article 11.2 of Law 1/2000 of 7 January on Civil Procedure.
The action for unjust enrichment may only be brought by the holder of the legal position infringed.
2. The actions referred to in article 32.1, 1st to 4th, may also be brought by associations and professional bodies or bodies representing economic interests, where the interests of their members are affected.
3. The following have standing to bring the actions provided for in article 32.1, 1st to 4th, in defence of the general, collective or diffuse interests of consumers and users:
a) The National Consumer Institute (Instituto Nacional del Consumo) and the corresponding bodies or entities of the Autonomous Communities and of the local authorities with responsibility for consumer and user protection.
b) Consumer and user associations that meet the requirements laid down in the consolidated text of the General Law for the Protection of Consumers and Users or, where applicable, in the regional legislation on consumer and user protection.
c) Entities of other Member States of the European Community set up to protect the collective interests and the diffuse interests of consumers and users that are qualified by being included in the list published for that purpose in the “Official Journal of the European Communities”.
4. The Public Prosecutor’s Office (Ministerio Fiscal) may bring the action for cessation in defence of the general, collective or diffuse interests of consumers and users.
Article 34. Standing to be sued
1. The actions provided for in article 32 may be brought against any person who has carried out or ordered the unfair conduct or has cooperated in carrying it out. However, the action for unjust enrichment may only be brought against the person who benefited from the enrichment.
2. If the unfair conduct was carried out by employees or other collaborators in the performance of their duties and contractual obligations, the actions provided for in article 32.1, 1st to 4th, must be brought against the principal. As regards the actions for compensation for damage and for unjust enrichment, the provisions of civil law shall apply.
Article 35. Limitation
The unfair competition actions provided for in article 32 become time-barred one year after the time when they could have been brought and the person with standing became aware of the identity of the person who committed the act of unfair competition and, in any event, three years after the conduct ended.
The limitation of actions in defence of the general, collective or diffuse interests of consumers and users is governed by article 56 of the consolidated text of the General Law for the Protection of Consumers and Users and other complementary laws.
Article 36. Preliminary measures
1. Anyone intending to bring an unfair competition action may ask the court to order measures to verify those facts knowledge of which is objectively indispensable for preparing the proceedings.
2. Such measures shall be dealt with in accordance with articles 129 to 132 of Law 11/1986 of 20 March on Patents, and may extend to the entire internal sphere of the undertaking.
Chapter V. Codes of conduct
Article 37. Promotion of codes of conduct
1. Commercial, professional and consumer corporations, associations or organisations may draw up codes of conduct concerning commercial practices with consumers, for voluntary adoption by traders or professionals, in order to raise the level of consumer protection, ensuring that consumer organisations take part in drawing them up.
2. Codes of conduct shall comply with competition law and shall be given sufficient publicity for them to be duly known by those to whom they are addressed.
3. The public administrations shall promote the participation of business and professional organisations in drawing up codes of conduct with this same aim at Community level.
4. The application of these codes of conduct shall be entrusted to self-regulation systems, which shall have independent monitoring bodies to ensure effective compliance with the commitments made by the undertakings that are signatories. They may include, among other things, collective measures for prior self-monitoring of advertising content, and must establish effective systems for the out-of-court resolution of complaints that meet the requirements laid down in Community legislation and, as such, are notified to the European Commission in accordance with Law 7/2017 of 2 November transposing into Spanish law Directive 2013/11/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 May 2013 on alternative dispute resolution for consumer disputes, or any equivalent provision.
5. Recourse to the monitoring bodies of codes of conduct shall in no case entail a waiver of the judicial actions provided for in article 32, but it shall be deemed to satisfy the procedural precondition required by article 5 and the sixth additional provision of the Organic Law on measures concerning the efficiency of the Public Justice Service.
Article 38. Actions against codes of conduct
1. The actions for cessation and rectification provided for in article 32.1, 2nd and 4th, may be brought against codes of conduct that recommend, encourage or promote unfair or unlawful conduct.
2. Before the actions provided for in the preceding paragraph are brought against those responsible for codes of conduct that meet the requirements laid down in article 37.4, the person responsible for the code must be requested to cease or rectify the unfair recommendation, and to undertake to refrain from making it where it has not yet been made.
The request must be made by any means that provides a record of its content and of the date of its receipt.
The person responsible for the code of conduct shall be required to issue the appropriate decision within 15 days of the request being submitted; during that period, whoever initiated this prior procedure may not bring the corresponding judicial action.
Once the period provided for in the preceding sub-paragraph has elapsed without the decision having been notified to the claimant, or where the decision is unsatisfactory or is not complied with, the way to the courts shall be open.
Article 39. Prior actions against traders and professionals who are signatories to codes of conduct
1. Where the action is based on the grounds provided for in article 5.2, before the actions provided for in article 32.1, 2nd and 4th, are brought, an application shall be made to the monitoring body of the code of conduct for the cessation or rectification of the act or commercial practice of those who are publicly signatories to the code, and for an undertaking to refrain from carrying out the unfair act or practice where it has not yet taken place.
The monitoring body shall be required to issue the appropriate decision within 15 days of the application being submitted; during that period, whoever initiated this prior procedure may not bring the corresponding judicial action.
Once the period provided for in the preceding sub-paragraph has elapsed without the decision having been notified to the claimant, or where the decision is unsatisfactory or is not complied with, the way to the courts shall be open.
2. In all other cases of actions seeking the cessation or rectification of unfair conduct by those who are publicly signatories to codes of conduct that meet the requirements of article 37.4, the prior action before the monitoring body provided for in the preceding paragraph shall be optional.
Sole additional provision. Definition of advertising
For the purposes of this Act, advertising means the activity so defined in article 2 of Law 34/1988 of 11 November, the General Advertising Act.
Transitional provision
Judicial actions commenced before this Act enters into force shall be dealt with in accordance with the substantive and procedural rules previously in force.
Repealing provision
When this Act enters into force, articles 87, 88 and 89 of Law 32/1988 of 10 November on Trade Marks shall be repealed.
Likewise, all provisions of equal or lower rank that conflict with this Act shall be repealed.
I therefore command all Spaniards, private individuals and authorities, to observe and enforce this Act.
Madrid, 10 January 1991.
JUAN CARLOS R.
The President of the Government,
FELIPE GONZÁLEZ MÁRQUEZ
Where this sits
Previous: Unfair Competition Act: general rules and unfair acts. All translated laws: Spanish laws in English.
Related on voixa.es: Advertising standards in Spain: Autocontrol and the law; Online reviews and social proof in Spain; Influencer marketing rules in Spain.
Nothing here is advice on your own position, and this reading is not the official text. Spain publishes no official English version of this text; where the wording matters to a decision, read it against the Spanish original published in the BOE.