Spanish VAT deductions: time limits, pro rata and capital goods
Law 37/1992 on Value Added Tax, articles 99 to 110: how and when the right to deduct is exercised, the four-year limit and carrying forward excess input VAT. Deductions in distinct sectors of activity, the general and special pro rata rules, and the adjustment of deductions for capital goods, including on their supply during the adjustment period.
Title VIII. Deductions and refunds (continued)
Chapter I. Deductions (continued)
Article 99. Exercise of the right to deduct
One. In the returns for each tax period, taxpayers may deduct, on a global basis, the total amount of deductible tax borne in that period from the total amount of Value Added Tax that became chargeable during the same tax period in the territory where the tax applies as a result of the supplies of goods, intra-Community acquisitions of goods or supplies of services they have carried out.
Two. Deductions must be made according to the foreseeable use of the goods and services acquired, without prejudice to their subsequent correction if that use changes.
However, in cases of destruction or loss of the goods acquired or imported, for a duly evidenced cause not attributable to the taxpayer, that correction shall not be required.
Three. The right to deduct may only be exercised in the return for the tax period in which its holder bore the deductible tax amounts or in the returns for subsequent periods, provided that the period of four years, counted from the time that right arose, has not expired.
However, in the event of a declaration of insolvency (concurso), the right to deduct tax amounts borne before that declaration that were pending deduction must be exercised in the return for the tax period in which they were borne.
Where the deductible tax amounts borne referred to in the preceding paragraph were not included in those returns, and provided that the period of four years, counted from the time the right to deduct those amounts arose, has not expired, the insolvent debtor or, in the cases provided for in article 86.3 of the Insolvency Law, the insolvency administrator may deduct them by correcting the return for the period in which they were borne.
Where there has been a request from the Administration or an inspection procedure, the tax amounts borne that were duly entered in the record books laid down by regulation for this tax shall be deductible in the relevant assessments, while amounts not entered shall be deductible in the return for the period in which they are entered or in the returns for subsequent periods. In any event, both kinds of tax amounts may only be deducted where the period referred to in the first paragraph has not expired.
In the case of the occasional sales referred to in article 5, paragraph One, letter e), of this Law, the right to deduct may only be exercised in the return for the period in which the new means of transport concerned are supplied.
Four. Deductible tax amounts shall be regarded as borne at the time when the business or professional who bore them receives the corresponding invoice or other documents evidencing the right to deduct.
If the tax becomes chargeable at a time later than receipt of the invoice, those tax amounts shall be regarded as borne when they become chargeable.
In the case referred to in article 98, paragraph Four of this Law, deductible tax amounts shall be regarded as borne when the right to deduct arises.
Five. Where the amount of the allowable deductions exceeds the tax that became chargeable in the same tax period, the excess may be offset in subsequent returns, provided that four years have not passed from the filing of the return in which that excess arose.
However, the taxpayer may opt for a refund of the balance in its favour where this is allowed under Chapter II of this Title, in which case it may not offset that balance in subsequent returns, whatever the period of time that passes until the refund is actually made.
In the return provided for by regulation relating to taxable events prior to the declaration of insolvency, the whole of the accumulated balances to be offset from tax periods prior to that declaration must be applied.
Article 100. Expiry of the right to deduct
The right to deduct expires when its holder has not exercised it within the time limits and in the amounts set out in article 99 of this Law.
However, in cases where the existence of the right to deduct or the amount of the deduction is pending the resolution of a dispute in administrative or judicial proceedings, the right to deduct shall expire when four years have passed from the date on which the decision or judgment becomes final.
Article 101. Deduction scheme in distinct sectors of business or professional activity
One. Taxpayers who carry on economic activities in distinct sectors of business or professional activity must apply the deduction scheme separately for each of them.
The special pro rata rule may be applied independently for each of the distinct sectors of business or professional activity determined under article 9, number 1st, letter c), letters a′), c′) and d′) of this Law.
The deduction schemes for the distinct sectors of activity determined under article 9, number 1st, letter c), letter b′) of this Law shall in all cases be governed by the provisions of this Law for the special schemes for the simplified scheme, agriculture, livestock and fisheries, transactions in investment gold and the equivalence surcharge, as appropriate.
Where goods or services are acquired or imported for common use in several distinct sectors of activity, article 104, paragraphs Two et seq. of this Law shall apply in order to determine the deduction percentage applicable to the tax amounts borne on those acquisitions or importations, taking into account for that purpose the transactions carried out in the distinct sectors concerned and treating the transactions included in the special scheme for agriculture, livestock and fisheries or in the special scheme of the equivalence surcharge as not giving rise to the right to deduct for those purposes.
By way of exception to the preceding paragraph, the transactions carried out in the distinct sector of activity of a VAT group of entities shall not be taken into account. Likewise, and provided that the preceding paragraph cannot be applied, where such goods or services are intended to be used simultaneously in activities under the special simplified scheme and in other activities subject to the special scheme for agriculture, livestock and fisheries or the equivalence surcharge, the deduction percentage for the purposes of the simplified scheme shall be 50 per cent if the goods or services are assigned to activities subject to two of those special schemes, or one third otherwise.
Two. The Administration may authorise the application of a common deduction scheme to the distinct sectors of the taxpayer’s business or professional activity that are determined solely under article 9, number 1st, letter c), letter a′) of this Law.
The authorisation shall have no effect in the year in which the total amount of tax deductible under the common deduction scheme exceeds by 20 per cent the amount that would result from applying the deduction scheme independently to each distinct sector.
The authorisation granted shall remain in force in subsequent years until revoked or waived by the taxpayer.
The requirements and procedure to be followed for the authorisations referred to in this paragraph shall be laid down by regulation.
Article 102. Pro rata rule
One. The pro rata rule shall apply where the taxpayer, in carrying on its business or professional activity, makes both supplies of goods or supplies of services that give rise to the right to deduct and other transactions of a similar nature that do not entitle it to exercise that right.
Two. Notwithstanding the preceding paragraph, taxpayers may deduct in full the tax amounts borne on acquisitions or importations of goods or on supplies of services to the extent that they are used to carry out the self-supplies referred to in article 9, number 1st, letter c), that concern goods forming part of stock, and the self-supplies covered by letter d) of the same article and number of this Law.
Article 103. Types of pro rata and criteria for their application
One. The pro rata rule shall have two forms of application: general and special.
The general pro rata rule shall apply where the circumstances indicated in the following paragraph do not exist.
Two. The special pro rata rule shall apply in the following cases:
1st. Where taxpayers opt to apply that rule within the time limits and in the manner determined by regulation.
2nd. Where the total amount of tax deductible in a calendar year under the general pro rata rule exceeds by 10 per cent or more the amount that would result from applying the special pro rata rule.
Article 104. The general pro rata
One. Where the general pro rata rule applies, the tax borne in each tax period shall be deductible only in the percentage resulting from paragraph Two below.
For the application of the preceding paragraph, tax amounts that are not deductible under articles 95 and 96 of this Law shall not be counted in the tax borne.
Two. The deduction percentage referred to in the preceding paragraph shall be determined by multiplying by 100 the result of a fraction showing:
1st. In the numerator, the total amount, determined for each calendar year, of the supplies of goods and supplies of services giving rise to the right to deduct made by the taxpayer in carrying on its business or professional activity or, where applicable, in the distinct sector concerned.
2nd. In the denominator, the total amount, determined for the same period of time, of the supplies of goods and supplies of services made by the taxpayer in carrying on its business or professional activity or, where applicable, in the distinct sector concerned, including those that do not give rise to the right to deduct.
In transactions involving the transfer of foreign currencies, banknotes and coins that are legal tender, which are exempt from the tax, the amount to be counted in the denominator shall be the consideration for the resale of those means of payment, increased, where applicable, by the commissions received and reduced by their acquisition price or, if that cannot be determined, by the price of other currencies, banknotes or coins of the same kind acquired on the same date.
In transactions involving the transfer of promissory notes and securities not forming part of the portfolio of financial institutions, the amount to be counted in the denominator shall be the consideration for the resale of those instruments, increased, where applicable, by the interest and commissions payable and reduced by their acquisition price.
In the case of securities forming part of the portfolio of financial institutions, the interest payable during the relevant period of time and, where those securities are transferred, the capital gains obtained must be counted in the denominator of the pro rata.
The deduction pro rata resulting from applying the above criteria shall be rounded up to the next whole number.
Three. To determine the deduction percentage, the following shall not be counted in either term of the ratio:
1st. Transactions carried out from permanent establishments located outside the territory where the tax applies.
2nd. The Value Added Tax amounts that have been levied directly on the transactions referred to in the preceding paragraph.
3rd. The amount of supplies and exportations of capital goods that the taxpayer has used in its business or professional activity.
4th. The amount of real estate or financial transactions that do not constitute the taxpayer’s habitual business or professional activity.
Leasing shall in all cases be deemed a habitual business or professional activity of the taxpayer.
For these purposes, financial transactions means those described in article 20, paragraph One, number 18th of this Law, including those that do not benefit from the exemption.
5th. Transactions not subject to the tax under article 7 of this Law.
6th. The transactions referred to in article 9, number 1st, letter d) of this Law.
Four. For the purposes of calculating the pro rata, the total amount of the transactions means the sum of the consideration for them, determined in accordance with articles 78 and 79 of this Law, including for transactions that are exempt from or not subject to the tax.
For the purposes of the preceding paragraph, in transactions in which the consideration is lower than the taxable amount for Value Added Tax, the latter amount must be counted instead of the former.
In the case of supplies destined for other Member States or of definitive exportations, in the absence of consideration the amount of the transaction shall be taken to be the market value, within the territory where the tax applies, of the products supplied or exported.
Five. In works and supplies of services carried out outside the territory where the tax applies, the amount of the transaction shall be taken to be the result of multiplying the total consideration by the coefficient obtained by dividing the part of the cost borne in the territory where the tax applies by the total cost of the transaction.
For the purposes of the preceding paragraph, the costs of the undertaking’s employed staff shall not be counted.
Six. For allocation to periods, the rules on chargeability of the tax laid down in Title IV of this Law shall apply to all the transactions included in the preceding paragraphs.
However, exportations exempt from the tax under article 21 of this Law and other definitive exportations of goods shall be deemed to be carried out, for these purposes, at the time the Customs accepts the relevant exit application.
Article 105. Procedure for the general pro rata
One. Save as provided in paragraphs Two and Three of this article, the deduction percentage provisionally applicable in each calendar year shall be the percentage fixed as definitive for the preceding year.
Two. Application of a provisional percentage different from that laid down in the preceding paragraph may be requested where circumstances arise that are likely to alter it significantly.
Three. In cases of commencement of business or professional activities, and in cases of commencement of activities that are to constitute a distinct sector in relation to those previously carried on, the provisional deduction percentage applicable during the year in which the supplies of goods and supplies of services of the activity concerned begin shall be the percentage determined under paragraph Two of article 111 of this Law.
Where no provisional deduction percentage has been determined under paragraph Two of article 111 of this Law, the provisional percentage referred to in the preceding paragraph shall be fixed in a manner analogous to that provision.
Four. In the last return of the tax for each calendar year, the taxpayer shall calculate the definitive deduction pro rata on the basis of the transactions carried out in that calendar year and shall make the resulting adjustment of the provisional deductions.
Five. In cases where the business or professional activity or, where applicable, a distinct sector of it is interrupted for one or more calendar years, the deduction percentage definitively applicable during each of those years shall be the overall percentage for the last three calendar years in which transactions were carried out.
Six. The deduction percentage determined in accordance with the preceding paragraphs of this article shall be applied to the sum of the tax amounts borne by the taxpayer during the calendar year concerned, excluding those that are not deductible under articles 95 and 96 of this Law.
Article 106. The special pro rata
One. The right to deduct under the special pro rata shall be exercised in accordance with the following rules:
1st. Tax amounts borne on the acquisition or importation of goods or services used exclusively in carrying out transactions that give rise to the right to deduct may be deducted in full.
2nd. Tax amounts borne on the acquisition or importation of goods or services used exclusively in carrying out transactions that do not give rise to the right to deduct may not be deducted.
3rd. Tax amounts borne on the acquisition or importation of goods or services used only partly in carrying out transactions that give rise to the right to deduct may be deducted in the proportion resulting from applying to their overall amount the percentage referred to in article 104, paragraphs Two et seq.
The application of that percentage shall follow the procedural rules laid down in article 105 of this Law.
Two. In no case may tax amounts that are not deductible under articles 95 and 96 of this Law be deducted.
Article 107. Adjustment of deductions for capital goods
One. The tax amounts deductible on the acquisition or importation of capital goods must be adjusted during the four calendar years following the year in which the taxpayers carry out those transactions.
However, where actual use or entry into operation of the goods begins after their acquisition or importation, the adjustment shall be made in the year in which those circumstances occur and the following four years.
The adjustments indicated in this paragraph shall only be made where there is a difference of more than ten points between the definitive deduction percentage for each of those years and the percentage that applied in the year in which the tax was charged to the taxpayer.
Two. The adjustment referred to in the preceding paragraph shall also apply where taxpayers, during the year of acquisition of the capital goods, carried out exclusively transactions giving rise to the right to deduct or exclusively transactions not giving rise to that right and, subsequently, during the following years indicated in that paragraph, that situation changes in the terms laid down in the preceding paragraph.
Three. In the case of land or buildings, the tax amounts deductible on their acquisition must be adjusted during the nine calendar years following the acquisition.
However, if their actual use or entry into operation begins after their acquisition, the adjustment shall be made in the year in which those circumstances occur and the following nine calendar years.
Four. The adjustment of tax amounts borne after the acquisition or importation of the capital goods or, where applicable, after the start of their use or their entry into operation must be made at the end of the year in which those tax amounts are borne, with reference to the date on which the circumstances indicated occurred and for each of the years that have passed since then.
Five. This article shall not apply to the transactions referred to in article 7, number 1st of this Law, the acquirer being automatically subrogated to the position of the transferor.
In such cases, the deduction pro rata applicable for adjusting the deductions for those goods during the same year and the years remaining until the end of the adjustment period shall be that of the acquirer.
Six. In cases of loss or definitive disablement of the capital goods, for a duly evidenced cause not attributable to the taxpayer, no adjustment shall be made during the years after the year in which that circumstance occurs.
Seven. The payments or, where applicable, additional deductions resulting from the adjustment of deductions for capital goods must be made in the return for the last tax period of the calendar year to which they relate, except in the case mentioned in paragraph Four, in which they must be made in the same year in which the tax charged is borne.
Article 108. Concept of capital goods
One. For the purposes of this tax, capital goods means tangible movable property, livestock or immovable property which, by reason of their nature and function, are normally intended to be used for a period of more than one year as tools of work or means of operation.
Two. The following shall not be regarded as capital goods:
1st. Accessories and spare parts acquired for the repair of capital goods used by the taxpayer.
2nd. Works for the repair of other capital goods.
3rd. Containers and packaging, even if capable of reuse.
4th. Clothing used for work by the taxpayers or their employed staff.
5th. Any other goods whose acquisition value is less than five hundred thousand pesetas.
Article 109. Procedure for adjusting deductions for capital goods
The adjustment of the deductions referred to in article 107 of this Law shall be made as follows:
1st. Once the deduction percentage definitively applicable in each of the years in which the adjustment must take place is known, the amount of the deduction that would be allowable if the tax had been charged in the year under consideration shall be determined.
2nd. That amount shall be subtracted from the amount of the deduction made in the year in which the tax was charged.
3rd. The positive or negative difference shall be divided by five or, in the case of land or buildings, by ten, and the resulting quotient shall be the amount of the additional payment or deduction to be made.
Article 110. Supplies of capital goods during the adjustment period
One. Where capital goods are supplied during the adjustment period, a single adjustment shall be made for the remaining part of that period.
For that purpose, the following rules shall apply:
1st. If the supply is subject to and not exempt from the tax, the capital goods shall be deemed to have been used exclusively in carrying out transactions giving rise to the right to deduct throughout the year in which the supply was made and in the remaining years until the end of the adjustment period.
However, the difference between the amount resulting from applying the preceding paragraph and the amount of tax that became chargeable on the supply of the goods shall not be deductible.
2nd. If the supply is exempt or not subject to the tax, the capital goods shall be deemed to have been used exclusively in carrying out transactions not giving rise to the right to deduct throughout the year in which the supply was made and in the remaining years until the end of the adjustment period.
The rule laid down in the preceding paragraph shall also apply where the taxpayer uses capital goods for purposes which, under articles 95 and 96 of this Law, entail the application of limitations, exclusions or restrictions on the right to deduct, throughout the year in which those circumstances occur and the remaining years until the end of the adjustment period.
Excepted from the first paragraph of this rule are exempt or non-taxable supplies of capital goods that give rise to the right to deduct, to which the first rule shall apply. The deductions allowable in this case may not exceed the tax that would result from applying the rate in force for supplies of goods of the same kind to the domestic value of the goods exported or dispatched to another Member State of the Community.
Two. The adjustment referred to in this article must be made even where the pro rata rule did not apply in previous years.
Three. This article shall also apply where the capital goods are transferred before their use by the taxpayer.
Four. This article shall in no case apply to the transactions referred to in article 7, number 1st, of this Law.
Where this sits
Previous: Deductions: requirements and limits. Next: Pre-activity deductions and refunds. All parts: contents of the VAT Act.
Related on voixa.es: ROI registration: the intra-EU VAT number; Modelo 036, filled in without mistakes; Verifactu and e-invoicing in Spain.
Nothing here is advice on your own position, and this reading is not the official text. Where the wording matters to a decision, read it against the Spanish original published in the BOE.