Spanish VAT: what counts as a supply of goods or services
Law 37/1992 on Value Added Tax, articles 8 to 12: the concept of a supply of goods, including works contracts, contributions in kind and lease-sale contracts, the definitions of intra-Community distance sales and distance sales of imported goods, and supplies facilitated through digital interfaces. These articles also cover transactions treated as supplies of goods, among them self-supply and transfers of own goods to another Member State, call-off stock arrangements, the concept of processing, the concept of a supply of services and self-supply of services.
Title I. Delimitation of the taxable event (continued)
Chapter I. Supplies of goods and services (continued)
Article 8. Concept of supply of goods
One. A supply of goods means the transfer of the power of disposal over tangible goods, even where it is effected by assigning documents of title representing those goods.
For these purposes, gas, heat, refrigeration, electricity and other forms of energy shall be regarded as tangible goods.
Two. The following shall also be regarded as supplies of goods:
1st Works contracts whose subject matter is the construction or refurbishment of a building, within the meaning of article 6 of this Law, where the business carrying out the works provides part of the materials used, provided that their cost exceeds 40 per cent of the taxable amount.
2nd Non-monetary contributions made by taxpayers of the Tax of elements of their business or professional assets to companies, joint ownership arrangements (comunidades de bienes) or any other type of entity, and allotments of this nature in the event of the liquidation or total or partial dissolution of those entities, without prejudice to the taxation that applies under the rules governing the “documented legal acts” and “corporate transactions” headings of the Tax on Transfers of Assets and Documented Legal Acts.
In particular, the allotment to the co-owners, in proportion to their share of participation, of land or buildings developed by a joint ownership arrangement shall be regarded as a supply of goods.
3rd Transfers of goods under a rule of law or an administrative or judicial decision, including compulsory expropriation.
4th Assignments of goods under contracts of sale with a reservation of title clause or subject to a condition precedent.
5th Assignments of goods under lease-sale contracts and similar contracts.
For the purposes of this tax, leases with an option to purchase shall be treated as lease-sale contracts from the moment the lessee undertakes to exercise that option and, in general, leases of goods with a clause transferring ownership that is binding on both parties.
6th Transfers of goods between a principal and a commission agent acting in his own name, carried out under contracts of commission for sale or commission for purchase.
7th The supply of a standardised software product on any physical medium.
For these purposes, standardised software products are those that do not require any substantial modification in order to be used by any user.
8th Transfers of securities whose holding ensures, in fact or in law, the attribution of ownership, use or enjoyment of immovable property or part of it, in the cases provided for in article 20.One.18th k) of this Law.
Three. For the purposes of this law:
1st “Intra-Community distance sales of goods” means supplies of goods dispatched or transported by the vendor, directly or indirectly, or on his behalf, from a Member State other than the Member State in which the dispatch or transport to the customer ends, where the following conditions are met:
a) The recipients of those supplies are persons whose intra-Community acquisitions of goods are not subject to the tax under article 14 of this Law, or under the equivalent provision applicable in the Member State where the dispatch or transport ends, or any other person who does not have the status of business or professional acting as such.
b) The goods supplied are goods other than the following:
a′) New means of transport, as defined in article 13.2nd of this Law.
b′) Goods installed or assembled as referred to in article 68.Two.2nd of this Law.
2nd “Distance sales of goods imported from third countries or territories” means supplies of goods dispatched or transported by the vendor, directly or indirectly, or on his behalf, from a third country or territory to a customer located in a Member State, where the following conditions are met:
a) The recipients of those supplies are persons whose intra-Community acquisitions of goods are not subject to the tax under article 14 of this Law, or under the equivalent provision applicable in the Member State where the dispatch or transport ends, or any other person who does not have the status of business or professional acting as such.
b) The goods supplied are goods other than the following:
a′) New means of transport, as defined in article 13.2nd of this Law.
b′) Goods installed or assembled as referred to in article 68.Two.2nd of this Law.
Article 8 bis. Supplies of goods facilitated through a digital interface
Where a business or professional, using a digital interface such as an online marketplace, platform, portal or other similar means, facilitates:
a) The distance sale of goods imported from third countries or territories in consignments of an intrinsic value not exceeding 150 euros, or
b) The supply of goods within the Community by a business or professional not established in the Community to a person who does not have the status of business or professional acting as such, the business or professional holding the digital interface shall, in both cases, be deemed to have received and supplied the goods himself, and the dispatch or transport of the goods shall be deemed to be linked to the supply made by him.
For the purposes of this law, the intrinsic value of the goods shall be determined as provided for in customs legislation.
Article 9. Transactions treated as supplies of goods
The following shall be treated as supplies of goods for consideration:
1st Self-supply of goods.
For the purposes of this tax, the following transactions carried out without consideration shall be regarded as self-supplies of goods:
a) The transfer by the taxpayer of tangible goods from his business or professional assets to his personal assets or to his private consumption.
b) The transfer of the power of disposal over tangible goods forming part of the taxpayer’s business or professional assets.
c) The change of assignment of tangible goods from one distinct sector of his business or professional activity to another.
The self-supply referred to in this sub-paragraph c) shall not apply in the following cases:
– Where, as a result of a change in the legislation in force, a particular economic activity is required to become part of a distinct sector different from the one in which it was previously included.
– Where the tax scheme applicable to a particular economic activity changes from the general scheme to the special simplified scheme, the agriculture, livestock and fisheries scheme, the equivalence surcharge scheme or the scheme for transactions in investment gold, or vice versa, including by the exercise of a right of option.
The provisions of the two indents of the preceding paragraph shall be understood, where applicable, to be without prejudice to the following:
– The adjustments of deductions provided for in articles 101, 105, 106, 107, 109, 110, 112 and 113 of this Law.
– The application of paragraph two of article 99 of this Law, concerning the correction of deductions initially made according to the foreseeable use of the goods and services acquired where their actual use turns out to differ from that foreseen, in the case of tax amounts borne or paid on the acquisition or importation of goods or services other than capital goods which had not been used to any extent in the carrying on of the business or professional activity before the time when the economic activity for which they were foreseeably intended at the time the tax was borne becomes part of a distinct sector different from the one in which it was previously included.
– The provisions of articles 134 bis and 155 of this Law, concerning the commencement or cessation of the application of the special agriculture, livestock and fisheries scheme or the equivalence surcharge scheme, respectively.
For the purposes of this Law, the following shall be regarded as distinct sectors of business or professional activity:
a′) Those in which the economic activities carried out and the deduction regimes applicable are different.
Economic activities assigned to different groups in the National Classification of Economic Activities shall be regarded as different economic activities.
Notwithstanding the preceding paragraph, an activity ancillary to another shall not be regarded as different where, in the preceding year, its volume of transactions did not exceed 15 per cent of that of the latter and, in addition, it contributes to carrying it out. If the ancillary activity was not carried on during the preceding year, the requirement relating to that percentage shall apply in the current year according to the taxpayer’s reasonable forecasts, without prejudice to any adjustment that is due if the actual percentage exceeds the limit indicated.
Ancillary activities shall follow the same regime as the activities on which they depend.
The deduction regimes referred to in this letter a′) shall be regarded as different if the deduction percentages, determined in accordance with article 104 of this Law, that would be applicable in the activity or activities other than the main one differ by more than 50 percentage points from that of the main activity.
The main activity, together with the activities ancillary to it and the different economic activities whose deduction percentages do not differ by more than 50 percentage points from that of the main activity, shall constitute a single distinct sector.
Activities other than the main one whose deduction percentages differ by more than 50 percentage points from that of the main activity shall constitute another sector distinct from the main one.
For the purposes of this letter a′), the main activity shall be the one in which the greatest volume of transactions was carried out during the immediately preceding year.
b′) Activities under the special simplified scheme, the agriculture, livestock and fisheries scheme, the scheme for transactions in investment gold or the equivalence surcharge scheme.
c′) The finance lease transactions referred to in the third additional provision of Law 10/2014 of 26 June on the organisation, supervision and solvency of credit institutions.
d′) Transactions involving the assignment of receivables or loans, except those carried out under a factoring contract.
d) The assignment or, where applicable, the change of assignment of goods produced, constructed, extracted, processed, acquired or imported in the course of the taxpayer’s business or professional activity for use as capital goods.
This letter shall not apply in cases where the taxpayer would have been granted the right to deduct in full the Value Added Tax that he would have borne had he acquired goods of an identical nature from third parties.
The right to deduct in full the tax that taxpayers would have borne on acquiring goods of an identical nature shall not be deemed to have been granted where, after they are brought into operation and during the deduction adjustment period, the assigned goods are used for any of the following purposes:
a′) Those which, under articles 95 and 96 of this Law, limit or exclude the right to deduct.
b′) Use in transactions which do not give rise to the right to deduct.
c′) Exclusive use in transactions which give rise to the right to deduct, where the general pro rata rule is applicable.
d′) The making of a supply exempt from the tax which does not give rise to the right to deduct.
2nd (Deleted)
3rd The transfer by a taxpayer of tangible goods of his business to another Member State, to be assigned to the needs of that business in the latter Member State. Transfers carried out under a call-off stock arrangement on the terms provided for in article 9 bis of this Law shall not be so regarded.
Transfers of goods used to carry out the following transactions shall be excluded from this number:
a) Supplies of those goods by the taxpayer which would be regarded as carried out within the Member State where the dispatch or transport ends under the criteria contained in article 68, paragraph two, number 2nd, and paragraphs three and four, of this Law.
b) Supplies of those goods by the taxpayer referred to in article 68, paragraph two, number 4th, of this Law.
c) Supplies of those goods by the taxpayer within the country under the conditions provided for in article 21 or article 25 of this Law.
d) Works carried out for the taxpayer, where the goods are used by the business carrying out the works in the Member State where the dispatch or transport of those goods ends, provided that the work manufactured or assembled is the subject of a supply that is exempt under the criteria contained in articles 21 and 25 of this Law.
e) The supply of a service to the taxpayer consisting of expert valuations of, or work on, those goods in the Member State where their dispatch or transport ends, provided that, after those services, the goods are dispatched back to the taxpayer in the territory where the Tax applies.
That work includes repairs and works which must be classified as supplies of services under article 11 of this Law.
f) Temporary use of those goods, in the territory of the Member State where their dispatch or transport ends, in supplies of services carried out by the taxpayer established in Spain.
g) Temporary use of those goods, for a period not exceeding twenty-four months, in the territory of another Member State within which the importation of the same goods from a third country for temporary use would qualify for the temporary importation procedure with full exemption from import duties.
h) Supplies of gas through a natural gas system situated within the territory of the Community or any network connected to such a system, supplies of electricity, or supplies of heat or refrigeration through heating or cooling networks, which would be regarded as carried out in another Member State of the Community under the criteria laid down in article 68.Six of this Law.
The exclusions referred to in letters a) to h) above shall cease to have effect from the moment any of the requirements on which they depend ceases to be met.
Article 9 bis. Call-off stock arrangement
One. For the purposes of this Law, a call-off stock arrangement (acuerdo de ventas de bienes en consigna) is one that meets the following requirements:
a) The goods are dispatched or transported to another Member State by the vendor, or by a third party in his name and on his behalf, so that they may be acquired, at a later stage after their arrival, by another business or professional entitled to do so, in accordance with a prior agreement between both parties.
b) The vendor dispatching or transporting the goods does not have the seat of his economic activity or a permanent establishment in the Member State where their dispatch or transport ends.
c) The business or professional who is to acquire the goods is identified for Value Added Tax purposes in the Member State where the dispatch or transport ends, and that tax identification number, together with his full name or full company or corporate name, is known to the vendor at the time the dispatch or transport begins.
d) The vendor has entered the dispatch of those goods both in the register book determined by regulation and in the recapitulative statement referred to in article 164, paragraph one, number 5th, of this Law, in the manner determined by regulation.
Two. Where, within the twelve months following the arrival of the goods in the Member State of destination under a call-off stock arrangement, the business or professional mentioned in letter c) of the preceding paragraph, or in letter a′) of the second sub-paragraph of the following paragraph, acquires the power of disposal over the goods, there shall be deemed to be carried out in the territory where the Tax applies, as the case may be:
a) A supply of goods of the type provided for in article 68, paragraph two, number 1st, letter A), first sub-paragraph, of this Law, by the vendor, to which the exemption provided for in article 25 of this Law shall apply, or
b) an intra-Community acquisition of goods of the type provided for in article 15, paragraph one, letter b), of this Law, by the business or professional who acquires them.
Three. A transfer of goods as referred to in article 9.3rd of this Law shall be deemed to have taken place where, under a call-off stock arrangement and within the twelve-month period provided for in the preceding paragraph, any of the conditions laid down in paragraph one above ceases to be met, in particular:
a) Where the goods have not been acquired by the business or professional for whom they were initially intended.
b) Where the goods are dispatched or transported to a destination other than the Member State for which they were initially intended under the call-off stock arrangement.
c) In the event of destruction, loss or theft of the goods.
However, the requirements of paragraph one above shall be deemed to be met where, within that period:
a′) The goods are acquired by a business or professional who replaces the one referred to in letter c) of paragraph one above, in compliance with the requirements provided for in that letter.
b′) The power of disposal over the goods has not been transferred and they are returned to the Member State from which they were dispatched or transported.
c′) The circumstances provided for in letters a′) and b′) have been entered by the vendor in the register book determined by regulation.
Four. Where, under a call-off stock arrangement and with the conditions provided for in paragraph one above being met, the business or professional mentioned in letter c) of paragraph one, or in letter a′) of the second sub-paragraph of paragraph three of article 9 bis, has not acquired the power of disposal over the goods by the expiry of the period of 12 months from the arrival of the goods in the Member State of destination, a transfer of goods as referred to in article 9.3rd of this Law shall be deemed to have taken place on the day following that expiry.
Five. Businesses or professionals who enter into a call-off stock arrangement, and those who replace the person for whom the goods were initially intended, must keep a register book of these transactions under the conditions laid down by regulation.
Article 10. Concept of processing
Save as specifically provided in other provisions of this Law, processing means any alteration of goods which changes the specific purposes for which they could be used.
Article 11. Concept of supply of services
One. For the purposes of Value Added Tax, a supply of services means any transaction subject to that tax which, under this Law, is not regarded as a supply, intra-Community acquisition or importation of goods.
Two. In particular, the following shall be regarded as supplies of services:
1st The independent exercise of a profession, art or trade.
2nd Leases of goods, of industrial undertakings or businesses, or of enterprises or commercial establishments, with or without an option to purchase.
3rd Assignments of the use or enjoyment of goods.
4th Assignments and grants of copyright, licences, patents, manufacturing and trade marks and other intellectual and industrial property rights.
5th Obligations to do or not to do and abstentions stipulated in agency or exclusive sale contracts or arising from agreements for the distribution of goods in defined territorial areas.
6th Works contracts that are not regarded as supplies of goods under article 8 of this Law.
7th Transfers of business premises (traspasos de locales de negocio).
8th Transport.
9th Hotel, restaurant or camping services and sales of food or drink for immediate consumption on the premises.
10th Insurance, reinsurance and capitalisation transactions.
11th Hospitalisation services.
12th Loans and credits in money.
13th The right to use sports or recreational facilities.
14th The operation of fairs and exhibitions.
15th Intermediation transactions and agency or commission transactions where the agent or commission agent acts in the name of another. Where he acts in his own name and takes part in a supply of services, he shall be deemed to have received and supplied the relevant services himself.
16th The supply of software products where it does not qualify as a supply of goods, the supply of the corresponding medium being regarded as ancillary to the supply of services.
In particular, the supply of software products produced to the order of the recipient in accordance with the recipient’s specifications shall be regarded as a supply of services, as shall that of other software products that are subject to substantial adaptations necessary for use by the recipient.
Article 12. Transactions treated as supplies of services
Self-supplies of services shall be treated as supplies of services for consideration.
For the purposes of this tax, the following transactions carried out without consideration shall be self-supplies of services:
1st Transfers of goods and rights not covered by article 9, number 1st, of this Law, from the business or professional assets to the personal assets of the taxpayer.
2nd The total or partial application of goods forming part of the taxpayer’s business or professional assets to his private use or, in general, to purposes unrelated to his business or professional activity.
3rd Other supplies of services carried out free of charge by the taxpayer not mentioned in the preceding numbers of this article, provided that they are carried out for purposes unrelated to those of the business or professional activity.
Where this sits
Previous: Scope, taxable event and taxable persons. Next: Intra-Community acquisitions and imports. All parts: contents of the VAT Act.
Related on voixa.es: ROI registration: the intra-EU VAT number; Modelo 036, filled in without mistakes; Verifactu and e-invoicing in Spain.
Nothing here is advice on your own position, and this reading is not the official text. Where the wording matters to a decision, read it against the Spanish original published in the BOE.