Spanish VAT: the taxable amount and when it can be reduced
Law 37/1992 on Value Added Tax, articles 78 to 83: what is included in and excluded from the taxable amount, the special rules for consideration not in money, mixed supplies, self-supply, related parties and market value, commission agents, gold and foreign currency. They also cover reductions of the taxable amount for returns, discounts, cancellations, insolvency proceedings and bad debts, the methods for determining the taxable amount, and the taxable amount of intra-Community acquisitions and importations.
Title V. Taxable amount
Chapter I. Supplies of goods and services
Article 78. Taxable amount. General rule
One. The taxable amount shall consist of the total amount of the consideration for the transactions subject to the tax obtained from the recipient or from third parties.
Two. In particular, the following are included in the concept of consideration:
1st Commission costs, packing and transport costs, insurance, premiums for advance performance and any other actual claim in favour of the person making the supply of goods or supplying the service, arising from the principal supply or from supplies ancillary to it.
Notwithstanding the provisions of the preceding paragraph, interest for deferred payment of the price shall not be included in the consideration to the extent that the deferral corresponds to a period after the supply of the goods or services.
For the purposes of the preceding paragraph, only the remuneration for financial transactions of deferral or delay in payment of the price that are exempt from the tax under article 20, paragraph One, number 18th, letter c), of this Law and that is stated separately on the invoice issued by the taxpayer shall be regarded as interest.
In no case shall the part of the consideration that exceeds the rate usually applied in the market for similar transactions be regarded as interest.
2nd (Repealed)
3rd Subsidies directly linked to the price of the transactions subject to the tax.
Subsidies established according to the number of units supplied or the volume of services supplied shall be regarded as directly linked to the price of the transactions subject to the tax when they are determined before the transaction is carried out.
However, monetary contributions, whatever their name, made by public administrations to finance the following shall not be regarded as subsidies linked to the price and shall in no case form part of the amount of the consideration referred to in paragraph One of this article:
a) The management of public services or of the promotion of culture in which there is no significant distortion of competition, whatever the form of management.
b) Activities of general interest where their recipients are not identifiable and pay no consideration.
4th Taxes and levies of any kind charged on the same taxed transactions, except value added tax itself.
This number shall include the excise duties charged in relation to the goods that are the subject of the taxed transactions, with the exception of the excise duty on certain means of transport.
5th Amounts lawfully retained by the person obliged to make the supply in cases where the transactions subject to the tax are terminated.
6th The amount of containers and packaging, including returnable ones, charged to the recipients of the transaction, whatever the heading under which that amount is received.
7th The amount of debts assumed by the recipient of the transactions subject to the tax as total or partial consideration for them.
Three. The following shall not be included in the taxable amount:
1st Amounts received by way of compensation, other than those referred to in the preceding paragraph, which by their nature and function do not constitute consideration or compensation for the supplies of goods or services subject to the tax.
2nd Discounts and rebates that are substantiated by any means of proof admissible in law and that are granted before or at the time when the transaction is carried out and on account of it.
The provisions of the preceding paragraph shall not apply where the price reductions constitute remuneration for other transactions.
3rd Sums paid in the name and on behalf of the customer under the customer’s express instructions. The taxpayer shall be required to substantiate the actual amount of such expenses and may not deduct any tax that may have been charged on them.
Four. Where the value added tax amounts on the transactions subject to that tax have not been expressly charged on the invoice, the consideration shall be deemed not to have included those amounts.
The following are excepted from the provisions of the preceding paragraph:
1st Cases in which express charging of the tax was not mandatory.
2nd The cases referred to in paragraph Two, number 5th of this article.
Article 79. Taxable amount. Special rules
One. In transactions whose consideration does not consist of money, the taxable amount shall be the amount, expressed in money, agreed between the parties.
Unless proved otherwise, the taxable amount shall coincide with the amounts resulting from applying the rules in paragraphs Three and Four below.
However, if the consideration consists partly of money, the taxable amount shall be the result of adding to the amount, expressed in money, agreed between the parties for the non-monetary part of the consideration, the amount of the monetary part, provided that that result is higher than the amount determined by applying the preceding paragraphs.
Two. Where, in a single transaction and for a single price, goods are supplied or services of different kinds are supplied, including in cases of transfer of all or part of a business’s assets, the taxable amount corresponding to each of them shall be determined in proportion to the market value of the goods supplied or the services supplied.
The provisions of the preceding paragraph shall not apply where those goods or services are the subject of supplies ancillary to a principal supply subject to the tax.
Three. In the cases of self-supply and transfer of goods included in article 9, numbers 1st and 3rd, of this Law, the following rules shall apply to determine the taxable amount:
1st If the goods are supplied in the same state in which they were acquired without having undergone any process of manufacture, processing or transformation by the taxpayer itself or on its behalf, the taxable amount shall be that set in the transaction by which those goods were acquired.
In the case of imported goods, the taxable amount shall be that which would have applied for the assessment of the tax on their importation.
2nd If the goods supplied have undergone processes of processing or transformation by the transferor or on its behalf, the taxable amount shall be the cost of the goods or services used by the taxpayer to obtain those goods, including staff costs incurred for the same purpose.
3rd However, if the value of the goods supplied has changed as a result of their use, deterioration, obsolescence, loss of value, revaluation or any other cause, the taxable amount shall be the value of the goods at the time of the supply.
For the purposes of rule 3rd above, total deterioration shall be presumed to have taken place where the transactions referred to in this paragraph Three relate to goods acquired by non-profit entities defined in accordance with article 2 of Law 49/2002 of 23 December on the tax regime for non-profit entities and tax incentives for patronage, provided that those entities use them for the purposes of general interest that they pursue in accordance with article 3, paragraph 1st, of that Law.
Four. In cases of self-supply of services, the taxable amount shall be the cost of supplying the services including, where applicable, the depreciation of the goods made available.
Five. Where there is a relationship between the parties to a transaction, its taxable amount shall be its normal market value.
The relationship may be proved by any of the means admissible in law. A relationship shall be deemed to exist in the following cases:
a) Where one of the parties is a taxpayer of corporate income tax or a taxpayer of personal income tax or of non-resident income tax, when this follows from the applicable rules governing those taxes.
b) In transactions between taxpayers and the persons bound to them by employment or administrative relationships.
c) In transactions between the taxpayer and its spouse or its blood relatives up to and including the third degree.
d) In transactions between a non-profit entity referred to in article 2 of Law 49/2002 of 23 December on the tax regime for non-profit entities and tax incentives for patronage and its founders, associates, trustees, statutory representatives, members of its governing bodies, or the spouses or relatives up to and including the third degree of any of them.
e) In transactions between an entity that is a business or professional and any of its partners, associates, members or participants.
This valuation rule shall apply only when the following requirements are met:
a) That the recipient of the transaction is not entitled to deduct in full the tax corresponding to it and the agreed consideration is lower than that which would apply under conditions of free competition.
b) Where the business or professional making the supply of goods or services determines its deductions by applying the pro rata rule and, in the case of a transaction that does not give rise to the right to deduct, the agreed consideration is lower than the normal market value.
c) Where the business or professional making the supply of goods or services determines its deductions by applying the pro rata rule and, in the case of a transaction that gives rise to the right to deduct, the agreed consideration is higher than the normal market value.
For the purposes of this Law, normal market value means the amount that a recipient, at the same marketing stage as that at which the supply of goods or services is made, would have to pay in the territory where the tax applies, under conditions of free competition, to an independent supplier in order to acquire the goods or services in question at that same time.
Where there is no comparable supply of goods or services, market value means:
a) In respect of supplies of goods, an amount equal to or higher than the purchase price of those goods or of similar goods or, in the absence of a purchase price, their cost price, determined at the time of the supply.
b) In respect of supplies of services, the full cost to the business or professional of supplying the service.
For the purposes of the two preceding paragraphs, article 16 of the consolidated text of the Corporate Income Tax Law, approved by Royal Legislative Decree 4/2004 of 5 March, shall apply as appropriate.
Six. In transfers of goods from the principal to the commission agent under sale-on-commission contracts in which the commission agent acts in its own name, the taxable amount shall consist of the consideration agreed by the commission agent less the amount of the commission.
Seven. In transfers of goods from the commission agent to the principal under purchase-on-commission contracts in which the commission agent has acted in its own name, the taxable amount shall consist of the consideration agreed by the commission agent plus the amount of the commission.
Eight. In supplies of services made on behalf of a third party, where the person supplying the services acts in its own name, the taxable amount of the transaction between the principal and the commission agent shall consist of the consideration for the service agreed by the commission agent less the amount of the commission.
Nine. In acquisitions of services made on behalf of third parties, where the person acquiring the services acts in its own name, the taxable amount of the transaction between the commission agent and the principal shall consist of the consideration for the service agreed by the commission agent plus the amount of the commission.
Ten. In supplies of goods or services that do not have investment gold as their object or result and in which gold provided by the recipient of the transaction is used whose acquisition or importation was exempt under the exemption in paragraph One, number 1st of article 140 bis of this Law or its equivalent in the legislation of another Member State of the Community, the taxable amount shall be the result of adding to the total amount of the consideration the market value of that gold, determined on the date on which the tax becomes chargeable.
Eleven. In transactions whose consideration has been set in a currency other than the Spanish currency, the selling exchange rate set by the Bank of Spain in force at the time of chargeability shall apply.
Twelve. In the taxable amount of the transactions referred to in the preceding paragraphs, the expenses or components included, respectively, in paragraphs Two and Three of the preceding article shall be included or excluded, as appropriate.
Article 80. Modification of the taxable amount
One. The taxable amount determined in accordance with articles 78 and 79 above shall be reduced by the following amounts:
1st The amount of reusable containers and packaging that have been returned.
2nd Discounts and rebates granted after the time when the transaction was carried out, provided that they are duly substantiated.
Two. Where, by a final judicial or administrative decision, or in accordance with law or commercial usage, the taxed transactions are wholly or partly cancelled, or the price is altered after the time when the transaction was carried out, the taxable amount shall be modified by the corresponding amount.
Three. The taxable amount may be reduced where the recipient of the transactions subject to the tax has not paid the tax amounts charged and provided that, after the tax on the transaction has become chargeable, an order declaring insolvency proceedings (auto de declaración de concurso) is issued. The modification, where applicable, may not be made after the expiry of a period of two months counted from the end of the maximum period set in number 5th of paragraph 1 of article 21 of Law 22/2003 of 9 July, the Insolvency Law.
Only where the closure of the insolvency proceedings is ordered on the grounds set out in article 176.1, paragraphs 1st, 4th and 5th of the Insolvency Law shall the creditor that modified the taxable amount be required to modify it upwards again by issuing, within the period set by regulation, a corrective invoice charging the appropriate tax amount.
Four. The taxable amount may also be reduced proportionately where the claims corresponding to the tax amounts charged on the taxed transactions are wholly or partly uncollectable. For these purposes:
A) A claim shall be regarded as wholly or partly uncollectable when it meets the following conditions:
1st That one year has elapsed since the tax charged became chargeable without all or part of the claim arising from it having been collected.
However, in the case of instalment transactions or transactions with a deferred price, one year must have elapsed since the due date of the unpaid instalment or instalments in order to reduce the taxable amount proportionately. For these purposes, instalment transactions or transactions with a deferred price are those in which it has been agreed that the consideration is to be paid in successive payments or in a single payment, respectively, provided that the period between the chargeability of the tax charged and the due date of the last or only payment is more than one year.
Where the holder of the claim whose taxable amount is to be reduced is a business or professional whose volume of transactions, calculated in accordance with article 121 of this Law, did not exceed 6,010,121.04 euros during the immediately preceding calendar year, the period referred to in this condition 1st may be six months or one year.
In the case of transactions to which the special cash accounting scheme applies, this condition shall be deemed to be met on the date on which the tax becomes chargeable by application of the deadline of 31 December referred to in article 163 terdecies of this Law.
Notwithstanding the provisions of the preceding paragraph, in the case of instalment transactions or transactions with a deferred price, the period of six months or one year referred to in this rule 1st must have elapsed from the due date of the corresponding instalment or instalments up to the date on which the transaction becomes chargeable.
2nd That this circumstance has been reflected in the record books required for this tax.
3rd That the recipient of the transaction acts in the capacity of a business or professional or, otherwise, that the taxable amount of the transaction, excluding value added tax, is more than 50 euros.
4th That the taxpayer has sought collection by a court claim against the debtor or by a notarial demand served on the debtor, or by any other means that reliably evidences the claim for collection against the debtor, including where the claims are guaranteed by public bodies.
In the case of the instalment transactions referred to in condition 1st above, it shall be sufficient to seek collection of one of the instalments by any of the means referred to in condition 4th above in order to modify the taxable amount in the proportion corresponding to the unpaid instalment or instalments.
In the case of claims owed by public bodies, the means referred to in condition 4th above shall be replaced by a certificate issued by the competent body of the debtor public body, in accordance with the report of its Comptroller or Treasurer, recording the acknowledgement of the obligation owed by it and its amount.
B) The modification must be made within the six months following the end of the period of six months or one year referred to in condition 1st above and notified to the State Tax Administration Agency within the period set by regulation.
In the case of transactions to which the special cash accounting scheme applies, the six-month period for making the modification shall be counted from the deadline of 31 December referred to in article 163 terdecies of this Law.
C) Once the taxable amount has been reduced, it shall not be modified upwards again even if the taxpayer obtains total or partial payment of the consideration, except where the recipient does not act in the capacity of a business or professional. In that case, value added tax shall be deemed to be included in the amounts received, in the same proportion as the part of the consideration received.
Notwithstanding the provisions of the preceding paragraph, where the taxpayer withdraws the court claim against the debtor or reaches an agreement on payment with the debtor after the notarial demand has been served, as a result of the demand or for any other reason, it shall modify the taxable amount upwards again by issuing, within one month of the withdrawal or of the payment agreement respectively, a corrective invoice charging the appropriate tax amount.
Five. In relation to the cases of modification of the taxable amount included in paragraphs Three and Four above, the following rules shall apply:
1st The taxable amount may not be modified in the following cases:
a) Claims secured by a right in rem, to the extent secured.
b) Claims guaranteed by credit institutions or mutual guarantee companies, or covered by a credit insurance or surety insurance contract, to the extent guaranteed or insured.
c) Claims between related persons or entities as defined in article 79, paragraph Five, of this Law.
d) Claims owed or guaranteed by public bodies.
The provisions of this letter d) shall not apply to the reduction of the taxable amount made in accordance with paragraph Four of article 80 of this Law for claims regarded as wholly or partly uncollectable, without prejudice to the need to meet the requirement of documentary evidence of non-payment referred to in condition 4th of that provision.
2nd Nor may the taxable amount be modified where the recipient of the transactions is not established in the territory where the tax applies, or in the Canary Islands, Ceuta or Melilla.
Excluded from the provisions of the preceding paragraph are cases of claims that are uncollectable as a result of insolvency proceedings declared by a court of another Member State where they are insolvency proceedings to which Regulation (EU) 2015/848 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 May 2015 on insolvency proceedings applies; these may, where applicable, give rise to the modification of the taxpayer’s taxable amount on the terms provided for in article 80.Three of this Law.
3rd Nor may the taxable amount be modified in accordance with paragraph Four of article 80 of this Law after the order declaring insolvency proceedings, for claims corresponding to tax amounts charged on transactions that became chargeable before that order.
4th In cases of partial payment before that modification, value added tax shall be deemed to be included in the amounts received, in the same proportion as the part of the consideration paid.
5th The correction of the deductions of the recipient of the transactions, which must be made in accordance with article 114, paragraph Two, number 2nd, fourth paragraph, of this Law, shall give rise to the corresponding claim in favour of the Public Treasury.
If the recipient of the transactions subject to the tax was not entitled to deduct the tax in full, it shall also be a debtor to the Public Treasury for the amount of the non-deductible tax. Where the recipient does not act in the capacity of a business or professional, and to the extent that it has not paid that debt, the provisions of paragraph Four C) above shall apply.
Six. If the amount of the consideration is not known at the time the tax becomes chargeable, the taxpayer shall set it provisionally by applying reasoned criteria, without prejudice to its correction when that amount becomes known.
Seven. In the cases referred to in the preceding paragraphs, the modification of the taxable amount shall be conditional on compliance with the requirements laid down by regulation.
Article 81. Determination of the taxable amount
One. As a general rule, the taxable amount shall be determined under the direct assessment method, with no exceptions other than those established in this Law and in the rules governing the indirect assessment of taxable amounts.
The application of the indirect assessment method shall cover the amount of the acquisitions of goods and services made by the taxpayer and the input tax borne on them.
Two. The objective assessment method (estimación objetiva) for determining the taxable amount may be established by regulation for the sectors or economic activities and with the limitations specified.
In no case shall this method apply to supplies of immovable property or to the transactions referred to in articles 9, number 1st, letters c) and d), 13, 17 and 84, paragraph One, number 2nd, of this Law.
Three. Where returns are not filed, the provisions of article 168 of this Law on provisional assessment by the tax administration of its own motion shall apply.
Chapter II. Intra-Community acquisitions of goods
Article 82. Taxable amount
One. The taxable amount of intra-Community acquisitions of goods shall be determined in accordance with the preceding chapter.
In particular, in the acquisitions referred to in article 16, number 2nd, of this Law, the taxable amount shall be determined in accordance with article 79, paragraph Three, of this Law.
Where the acquirer obtains a refund of excise duties in the Member State from which the goods are dispatched or transported, its tax position shall be adjusted in the manner determined by regulation.
Two. Where article 71, paragraph Two, applies, the taxable amount shall be that corresponding to the intra-Community acquisitions that have not been taxed in the Member State of arrival of the dispatch or transport of the goods.
Chapter III. Importations
Article 83. Taxable amount
One. General rule.
In importations of goods, the taxable amount shall be the result of adding to the customs value the following items, to the extent that they are not included in it:
a) Taxes, duties, levies and other charges that become chargeable outside the territory where the tax applies, and those that become chargeable by reason of the importation, with the exception of value added tax.
b) Incidental expenses, such as commission, packing, transport and insurance costs, incurred up to the first place of destination of the goods within the Community.
“First place of destination” means the place indicated on the consignment note or on any other document under which the goods enter the Community. In the absence of such an indication, the first place of destination shall be deemed to be the place where the first break of bulk of the goods takes place within the Community.
Two. Special rules.
1st The taxable amount of reimportations of goods temporarily exported outside the Community to undergo repair, transformation or adaptation work or work to order shall be the consideration for that work determined according to the rules in Chapter I of this Title.
The items referred to in letters a) and b) of the preceding paragraph shall also be included in the taxable amount where they are not included in the consideration defined in the preceding paragraph.
2nd The taxable amount of the importations referred to in article 19, numbers 1st, 2nd and 3rd, shall include the amount of the consideration for all transactions relating to the means of transport concerned, carried out before those importations, that benefited from exemption from the tax.
3rd In the importations referred to in article 18, paragraphs Two and Three, of this Law, where the goods have been the subject of supplies of goods or services that were exempt from the tax under article 23 or article 24 of this Law, the taxable amount shall be the result of adding to the corresponding consideration the services that were exempt:
i. The value resulting from the application of paragraph One above or, where applicable,
ii. the consideration for the last supply made while those customs or tax arrangements applied, or while the goods were in the situations governed by that provision.
4th The taxable amount of goods leaving the arrangements for tax warehouses other than customs warehouses, where this does not give rise to the taxable event of importation under article 18.Three of this Law but to a transaction treated as an importation, shall be as follows:
a) For goods coming from another Member State or from third countries, the amount resulting from applying, respectively, the rules in article 82 or in paragraph One of this article or, where applicable, the amount corresponding to the last supply made in that warehouse.
b) For goods coming from within the country, the amount corresponding to the last exempt supply of those goods.
c) For goods resulting from processes of incorporation or transformation of the goods included in the preceding letters, the sum of the taxable amounts resulting from applying the rules in those letters.
d) In all cases, it shall include the amount of the consideration for the services exempt from the tax supplied after the importation, intra-Community acquisition or, where applicable, last supply of the goods.
e) In all cases of removal from the arrangements for tax warehouses other than customs warehouses, the excise duty chargeable on leaving those arrangements shall, where applicable, be included in the taxable amount.
5th The taxable amount of the other transactions referred to in article 19, number 5th, of this Law shall be the sum of the consideration for the last supply or intra-Community acquisition of goods and for the services supplied after that supply or acquisition, all of them exempt from the tax, determined in accordance with Chapters I and II of this Title.
6th In importations of standardised computer products, the taxable amount shall be that corresponding to the carrier medium and to the programmes or information incorporated in it.
Three. The rules in article 80 of this Law shall also apply, where appropriate, to the determination of the taxable amount of importations.
Four. Where the elements determining the taxable amount have been set in a currency other than the Spanish currency, the exchange rate shall be determined in accordance with the Community provisions in force for calculating the customs value.
Where this sits
Previous: Intra-Community place rules and chargeability. Next: Taxpayers, liability and charging VAT. All parts: contents of the VAT Act.
Related on voixa.es: ROI registration: the intra-EU VAT number; Modelo 036, filled in without mistakes; Verifactu and e-invoicing in Spain.
Nothing here is advice on your own position, and this reading is not the official text. Where the wording matters to a decision, read it against the Spanish original published in the BOE.