The owners’ meeting in Catalonia: calling it, voting and majorities
Catalan Civil Code, Book V, articles 553-15 to 553-32: the chair, secretary and administrator; eight days’ notice of a meeting; why an owner in arrears cannot vote; the simple majority for lifts, accessibility and energy works; unanimity and four fifths for the rest; the month in which an absent owner’s silence counts as a yes; and the one-year and three-month limits for challenging a resolution.
An owner abroad votes yes by staying silent
Catalan meetings work on a rule a non-resident owner needs to know. For decisions requiring unanimity or four fifths, the vote is not closed at the meeting. The minutes are sent out, and under article 553-26.3 every owner who did not attend and does not object in writing within one month of notification is counted as having voted with the majority. For a simple majority, the same month decides whether an absent owner can challenge the resolution or escape the cost of a new service. An owner who does not read the community’s post can find that they approved a statutes change they never saw.
Book V, Title V, Chapter III (continued)
Subsection 3. Bodies of the community
Article 553-15. Organisation of the community
1. The bodies of the community are the chair, the secretary and the owners’ meeting. The first two are single-person offices. The office of chair must be held by an owner. The office of secretary may be held by an owner or by the person outside the community who assumes the functions of administration.
2. The community may entrust its administration to an external professional who meets the legally required professional conditions. In that case the functions of administration also include those of secretary.
3. The office-holders are appointed by the owners’ meeting, to which they answer for their actions. They may also be appointed by the developer of the property, in which case they hold office until the first meeting of the owners.
4. Office-holders may be re-elected, serve for one year and are deemed extended until the ordinary meeting following the end of the term for which they were appointed.
5. Holding office is compulsory, although the owners’ meeting may consider well-founded grounds for excuse. In the absence of candidates, the appointment is made by rotation or by drawing lots among those who have not held the office.
6. Offices are unpaid, unless held by persons outside the community, in which case they may be paid. In any event, office-holders are entitled to be reimbursed for expenses incurred in holding office.
7. The statutes may regulate the creation of other bodies in addition to those established in paragraph 1.
8. There must be no discrimination of any kind on grounds of sex, sexual orientation, origin or beliefs, or on any other ground, in the appointment of office-holders.
9. Where there are fewer than three owners, and while that situation continues, the organisation of the community operates under the regime that article 552-7 establishes for the ordinary undivided community.
Article 553-16. Chair
1. The chair has the following functions:
a) To call and chair the meetings of the owners.
b) To represent the community in and out of court.
c) To have resolutions executed as public instruments, where appropriate.
d) To ensure the proper functioning of the community and the performance of the duties of the secretary and the administrator.
e) Any other functions established by law.
2. The owners’ meeting may appoint a vice-chair, who exercises the chair’s functions in the event of the holder’s death, impossibility, absence or incapacity. The vice-chair may also exercise the functions expressly delegated by the chair.
Article 553-17. Secretary
The secretary draws up the minutes of meetings, makes the notifications, issues the certificates and keeps, for at least five years, the notices of meetings, communications, powers of attorney, accounting documents and other relevant documents of the meetings and of the community. The custody and keeping of the minute books are regulated by article 553-28.
Article 553-18. Administration
1. The administrator manages the ordinary business of the community and has the following functions:
a) To take appropriate measures and carry out the acts necessary to preserve the property and the proper functioning of the community’s services.
b) To ensure that the owners perform their obligations and give them the relevant warnings.
c) To prepare the annual accounts for the previous financial year and the budget.
d) To implement the resolutions of the owners’ meeting and to make the appropriate collections and payments.
e) To decide on the execution of urgent conservation and repair works, reporting all of this immediately to the chair.
f) To pay, with the chair’s authorisation, urgent expenses that may be charged to the reserve fund.
g) Any other functions expressly delegated by the owners’ meeting or attributed by law.
2. The administrator answers for its actions to the owners’ meeting.
Article 553-19. Owners’ meeting
1. The owners’ meeting, made up of all the owners of private elements, is the supreme body of the community.
2. The owners’ meeting has the powers not expressly attributed to other bodies and, as a minimum, the following:
a) The appointment and removal of the persons who are to hold or who hold the community’s offices.
b) The modification of the constitutive title.
c) The approval and modification of the statutes and the internal regulations.
d) The approval of the budgets and annual accounts.
e) The approval of unbudgeted ordinary repairs and of extraordinary and improvement repairs, of their amount and of the imposition of levies to finance them.
f) The establishment or modification of the general criteria for fixing or modifying quotas.
g) The voluntary extinction of the regime.
Article 553-20. Meetings
1. The owners’ meeting must meet in ordinary session once a year to approve the accounts and the budget and to elect the persons who are to hold office.
2. The owners’ meeting must meet when the chair considers it appropriate and when requested by at least one quarter of the owners, or by those representing one quarter of the participation quotas.
3. The statutes may provide for special meetings to deal with matters affecting only certain owners or, where appropriate, the sub-communities.
4. The owners’ meeting may meet without notice if all the owners attend and agree unanimously to hold the meeting and on its agenda.
Article 553-21. Notices of meeting
1. The chair calls the meetings of the owners. In the event of vacancy, inactivity or refusal of the chair, the meeting may be called by the vice-chair or, in the event of vacancy, inactivity or refusal of the vice-chair, by the owners promoting the meeting in accordance with article 553-20.2.
2. Notices, summonses and notifications, unless the statutes expressly provide otherwise, must be sent at least eight calendar days in advance to the address notified by the owner to the secretary. They may be sent by post or e-mail, or by other means of communication, provided that the authenticity of the communication and its content is guaranteed. If the owner has not notified any address, they must be sent to the private element the owner holds. In addition, the notice of meeting must be published with the same advance notice on the community’s notice board or in a visible place set aside for that purpose. That notice has the effect of actual notification where personal notification has not succeeded.
3. In the case of extraordinary meetings to deal with urgent matters, it is only necessary that the owners have been able to learn of the notices, summonses and notifications before the date on which the meeting is to be held.
4. The notice of the owners’ meeting must state clearly and in detail:
a) The agenda. If the meeting is called at the request of promoting owners, the items they propose must appear on it. The agenda includes, among other matters, those proposed in writing to the chair, before the notice is issued, by any of the owners.
b) The day, place and time of the meeting.
c) The warning that, as regards the resolutions referred to in article 553-26, the votes of owners who do not attend the meeting are counted in the direction of the resolution adopted by the majority, without prejudice to their right to object.
d) The list of owners with debts outstanding to the community for quotas, who, in accordance with article 553-24, may speak but have no right to vote, of all of which a warning must be given.
5. The documentation relating to the matters to be dealt with must be sent to the owners together with the notice, or the place where it is available must be indicated. If the functions of administration of the community are carried out by an external professional, that professional must make the documentation available to the owners from the moment the notice is sent.
Article 553-22. Attendance
1. The right to attend the meeting belongs to the owners, who attend in person or by legal, corporate or voluntary representation, which must be evidenced in writing. The statutes may provide, or the owners’ meeting may agree, that attendance may be by videoconference or other similar synchronous telematic means of communication.
2. The right to attend includes the right to speak and the right to vote at the owners’ meeting, without prejudice to article 553-24.
3. Where a private element is held in common, the co-holders designate one of them to exercise the right to attend the owners’ meeting.
4. In usufruct, the bare owners, unless they have stated otherwise, are deemed to be represented by the usufructuaries. Representation must be express if resolutions are to be adopted on the constitutive title, the statutes and extraordinary or improvement works.
Article 553-23. Constitution
1. The owners’ meeting is validly constituted whatever the number of owners attending and the quotas they hold or represent.
2. If neither the chair nor the vice-chair attends, the owners’ meeting designates one of the owners present to chair it.
3. If the secretary does not attend, the owners’ meeting designates one of those present.
Article 553-24. Right to vote
1. Owners who have no debts outstanding to the community when the meeting is held are entitled to vote at the meeting. Owners with debts outstanding to the community are entitled to vote if they show that they have deposited the amount with the court or a notary or have challenged the debt in court.
2. The right to vote is exercised in the following ways:
a) In person.
b) By representation, in accordance with article 553-22.1.
c) By delegation to another owner, made in writing naming the delegate, in which the direction of the vote on the items on the agenda may be indicated. The delegation must be made for a specific meeting of the owners and must be received before it begins.
3. The votes of those who abstain and the vote corresponding to the private elements of common benefit are counted in the same direction as that of the majority obtained.
Article 553-25. General rules for adopting resolutions
1. Resolutions may be adopted only on matters included in the agenda.
2. Resolutions concerning the following are adopted by a simple majority of the owners who have taken part in each vote, which must at the same time represent a simple majority of their total participation quotas:
a) The execution of works or the establishment of services intended to remove architectural barriers, or the installation of lifts, even if the resolution entails modifying the constitutive title and the statutes or the works or services affect the structure or the exterior configuration.
b) Innovations required for the habitability, accessibility, safety of the property or energy or water efficiency according to its nature and characteristics, even if the resolution entails modifying the constitutive title and the statutes or affects the structure or the exterior configuration.
c) The execution of works to install common infrastructure or equipment to improve users’ mobility, to connect broadband telecommunications services, to individualise the metering of water, gas or electricity consumption or for the general installation of charging points for electric vehicles, even if the resolution entails modifying the constitutive title and the statutes.
d) The execution of works to install common infrastructure or equipment to improve energy or water efficiency, and to install renewable energy systems and their ancillary elements for common use on common elements, even if the resolution entails modifying the constitutive title and the statutes or affects the structure or the exterior configuration.
e) The execution of works to install infrastructure or equipment to improve energy or water efficiency, and to install renewable energy systems for private benefit on common elements, at the request of the interested owners, even if they affect the structure or the exterior configuration. The resolution adopted includes, if the existing installation allows, access by other owners provided that they pay the amount that would have been due from them when the installation was made, duly updated, and the cost of the adaptation necessary for access. Owners who wish to have access to existing installations must first notify the chair or the community’s administration.
f) Participation in the generation of renewable energy shared with other communities of owners, in demand aggregation, and in local energy communities or citizen energy communities, and the exercise of the rights deriving from that participation, even if the resolution entails modifying the constitutive title and the statutes.
g) Financing contracts to meet the expenses of executing the works or installations provided for in the preceding letters.
h) The rules of the internal regulations.
i) The resolution to submit any matter of the horizontal property regime to mediation.
j) Resolutions for which no different majority is fixed.
3. To calculate majorities, the votes and quotas of the owners who have taken part in the vote on each item of the agenda are counted, whether in person, by representation or by delegation of the vote. Where a private element belongs to several owners, they jointly have a single indivisible vote by reason of the ownership of that private element. Adoption of a resolution by simple majority requires the votes and quotas in favour to exceed the votes and quotas against.
4. Resolutions modifying a participation quota, those depriving any owner of the powers of use and enjoyment of common elements and those determining the extinction of the simple or complex horizontal property regime require the express consent of the owners affected.
5. Owners or holders of a possessory right over the private element who, themselves or the persons with whom they live or work, have a disability or are over seventy years of age, and who fail to have the resolutions referred to in letters a) and b) of paragraph 2 adopted, may ask the judicial authority to order the community to remove the architectural barriers or carry out the required innovations, provided that they are reasonable and proportionate, to achieve accessibility and passability of the property in view of the disability that prompts them.
6. Solely for the purposes of standing to challenge resolutions and exemption from paying the costs of new common installations or services, owners who have not taken part in the vote may object to the resolution by a document sent to the secretary, by any reliable means, within one month of its notification to them. If, once the month has passed, they have not sent the document of objection, they are deemed to adhere to the resolution.
Article 553-25 bis. Simplified regime for adopting resolutions on renewable energy installations
(Repealed.)
Article 553-26. Adoption of resolutions by unanimity and by qualified majorities
1. The favourable vote of all the owners entitled to vote is required to:
a) Modify the participation quotas.
b) Detach an annex.
c) Attach the exclusive use of courtyards, gardens, terraces, roofs of the property or other common elements to one or more private elements.
d) Assign free of charge the use of common elements that have a common use.
e) Constitute a right to raise, build below or build on the property.
f) Extinguish the simple or complex horizontal property regime and convert it into a different type of community.
g) Agree on integration into a complex horizontal property.
h) Submit any matter concerning the horizontal property regime to arbitration, unless there is a statutory provision to the contrary.
2. The favourable vote of four fifths of the owners entitled to vote, who must at the same time represent four fifths of the participation quotas, is required to:
a) Modify the constitutive title and the statutes, unless there is a legal provision to the contrary.
b) Adopt resolutions on physical innovations in the property, if they affect its structure or exterior configuration, except in the cases regulated in letters b), d) and e) of article 553-25.2, and those concerning the construction of swimming pools and recreational facilities.
c) Remove a common element from common use.
d) Constitute, transfer, encumber and divide a private element of common benefit.
e) Agree on special quotas of expenses, or an increase in the share of common expenses corresponding to a private element for disproportionate use of common elements or services, in accordance with article 553-45.4.
f) Agree on the voluntary extinction of the horizontal property regime by plots.
g) The assignment for consideration of the use, and the lease, of common elements that have a common use for a term of more than fifteen years.
h) Financing contracts with a repayment term of more than fifteen years.
3. The resolutions in paragraphs 1 and 2 are deemed adopted:
a) Where unanimity is required, when all the owners who have taken part in the vote have voted in favour and, within one month of notification of the resolution, no other owner has objected by a document sent to the secretary by any reliable means.
b) Where four fifths are required, when a simple majority of the owners and of the quotas taking part in the vote have voted in favour and, within one month of notification of the resolution, the qualified majority is reached, counting as a favourable vote the position of the absent owners who, within that period, have not objected to the resolution by a document sent to the secretary by any reliable means.
Article 553-27. Minutes
1. The secretary must draw up the minutes, which must be authorised with the signatures of the secretary and the chair within five days from the day after the meeting.
2. The minutes of the meeting must be drawn up at least in Catalan, or in Aranese in Aran, and must contain the following particulars:
a) The date and place of the meeting, whether it is ordinary or extraordinary, and the name of the person who called it.
b) The agenda.
c) The name of the person who chaired it and of the person who acted as secretary.
d) The list of persons who attended in person or by representation and, where applicable, of those who delegated.
e) The resolutions adopted, those who took part in each vote and their respective quotas, and the results of the votes, indicating those who voted in favour, those who voted against and those who abstained.
f) The resolutions capable of successive formation, in accordance with article 553-26.3.
3. The chair may require a notary to record the resolutions of the meeting when the chair considers it appropriate, and must do so in all cases where a written request has been submitted, at least five days before the date of the meeting, by one quarter of the owners, or by fewer if they represent one quarter of the quotas. In that case a clear reference to the date of the meeting and to the name and residence of the notary who attended must be made in the minute book.
4. The minutes must be sent to all owners within ten days from the day after the owners’ meeting, to the address notified by each owner to the secretary or, failing that, to the private element. They may be sent by post or e-mail or by other means of communication, with the same guarantees required for the notice of meeting.
5. Once the period set by article 553-26.3 has passed, an annex to the minutes must be sent to all owners stating whether or not the resolutions capable of successive formation have become effective, and also stating the final result of the vote.
Article 553-28. Minute book
1. The resolutions of the owners’ meeting must be transcribed in a minute book, which must be legalised, at least in Catalan, or in Aranese in Aran, at the corresponding Land Registry.
2. The secretary must keep the minute books of the owners’ meeting, which must be kept for thirty years while the horizontal property regime exists, or for five years from the time it has been extinguished.
Article 553-29. Enforceability
Resolutions validly adopted by the owners’ meeting, unless the statutes provide otherwise, are enforceable from the time they are adopted.
Article 553-30. Binding force of resolutions
1. Resolutions adopted by the meeting are compulsory and bind all owners, including dissenting ones.
2. Notwithstanding paragraph 1, dissenting owners are not obliged to pay the costs of new installations or new common services that are not required by law if the total value of the expenditure agreed exceeds one quarter of the community’s current annual budget, after deducting public subsidies or aid and the costs of obtaining the necessary credit from financial institutions. The owners may enjoy the new installations or new services only if they pay the amount of the costs of execution and maintenance, with the corresponding update by applying the general consumer price index.
3. The costs of removing architectural barriers or installing lifts and those necessary to guarantee the accessibility and habitability of the building are borne by all owners if they derive from a resolution of the meeting. If they derive from a judicial decision under article 553-25.5, the judicial authority fixes the amount in view of the community’s ordinary common expenses.
4. The costs of works to install common infrastructure or equipment to improve energy or water efficiency, and to install renewable energy systems for common use on common elements, are borne by all owners if they derive from the meeting’s resolution, in accordance with article 553-25.2.d). Dissenting owners are in any event bound if the total value of the expenditure agreed does not exceed three quarters of the community’s current annual budget for ordinary common expenses, after deducting any public subsidies or aid that may correspond to them for this purpose.
5. Owners who, without just cause, oppose or delay the actions or works that are necessary and required by the competent authority are individually liable for the penalties imposed by the administration.
Article 553-31. Challenge
1. Resolutions of the owners’ meeting may be challenged in court in the following cases:
a) If they are contrary to the law, the constitutive title or the statutes, or if, in the circumstances, they amount to an abuse of rights.
b) If they are contrary to the interests of the community or are seriously harmful to one of the owners.
2. Owners who voted against, absent owners who objected and those unlawfully deprived of the right to vote have standing to challenge a resolution.
3. To bring the challenge action, the owner must be up to date with payment of the debts to the community due at the time the resolution to be challenged was adopted, or have deposited their amount.
4. The action to challenge resolutions lapses after one year in the cases referred to in paragraph 1.a) and after three months in the cases referred to in paragraph 1.b). The periods run from notification of the minutes or of the annex to the minutes, as the case may be.
Article 553-32. Suspension
1. A challenge to a resolution of the owners’ meeting does not suspend its enforceability.
2. The judicial authority may adopt the precautionary measures it considers appropriate, including provisionally suspending the challenged resolution of the owners’ meeting.
Where this sits
The previous page translates articles 553-1 to 553-14: quotas, the four-year liability for unpaid fees and the statutes. The next page translates articles 553-33 to 553-59: what an owner may do with a flat and the common elements, the action to stop prohibited activities, expenses, claims for unpaid fees and complex developments.
Related on voixa.es: Personal tax in Catalonia: both halves of the bill; Spain’s 100% property tax for non-EU buyers: what happened.
Nothing here is advice on your own position, and this reading is not the official text. Where the wording matters to a decision, read it against the Catalan or Spanish original linked above.