Flats, common elements, expenses and complex developments in Catalonia
Catalan Civil Code, Book V, articles 553-33 to 553-59: what an owner may do inside a flat, works that alter common elements and the four-year period after which unchallenged works stand, the seller’s duty to notify the community of a sale, the action against prohibited activities with loss of use for up to two years, expenses and claims for unpaid fees, garages and storerooms, and developments made up of several buildings or plots.
What a buyer inherits beyond the walls
Three provisions on this page reach a buyer after completion. Under article 553-37.3 the seller must notify the community of the sale, and until they do they remain jointly liable for the community’s fees. Under article 553-36.4, works an earlier owner made to common elements without consent — a closed-in terrace, say — are deemed accepted if they are notorious, do not weaken the building or occupy common space, and the community has not objected within four years. And under article 553-40, an activity contrary to the statutes, the planning rules or the law can be stopped by the community in court, with the owner losing the use of the flat for up to two years if it continues.
Book V, Title V, Chapter III (continued)
Section 2. Simple horizontal property
Article 553-33. Private elements
Only dwellings, premises and physical spaces that may be the subject of separate ownership and have functional independence because they have direct or indirect access to the public highway may be configured as private elements of a property.
Article 553-34. Private elements of common benefit
1. Private elements of common benefit are those which, by provision of law, of the constitutive title or by resolution of the owners’ meeting, belong to all the owners in proportion to their quota and inseparably from ownership of the specific private element.
2. Common elements removed from common use by resolution of the owners’ meeting have the character of private elements of common benefit, unless otherwise established.
3. The administration and disposal of a private element of common benefit are governed by the rules of horizontal property.
Article 553-35. Annexes
Annexes are determined in the constitutive title as physical spaces or rights inseparably attached to a private element; they have no special quota and are privately owned for all purposes.
Article 553-36. Use and enjoyment of the private elements
1. Owners of private elements may exercise all the powers of the right of ownership with no restrictions other than those deriving from the horizontal property regime.
2. Owners of a private element may carry out conservation and refurbishment works provided that they do not harm the other owners or the community, do not reduce the soundness or accessibility of the property and do not alter the configuration or exterior appearance of the whole.
3. Owners intending to carry out works in their private element must first notify the chair or the community’s administration. If the works involve altering common elements, a resolution of the owners’ meeting is required. In the case of installation of an individual electric vehicle charging point, it is only necessary to send the technical project to the chair or the administration thirty days before the works begin and the corresponding technical certificate once the installation is finished. Within that period the community may propose a reasonable alternative more suited to its general interests. If the alternative installation is not carried out within two months, the interested owner may carry out the installation originally planned.
4. The community may require common elements altered without its consent to be restored to their original state. However, the community is deemed to have given its consent if the execution of the works is notorious, does not reduce the soundness of the building and does not involve occupying common elements or constituting new easements, and the community has not objected within the lapse period of four years from completion of the works.
Article 553-37. Disposal of the private elements
1. Owners of private elements may modify, transfer and encumber them and may carry out all kinds of acts of disposal with them. If they establish easements for the benefit of other properties, those easements are extinguished if the building is destroyed or demolished.
2. Owners, in the case of a lease or any other transfer of the enjoyment of the private element, are liable to the community and to third parties for the obligations deriving from the horizontal property regime.
3. The person transferring a private element must notify the change of ownership to the community’s secretary. Until they do so, they are jointly and severally liable for the debts to the community.
Article 553-38. Obligations to conserve and maintain the private elements
Owners of private elements must keep them in good condition and must maintain the services and installations located in them.
Article 553-39. Restrictions and compulsory easements
1. Private elements are subject, for the benefit of the others and of the community, to the restrictions essential for carrying out the conservation and maintenance works of the common elements and of the other private elements, if there is no other way of carrying them out or the other way is disproportionately expensive or burdensome.
2. The community may require permanent easements to be constituted over the annexes of the elements of private use if they are essential to implement the resolutions to remove architectural barriers or on improvements adopted by the owners’ meeting, or for access to common elements that have no other access.
3. Owners of private elements may require the constitution of the easements, permanent or temporary, essential for carrying out conservation works and for access to the general supply networks.
4. Holders of the easements must compensate the damage and impairment they cause to the private or common elements affected.
Article 553-40. Prohibitions and restrictions on the use of private and common elements
1. Owners and occupants may not carry out, in the private elements or in the rest of the property, activities or acts contrary to normal coexistence in the community or that damage or endanger the property. Nor may they carry out the activities that the statutes, planning rules or the law expressly exclude or prohibit.
2. If the activities or acts referred to in paragraph 1 are carried out, the chair of the community, on its own initiative or at the request of one quarter of the owners, must reliably require whoever carries them out to stop. If the person or persons required persist in the activity, the owners’ meeting may bring against the owners and occupants of the private element the action to make it cease, which must be processed in accordance with the corresponding procedural rules. Once the claim has been filed, which must be accompanied by the demand and the certificate of the owners’ meeting’s resolution, the judicial authority must adopt the precautionary measures it considers appropriate, including the immediate cessation of the prohibited activity. In the case of occupation without an enabling title, the action may be brought against the occupants even if their identity is not known. If the activities or acts contrary to coexistence, or that damage or endanger the property, are carried out by the occupants of the private element unlawfully and without the owners’ consent, the owners’ meeting may report the facts to the municipal council so that, after proceedings showing that the prohibited activities or acts have actually taken place, it initiates the procedure established by article 44 bis of Law 18/2007 of 28 December on the right to housing.
3. The community is entitled to compensation for the loss caused to it and, if the prohibited activities continue, to seek in court the deprivation of the use and enjoyment of the private element for a period not exceeding two years and, where appropriate, the termination of the lease or of any other contract granting the occupants a right over the private element.
Article 553-41. Common elements
Common elements are the plot, the gardens, the swimming pools, the structures, the facades, the roofs, the entrance halls, the staircases and the lifts, the aerials and, in general, the installations and services of the private elements intended for community use or to facilitate the use and enjoyment of those private elements.
Article 553-42. Use and enjoyment of the common elements
1. The use and enjoyment of the common elements belongs to all owners of private elements and must conform to the purpose established by the statutes or to that which is normal and appropriate to their nature, without harming the interest of the community.
2. Where the meeting agrees on installations for energy or water efficiency or renewable energy systems for community use on common elements where previously authorised installations or systems for private benefit exist that are incompatible with the new resolution, the community assumes their removal and must compensate the owner for the damage the removal entails.
Article 553-43. Common elements of exclusive use
1. In the constitutive title or by unanimous resolution of the meeting, the exclusive use of courtyards, gardens, terraces, roofs of the property or other common elements may be attached to one or more private elements. This attachment does not make them lose their nature as common elements.
2. Owners of the private elements that have the exclusive use and enjoyment of common elements bear all the costs of conserving and maintaining them and are obliged to conserve them properly and keep them in good condition.
3. Owners of the private elements that have the exclusive use of common elements may carry out improvement works for energy or water efficiency or install renewable energy systems on those common elements, bearing the resulting costs and the maintenance costs. In any event, they must send the technical project to the chair or the administration thirty days before the works begin. Within that period the community may propose an alternative more suited to its general interests, provided that it is reasonable and proportionate and does not entail a substantial increase in the cost of the technical project submitted for the promoting persons. In the absence of an alternative, the owners may carry out those works or installations.
4. Repairs due to construction or structural defects, original or supervening, or repairs that affect and benefit the whole property, are borne by the community, unless they result from misuse or poor conservation.
Article 553-44. Conservation and maintenance of the common elements
1. The community must conserve the common elements of the property so that it meets the structural, habitability, accessibility, watertightness, safety and energy or water efficiency conditions under the rules in force, and must keep the services and installations in proper working order. The owners must bear the necessary conservation and repair works.
2. Owners who benefit from the installation of infrastructure or equipment improving energy or water efficiency, or of renewable energy systems for private benefit, located on common elements or on common elements of exclusive use, must bear their conservation and maintenance in full.
Article 553-45. Contribution to the payment of common expenses
1. Owners must pay the common expenses in proportion to their participation quota or in accordance with the special features fixed by the constitutive title, the statutes or the resolutions of the meeting.
2. Not using and enjoying specific common elements does not exempt an owner from the obligation to pay the expenses arising from their maintenance, unless a provision of the statutes, which may refer only to services or elements specified in concrete terms, establishes otherwise, and without prejudice to article 553-30.2.
3. The contribution to the payment of certain expenses for which the statutes establish special quotas different from the participation quotas, including those of different staircases, swimming pools and garden areas, must be made in accordance with the specific quota.
4. The constitutive title may establish an increase in the share of common expenses corresponding to a specific private element in the case of particularly intensive use or enjoyment of common elements or services as a result of carrying on business or professional activities in the flat or premises. This increase may also be agreed by the owners’ meeting. In neither case may the increase exceed twice what would correspond under the quota.
Article 553-46. Liability of the community
1. The common credits and funds of the owners and the private elements of common benefit answer for the debts incurred on behalf of the community. Secondarily, the owners of the private elements answer in proportion to their participation quota.
2. To attach the funds, credits and private elements of common benefit, it is sufficient to sue the community. To attach the other private elements, payment must be demanded from all the owners and they must be sued personally.
Article 553-47. Claim in the event of non-payment of common expenses
1. The community may claim all amounts owed to it for non-payment of ordinary or extraordinary common expenses, or of the reserve fund, through the special order-for-payment procedure applicable to communities of owners of properties under horizontal property established by procedural legislation.
2. To bring the claim, a certificate of non-payment of the common expenses issued by whoever acts as secretary of the community with the chair’s approval is sufficient. The certificate must state the existence of the debt and its amount, the statement that the debt is payable and corresponds exactly to the accounts approved by the owners’ meeting recorded in the corresponding minute book, and the demand for payment made to the debtor.
Section 3. Complex horizontal property
Article 553-48. Configuration
1. Complex horizontal property entails the coexistence of sub-communities within a property or a real-estate complex made up of several staircases or entrances, or of a number of independent and separate buildings connected to each other and sharing garden and recreation areas, swimming pools or other similar common elements.
2. Under the complex horizontal property regime, each staircase, entrance or building constitutes a sub-community governed by the provisions of sections 1 and 2.
3. Private elements located in one or more properties that are connected to each other and have economic and functional independence may be configured as a sub-community.
Article 553-49. Quotas
Each of the private elements making up a sub-community has a particular participation quota assigned to it, separate from the general quota corresponding to it in the complex horizontal property as a whole.
Article 553-50. Constitution
1. Complex horizontal property is initially constituted as a single community with sub-communities or as a grouping of several communities. In the latter case, the title may be executed by the sole owners of the different properties or by the chairs of the respective communities authorised by a prior resolution of each meeting.
2. The constitutive title must be set out in a public deed, which must describe:
a) The real-estate complex as a whole.
b) Each of the private elements making it up, indicating the sub-community to which they belong and the general and particular participation quotas.
c) The roads, garden and recreation areas and other common services and elements of the complex.
3. The complex horizontal property regime is registered in the Land Registry in accordance with mortgage legislation, by a general registration on its own folio for the complex horizontal property and, in addition, on another folio of its own for each sub-community and each private element.
Article 553-51. Regulation and resolutions
1. In complex horizontal property, each sub-community has its own specific bodies and adopts its own resolutions independently of the other sub-communities and of the general community, within the scope of matters recognised to it in the constitutive title.
2. The statutes may regulate a council of chairs if the complexity of the real-estate complex and of the common elements, services and installations, the number of private elements or other circumstances make it advisable. The council must act collectively for the ordinary administration of the common elements of the whole complex and must be governed by the rules of the owners’ meeting adapted to its specific nature.
Article 553-52. Communities and sub-communities for garages and storerooms
1. The garage or storeroom community, unless the statutes provide otherwise, operates independently of the general community as regards matters of its exclusive interest in the following cases:
a) If it is configured as a co-ownership forming a private element of a horizontal property regime and the acquisition of an undivided share confers the exclusive use of parking spaces or storerooms and the use of the access and exit ramps, the staircases and the manoeuvring areas. In this case, the holders of the undivided share may not bring the action for division of the community and do not enjoy pre-emption rights.
b) If the different parking spaces or storerooms of premises in a property under horizontal property are constituted as private elements. In this case, each space is assigned, in addition to its internal number and the quota corresponding to it in the horizontal property regime, a specific identifying number or letter; the ramps, staircases and areas for vehicle access, manoeuvre and exit are considered common elements of the garage or storeroom.
2. There is no sub-community for the garage or storeroom premises in the following cases:
a) If the different parking spaces or storerooms are configured as inseparable annexes of the private elements of the community. In this case, article 553-35 applies to them.
b) If the premises intended for garages or storerooms are configured as a common element of the horizontal property regime. In this case, the specific use of the parking spaces or storerooms may not be assigned to third parties independently of the use of the respective private element.
3. A sub-community may be constituted for the premises intended for garages or storerooms if several properties under horizontal property share their use. In that case, the sub-community also forms part of each horizontal property in the vertical projection corresponding to it. Unless specific statutory rules provide otherwise, the holders of the spaces are entitled to use all the areas for vehicle access, distribution, manoeuvre and exit located in the premises, regardless of the specific property under whose vertical or facade they are located.
Section 4. Horizontal property by plots
Article 553-53. Concept and configuration
1. The horizontal property regime may be established, by plots, over a set of independent properties that are building plots, whether built on or not, form part of an urban development scheme and participate inseparably in certain elements held in common.
2. The horizontal property regime by plots is governed, in what the constitutive title does not establish, by the specific rules of this section and, on a supplementary basis, by those of this chapter, in accordance with its specific nature and with the applicable planning rules.
Article 553-54. Privately owned properties
1. The private properties and, where applicable, their inseparable annexes belong exclusively to their holders under the property regime applicable to them.
2. Acts of transfer and encumbrance, and attachment, of the private properties extend inseparably to the participation quota corresponding to them in the common elements.
3. The transfer of a private property does not give the owners of the others any statutory pre-emption right.
Article 553-55. Common elements
1. Common elements are the properties, real-estate elements and services and installations intended for common use and enjoyment mentioned in the constitutive title, including garden and recreation areas, sports facilities, social premises, security services and, where applicable, other similar elements.
2. The common elements are inseparable from the private properties, to which they are linked by the participation quota, expressed in hundredths, corresponding to each property in the whole.
Article 553-56. Restrictions
Restrictions on the exercise of the powers of ownership over private properties imposed by the constitutive title, the statutes, planning or the law are considered common elements.
Article 553-57. Constitutive title
1. The constitutive title of the horizontal property regime by plots must be set out in a public deed, which must contain:
a) The description of the whole in general, which must include the name and location, the area, the administrative approval of the urban development scheme of which it forms part, the essential data of the licence or of the subdivision resolution, the number of plots making it up, and the reference and description of the common properties and installations.
b) The list of the development works and installations of the whole and the system provided for their conservation and maintenance, and information on the provision of non-planning services and the other circumstances resulting from the development plan.
c) The description of all the plots and other private elements, which must include the internal number; the general participation quota and, where applicable, the special quotas corresponding to them; the area; the boundaries; and, where applicable, the physical spaces or rights constituting their annexes or attached to them.
d) The general or specific rules on the purpose and buildability of the properties and information on whether they are divisible.
e) The statutes, if any.
f) The list of land of public use and domain included within the scope of the horizontal property by plots.
g) A descriptive plan of the whole, identifying the private properties and the common elements.
2. The planning determinations contained in the constitutive title have merely informative effects.
3. It is not necessary to describe each of the plots if the horizontal property regime by plots is established by agreement of all or some of the owners of plots, built on or not, located in a consolidated urban unit, which are already registered in the Land Registry as independent properties, provided that at least the number corresponding to them in the development, the registry identification, the cadastral reference and the names of the owners have been stated.
Article 553-58. Registry record
1. The horizontal property regime by plots is registered in the Land Registry in accordance with mortgage legislation. A general registration must be made for the whole and a registration for each of the private properties and, where applicable, of the properties intended for common use and enjoyment or common services, for each of which a separate special folio must be opened.
2. If the horizontal property by plots falls wholly or partly on several properties, an instrumental grouping must be made. The reference note must state its instrumental nature and it must be considered, for all purposes, that no community has ever existed. The private properties may be allotted directly to the corresponding holder.
3. Registration of the horizontal property regime by plots must be made in favour of its members and, in addition to the data required by mortgage legislation, must contain those established by article 553-57 that have effect in rem and the reference to the filing of the plan. In any event, the marginal reference notes to the registrations of the private properties must be made.
4. The registrations of the private properties must contain, in addition to the data required by mortgage legislation, the following:
a) The plot number corresponding to them.
b) The participation quota or quotas.
c) The special regime or the restrictions that may affect them in a specific way.
d) The reference to the general registration and subjection to the horizontal property regime by plots.
5. The properties intended for common use and enjoyment or for common services are registered in favour of the members of the horizontal property by plots, without naming them explicitly or stating the quotas corresponding to them.
6. Where horizontal property by plots is established after the event, a separate and independent folio must be opened for the horizontal property as a whole, in which the circumstances established by this article must be stated, and a reference must be made, in a marginal note, to each of the registrations of the properties that become private, stating the quota corresponding to them.
Article 553-59. Voluntary extinction
1. The voluntary extinction of the horizontal property by plots takes place by resolution of four fifths of the owners, who must represent four fifths of the participation quotas.
2. Once extinction has been agreed, the obligations to third parties and, where appropriate, to the owners must be fully settled. During the liquidation process the owners’ meeting must retain its functions, must collect the arrears of quotas and the other claims in favour of the horizontal property by plots, must sell, where appropriate, the common-use properties that it has been agreed to sell and, once all the operations have been completed, must render accounts to all the owners.
Where this sits
The previous pages translate articles 553-1 to 553-14, on quotas, debts and the statutes, and articles 553-15 to 553-32, on the owners’ meeting. The Catalan rules on options and pre-emption rights, and on the sale of real estate and earnest money, are translated separately; the other Catalan housing and tourism laws are listed in our property law index.
Related on voixa.es: Personal tax in Catalonia: both halves of the bill; Spain’s 100% property tax for non-EU buyers: what happened.
Nothing here is advice on your own position, and this reading is not the official text. Where the wording matters to a decision, read it against the Catalan or Spanish original linked above.