Justice Efficiency Act, articles 2 to 11: negotiation before going to court
Organic Law 1/2025 on measures for the efficiency of the Public Justice Service, articles 2 to 11: what counts as an appropriate dispute resolution method (MASC), the civil and commercial matters covered and those excluded, the requirement to try such a method before most civil claims are admitted and the proceedings exempt from it, and when a lawyer is compulsory. They also cover the effect of a request to negotiate on limitation and expiry periods and the one-year deadline to file the claim, negotiation by electronic means, confidentiality, how the attempt is proved, when the process counts as ended without agreement, and fees.
Title II. Measures on procedural efficiency of the Public Justice Service
Chapter I. Appropriate dispute resolution methods outside the courts
Section 1. General provisions
Article 2. Concept and characterisation of appropriate dispute resolution methods outside the courts
For the purposes of this law, an appropriate dispute resolution method means any type of negotiating activity, recognised in this or other laws, state or regional, to which the parties to a dispute resort in good faith in order to find an out-of-court solution to it, either by themselves or with the intervention of a neutral third party.
Article 3. Scope of application of appropriate dispute resolution methods
1. The provisions of this title apply to civil and commercial matters, including cross-border disputes. For these purposes, cross-border disputes are those defined in article 3 of Law 5/2012 of 6 July on mediation in civil and commercial matters.
In the absence of express or tacit submission to the provisions of this title, its rules apply where at least one of the parties is domiciled in Spain and the negotiating activity takes place in Spanish territory.
2. Excluded in all cases from the provisions of this title are employment, criminal and insolvency matters, and matters of any kind, whatever the jurisdictional order before which they are to be heard, in which one of the parties is an entity belonging to the public sector.
Article 4. Principle of private autonomy in the use of appropriate dispute resolution methods
1. The parties are free to agree or settle, through these methods, on their rights and interests, provided that what is agreed is not contrary to the law, to good faith or to public policy. The parties may reach full or partial agreements. In the case of partial agreements, the parties may file a claim to pursue their claims on the points of the dispute on which disagreement remains.
However, disputes concerning matters that are not at the disposal of the parties under the applicable legislation may not be submitted to appropriate dispute resolution methods, not even on referral by a court; such methods may, however, be applied to the effects and measures provided for in articles 102 and 103 of the Civil Code, without prejudice to court approval of the agreement reached.
2. In no case may these dispute resolution methods be applied to civil disputes concerning any of the matters excluded from mediation under paragraph 9 of article 89 of Organic Law 6/1985 of 1 July on the Judiciary.
Article 5. Admissibility requirement
1. In the civil jurisdictional order, as a general rule, for a claim to be admissible, prior recourse to one of the appropriate dispute resolution methods provided for in article 2 is regarded as an admissibility requirement (requisito de procedibilidad). For this requirement to be regarded as met, the subject of the negotiation and the subject of the litigation must be the same, even if the claims that may be brought in court on that subject vary.
This requirement is regarded as met if the parties first resort to mediation, to conciliation or to the neutral opinion of an independent expert, if a binding confidential offer is made, or if any other type of negotiating activity is used that is recognised in this or other laws, state or regional, but which complies with sections 1 and 2 of this chapter or with a sectoral law. In particular, the requirement is regarded as met where the negotiating activity is carried out directly by the parties, or between their lawyers under their instructions and with their consent, and also where the parties have resorted to a collaborative law process.
2. Negotiating activity before going to court is required as an admissibility requirement in all declaratory proceedings of Book II and in the special proceedings of Book IV of Law 1/2000 of 7 January on Civil Procedure, except those concerning the following matters:
a) civil judicial protection of fundamental rights;
b) the adoption of the measures provided for in article 158 of the Civil Code;
c) the adoption of judicial support measures for persons with disabilities;
d) filiation, paternity and maternity;
e) summary protection of the holding or possession of a thing or right by a person who has been dispossessed of it or disturbed in its enjoyment;
f) a claim asking the court to order, summarily, the demolition or knocking down of a work, building, tree, column or any other similar object that is in a state of ruin and threatens to cause damage to the claimant;
g) the placement of minors with behavioural problems in specific protection centres, entry into homes and other places for the compulsory enforcement of child protection measures, or the restitution or return of minors in cases of international abduction;
h) bill of exchange proceedings (juicio cambiario).
3. It is not necessary to resort to an appropriate dispute resolution method in order to file a claim for enforcement, to apply for interim measures before the claim, to apply for preliminary steps (diligencias preliminares) or to initiate voluntary jurisdiction proceedings, except proceedings for judicial intervention in cases of disagreement between spouses and in the administration of community property (bienes gananciales), and proceedings for judicial intervention in case of disagreement in the exercise of parental authority. Nor is it necessary to resort to an appropriate dispute resolution method in order to file an application for a European order for payment under Regulation (EC) No 1896/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 December 2006 creating a European order for payment procedure, or to apply to start a European small claims procedure under Regulation (EC) No 861/2007 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 July 2007 establishing a European Small Claims Procedure.
4. The initiative to resort to appropriate dispute resolution methods may come from one of the parties, from both by mutual agreement, or from a decision of the court or of the Court Clerk (letrado o letrada de la Administración de Justicia) referring the parties to such methods.
Where all the parties propose resorting to an appropriate dispute resolution method and there is no agreement on which one to use, the one proposed first in time shall be used.
Article 6. Legal assistance
1. The parties may resort to any of the appropriate dispute resolution methods assisted by a lawyer.
2. Legal assistance to the parties is compulsory only where the appropriate dispute resolution method used is the making of a binding offer, except where the amount in dispute does not exceed two thousand euros or where a sectoral law does not require the intervention of a lawyer to make or accept the offer.
3. Where legal assistance is not compulsory but any of the parties intends to use it, that party shall state so in the request or within three days of the date on which the requested party receives the proposal. In both cases, this must be communicated to the other party so that it can decide, within the three days following receipt of the notification, whether also to use legal assistance.
Article 7. Effects of opening the negotiation process and of its ending without agreement
1. A request from one of the parties to the other to begin a negotiation procedure through an appropriate dispute resolution method, adequately defining the subject of the negotiation, interrupts the limitation period (prescripción) or suspends the expiry period (caducidad) of actions from the date on which there is a record of the attempt to communicate that request to the other party at the personal domicile or workplace known to the requesting person, or through the electronic means of communication used by the parties in their previous dealings.
The interruption or suspension lasts until the date on which the agreement is signed or the negotiation process ends without agreement.
The computation of the periods restarts or resumes, respectively, if the first meeting aimed at reaching an agreement is not held or no written response is obtained within thirty calendar days from the date on which the party to whom the request to negotiate is addressed receives it, or from the date of the attempted communication if that receipt does not take place.
If a specific proposal for agreement receives no response from the other party within thirty calendar days from the date of receipt, the computation of the periods restarts or resumes, respectively.
2. Without prejudice to the preceding paragraph, where a neutral third party intervenes, the following rules apply:
a) where a mediator intervenes, article 4 of Law 5/2012 of 6 July on mediation in civil and commercial matters applies.
b) where a conciliator intervenes, the request to begin conciliation interrupts the limitation period or suspends the expiry period of actions from the date on which there is a record that the conciliator received that request; the computation of the periods restarts or resumes, respectively, if within fifteen calendar days from the date on which the conciliator received the request the conciliator has not attempted to communicate with the other party, and also if, within fifteen calendar days from receipt of the proposal by the party to whom the request for conciliation is addressed, or from the date of the attempted communication if that receipt does not take place, the first meeting aimed at reaching an agreement is not held or no written response is obtained.
If the conciliation is opened, the interruption or suspension lasts until the date on which the agreement is signed or the conciliation ends.
c) where an independent expert intervenes, the limitation period is interrupted or the expiry period of actions suspended from the date on which the expert is appointed by mutual agreement, and the computation of the periods restarts or resumes, respectively, from the date on which all the parties accept the final agreement or the certificate provided for in article 18.5 is issued.
d) where a Court Clerk intervenes, Law 15/2015 of 2 July on Voluntary Jurisdiction applies as regards suspension of the expiry period and interruption of the limitation period, and it applies supplementarily where a notary or a land registrar acts as conciliator.
3. If the initial request to negotiate receives no response or the negotiation process ends without agreement, the parties must file the claim within one year from, respectively, the date on which the party to whom the request to negotiate was addressed received it or, where applicable, the date on which the negotiation process ended without agreement, for the admissibility requirement to be regarded as met.
If interim measures were granted while the negotiation process was under way, the parties must file the claim before the same court that heard them within the twenty days following the end of the negotiation process without agreement, or following the date on which the negotiation process is to be regarded as ended without agreement under this law.
If the interim measures were granted before the negotiation process began, the twenty-day period to file the claim is suspended and resumed, respectively, on the terms provided for in paragraph 1.
4. If court proceedings are begun with the same subject as the prior negotiating activity attempted without agreement, the courts must take into account the parties' cooperation towards a consensual solution and any abuse of the public justice service when ruling on costs or assessing them, and also when imposing the fines or penalties provided for, all on the terms laid down in Law 1/2000 of 7 January on Civil Procedure.
Article 8. Steps taken by electronic means
1. The parties may agree that all or some of the negotiation steps within an appropriate dispute resolution method be carried out by electronic means, by videoconference or by another similar means of transmitting voice or image, provided that the identity of the participants and compliance with the rules laid down in this title and, where applicable, with the implementing rules specifically provided for mediation are guaranteed.
2. Where the subject of the dispute is a claim for an amount not exceeding six hundred euros, the process shall preferably be conducted by electronic means, unless their use is not possible for one of the parties.
Article 9. Confidentiality and data protection
1. The negotiation process and the documentation used in it are confidential, except for information on whether or not the parties attempted prior negotiation and on the subject of the dispute.
The duty of confidentiality extends to the parties, to the lawyers involved and, where applicable, to the neutral third party involved, who are subject to the duty and right of professional secrecy, so that none of them may disclose information they may have obtained from the negotiation process.
2. In particular, the parties, the lawyers and the neutral third party may not give evidence or produce documentation arising from or related to the negotiation process, nor be compelled to do so, in court proceedings or in arbitration, except:
a) Where all the parties have expressly and in writing released each other, or the lawyer or the neutral third party, from the duty of confidentiality.
b) Where a challenge to the assessment of costs and an application for exemption from or reduction of costs under article 245 of Law 1/2000 of 7 January on Civil Procedure are being processed, and for those sole purposes, without the material being usable for other purposes or in later proceedings.
c) Where it is requested by judges of the criminal jurisdictional order by reasoned judicial decision.
d) Where necessary for reasons of public policy, in particular where required for the protection of the best interests of the child or the prevention of harm to the physical or psychological integrity of a person.
Accordingly, and save for those exceptions, if any of the parties seeks to submit the confidential information as evidence in the proceedings, the courts shall not admit it, under article 283.3 of Law 1/2000 of 7 January on Civil Procedure.
3. If information is disclosed or documentation submitted in breach of this article, the judicial authority shall refuse to admit it and order that it not be added to the case file, without prejudice, in addition, to the liability that the breach gives rise to on the terms provided for in the legal system.
4. Personal data of natural persons shall be processed in strict compliance with Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, and repealing Directive 95/46/EC (General Data Protection Regulation), and with Organic Law 3/2018 of 5 December on the Protection of Personal Data and the guarantee of digital rights.
Article 10. Proof of the attempt to negotiate and ending of the process without agreement
1. In order to prove that a prior negotiating activity has been attempted and to meet the admissibility requirement, that negotiating activity or the attempt at it must be recorded in a document.
2. If no neutral third party has intervened, proof is provided by any document signed by both parties recording their identity and, where applicable, that of the professionals or experts who have advised them, the date, the subject of the dispute, the date of the meeting or meetings held, where applicable, and the responsible declaration that both parties have taken part in the process in good faith. Failing that, the attempt to negotiate may be proved by any document showing that the other party received the request or invitation to negotiate or, where applicable, the proposal, on what date, and that it was able to access its full content.
3. Where a neutral third party has managed the negotiating activity, that third party must issue, at the request of any of the parties, a document stating:
a) The identity of the third party, their qualification, professional association, the institution to which they belong or the register in which they are entered.
b) The identity of the parties.
c) The subject of the dispute.
d) The date of the meeting or meetings held.
e) The solemn declaration that both parties have taken part in the process in good faith, so that it has effect before the relevant judicial authority.
If any of the parties has not appeared or has refused the invitation to take part in the negotiating activity, this shall be recorded together with, where applicable, the manner in which the summons was effectively made, proof that it was made and the date on which it was received.
4. The process is regarded as having ended without agreement:
a) If thirty calendar days pass from the date on which the other party received the initial request to negotiate and the first meeting or contact aimed at reaching an agreement is not held or no written response is obtained.
b) If, once the negotiating activity has begun, thirty days pass after one of the parties makes a specific proposal for agreement to the other without an agreement being reached or a written response being obtained. The thirty-day period runs from the date of receipt of the specific proposal for agreement.
c) If three months pass from the date of the first meeting without an agreement having been reached. Notwithstanding the above, the parties are entitled to continue the negotiating activity by mutual agreement beyond that period.
d) If any of the parties writes to the other declaring the negotiations terminated, with a record of the attempt to communicate that this is its will.
Article 11. Fees of the professionals involved
1. Where the parties take part in the negotiation process assisted by their lawyers, they shall pay their respective fees, unless they are entitled to free legal aid (justicia gratuita).
2. The existence of public dispute resolution mechanisms that the parties can access free of charge shall be ensured. If the parties decide to opt for other mechanisms in which a neutral third party intervenes, that third party's professional fees shall be agreed in advance with the participating parties. If the party invited to take part in the negotiation process does not accept the intervention of the neutral third party proposed unilaterally by the other party, the latter shall pay in full the fees, if any, accrued by the neutral third party up to that point.
Where this sits
Next: Agreements and the methods of negotiation. The Civil Procedure Act articles on the verbal trial claim and its admission, including eviction claims, are on Civil Procedure Act: verbal trial claim and admission. All translated laws: Spanish laws in English.
Related on voixa.es: Spain’s 100% property tax for non-EU buyers: what happened; Modelo 210: the non-resident deadlines changed in 2026.
Nothing here is advice on your own position, and this reading is not the official text. Spain publishes no official English version of this Act; where the wording matters to a decision, read it against the Spanish original published in the BOE.