Buying property in Catalonia: earnest money, the mortgage condition and the half-value rule
Catalan Civil Code, Book VI, articles 621-1 to 621-8 and 621-45 to 621-55: the contract of sale and the consumer sale; the seller’s duty to inform; earnest money (arras), which in Catalonia is a part-payment unless expressly agreed otherwise; rescission when the price is less than half the value; the buyer’s right to withdraw if the bank refuses the mortgage; the 10 per cent tolerance on floor area; off-plan sales; and the seller’s resolution for unpaid deferred price.
Three Catalan rules a buyer from abroad will not expect
First, under article 621-8 a deposit paid on signing is confirmatory: a part-payment that commits both sides, not a price for walking away. A buyer who wants the right to withdraw by forfeiting the deposit must agree that expressly. Second, under article 621-49 a buyer whose contract provides for bank financing can withdraw and recover their money if the bank refuses the loan, unless the contract excludes it. Third, under article 621-46 a sale can be rescinded for four years if one side received less than half the market value of what it gave — a rule that can catch a buyer who paid far below value as well as one who paid far above.
Book VI, Title II. Types of contract
Chapter I. Contracts for transfer
Section 1. Contract of sale
Subsection 1. General provisions
Article 621-1. Contract of sale
Sale is the contract by which the seller undertakes to deliver property in conformity with the contract and to transfer its ownership, whether of the right of ownership or of other patrimonial rights according to its nature, and the buyer undertakes to pay a price in money and to receive the property.
Article 621-2. Consumer sale
1. A sale is a consumer sale if the seller acts in the course of its business or professional activity and the buyer acts for a purpose mainly outside those activities.
2. In a consumer sale, the rules of this chapter are mandatory. Accordingly, any agreement, clause or stipulation that modifies them to the buyer’s detriment is ineffective.
Article 621-3. Object
1. The contract of sale has as its object tangible or intangible property, including future property, property that is to be produced, manufactured or made, and property that incorporates or is interconnected with digital content or services.
2. The following definitions apply:
a) Digital content: data produced and supplied in digital form.
b) Digital service: a service that allows the buyer to create, process, store or access data in digital form, or that allows the sharing of data in digital form uploaded or created by the buyer or other users of that service, or any other interaction with those data.
c) Property with digital elements: property that incorporates digital content or services, or is interconnected with them in such a way that it cannot perform its functions without them.
3. Where the object of the contract is property with digital elements, those elements are presumed to be included in the contract of sale, whether they are supplied by the seller or by a third party.
Article 621-4. Prohibitions
The following may not acquire under a contract of sale, directly or through an intermediary:
a) Public employees, the public property they manage.
b) Judges, magistrates, staff of the Administration of Justice, lawyers, court representatives and experts, property in litigation in proceedings in which they perform their functions under the applicable rules.
c) Those who, by law or by act of public authority, administer another’s property, the property administered, unless the law or the authority provides otherwise.
d) Guardians and other persons holding offices for the protection of a person, that person’s property, save with judicial approval or authorisation.
e) Attorneys and agents, the property whose management has been entrusted to them, save with express consent.
f) Executors, the property they administer, save with express authorisation.
Article 621-5. Determination of the price
1. If the contract concluded does not determine the price or establish the means of determining it, the price is understood to be that generally charged in comparable circumstances, at the time the contract is concluded and for property of a similar nature.
2. If the contract provides for the price to be determined by one of the parties or by third parties, it is possible to object only to a determination that is manifestly unreasonable or made outside the agreed period or one appropriate in the circumstances.
3. If the price is manifestly unreasonable or its determination is untimely, paragraph 1 applies.
4. The seller must obtain the buyer’s express consent for any increase in the agreed price. Otherwise, the buyer is not obliged to pay it.
5. In a consumer sale, the total price may not exceed the price stated in the offer or publicly advertised, which must include the taxes that must by law be passed on. If, by the nature of the property, the total price cannot be calculated before the contract is concluded, the seller must state how it is determined.
Article 621-6. Sale on approval or trial
1. A sale on approval or trial is deemed concluded subject to the suspensive condition of the buyer’s approval.
2. The seller must allow the buyer to examine the property sold and provide the appropriate means for exercising that right.
3. The buyer’s approval must take place within the period established in the contract or, failing that, within the reasonable period indicated by the seller that is sufficient for examining the property. Once the period has passed, the buyer’s silence is understood as approval.
Article 621-7. Duty to inform
The seller, before the contract is concluded, must provide the buyer with the relevant information on the characteristics of the property, taking into account the parties’ knowledge, the nature and cost of the information, and the requirements of good faith and fair dealing.
Article 621-8. Earnest money
1. The delivery by the buyer of a sum of money to the seller is understood to be made as confirmatory earnest money, that is, as a sign of conclusion of the sale and on account of its price.
2. Penitential earnest money must be expressly agreed. If the buyer withdraws from the contract, the buyer forfeits it, unless the withdrawal is justified under article 621-49. If the seller withdraws, the seller must return it doubled.
3. In the sale of immovable property, the delivery of penitential earnest money agreed for a maximum period of six months and deposited with a notary may be recorded in the Land Registry and, in that case, the property is charged with its return. In the event of withdrawal, the notary must deliver the deposited earnest money to whoever is entitled to it. The charge is extinguished:
a) Sixty days after the agreed period, unless there is an earlier entry of a claim by the buyer. In that case, the charge is cancelled ex officio.
b) When the buyer withdraws and the seller reliably evidences it.
c) When the sale is registered.
Subsection 6. Unfair advantage and loss of more than half
Article 621-45. Unfair advantage
1. The contract of sale and other contracts for consideration may be rescinded if, at the time the contract was concluded, one of the parties depended on the other or had a special relationship of trust with it, was in a situation of economic vulnerability or pressing need, was unable to foresee the consequences of its acts, or was manifestly ignorant or manifestly inexperienced, and the other party knew or should have known of that situation, took advantage of it and obtained an excessive benefit or a manifestly unfair advantage.
2. In a consumer sale, the contract may also be rescinded, in addition to the grounds referred to in paragraph 1, if it causes a serious imbalance in the parties’ rights and obligations to the detriment of the consumer, contrary to the requirements of good faith and fair dealing.
Article 621-46. Loss of more than half
1. The contract of sale and other contracts for consideration may be rescinded if the injured party proves that, at the time the contract was concluded, the market value of the performance it receives is less than half the market value of the performance it gives.
2. In the case referred to in paragraph 1, the other party may argue that the alleged imbalance is justified by the contractual risk inherent in aleatory contracts or by the existence of a gratuitous cause.
3. In the case of purchase options, the imbalance referred to in paragraph 1 must exist at the time the option is agreed.
Article 621-47. Adaptation of the contract and correction of the loss
1. In the case referred to in article 621-45, at the request of the injured party, the judicial authority may adapt the content of the contract to the prevailing contractual practice at the time of its conclusion and to the requirements of good faith and fair dealing.
2. In the case referred to in article 621-46, rescission of the contract may be avoided by paying in money the total value of the performance, with legal interest, from the conclusion of the contract.
Article 621-48. Actions
The actions established by this subsection lapse four years from the conclusion of the contract and may not be waived at that time.
Subsection 7. Special features of the sale of immovable property
Article 621-49. Provision for third-party financing
1. If the contract of sale provides for all or part of the price to be financed by a credit institution, the buyer, unless otherwise agreed, may withdraw from the contract if the buyer shows with documents, within the agreed period, that the designated institution has refused to grant the financing or to accept the buyer’s subrogation to the mortgage on the property, unless the refusal results from the buyer’s negligence.
2. The buyer’s withdrawal obliges the seller to return the price paid and, where applicable, the penitential earnest money, and obliges the buyer to leave the seller in the same situation in which the seller would have been had the contract not been concluded, without prejudice to mortgage legislation.
Article 621-50. Statement of the floor area of the property
1. In the sale of immovable property, unless otherwise agreed, the reference to the capacity, measurement or floor area of the property is indicative, and differences, up or down, do not amount to lack of conformity, unless they exceed 10 per cent or the stated capacity, measurement or floor area is a requirement for the specific use, agreed or customary, for which properties of the same characteristics are intended.
2. In the sale of immovable property in which the price is calculated by reason of the capacity, measurement or floor area of the property, a difference in capacity not exceeding 10 per cent of the agreed measurement gives rise to a proportional modification of the price.
3. In the sale of immovable property in which the price is agreed globally and not by reason of the capacity of the property, a difference in floor area, up or down, does not give rise to a modification of the price or to lack of conformity, provided that the parties’ intention to have concluded the contract in any event is clear and unequivocal.
Article 621-51. Property under construction or rehabilitation held in community
1. In the sale of a dwelling, premises or other element of a building under construction or rehabilitation that is to be subject to a horizontal property regime, the parties may establish a community over the property of which the property sold forms part.
2. In the case referred to in paragraph 1, the contract must include a description of the property and of the property or complex of which it forms part as an independent or private element, with express reference to the circumstances regulated in article 553-9.1.
3. The parties may set a final deadline for construction or rehabilitation, which may not exceed ten years from obtaining the corresponding building licence. In the absence of agreement, the final deadline is that established by the licence.
Article 621-52. Property under construction or rehabilitation before the building licence
1. A contract for the sale of property under construction or rehabilitation that is not a dwelling, concluded before the building licence is obtained, must establish the characteristics and conditions of the works, the initial and final construction or rehabilitation deadlines and the quality of the materials used.
2. The parties may agree that the final construction deadline, which may in no case exceed ten years, runs from the conclusion of the contract or from obtaining the licence. In the latter case, the period for obtaining the building licence may not exceed two years.
Article 621-53. Regime of the community
1. The buyer’s share in the community constituted corresponds to that which the element under construction or rehabilitation will have in the horizontal property regime of which it forms part once built or rehabilitated.
2. The community entails the exclusion of the action for division and of statutory pre-emption rights between owners of different dwellings, premises or elements of the building under construction or rehabilitation.
3. The buyer’s share, once construction or rehabilitation is completed, gives rise to separate ownership of the element that was the subject of the contract.
4. The seller may execute a deed of new building and constitution of the horizontal property regime if it states an individualised description of the element sold as it appears in the deed of sale. That element must be registered in the buyer’s name.
Article 621-54. Resolutory condition agreement
1. An agreement on a resolutory condition established for the case of non-payment of all or part of the deferred price entitles the seller to terminate the contract and recover the property, provided that the seller has first required the buyer, by notarial act, to make payment within twenty days, with the warning that, if the buyer does not do so, the sale will be terminated.
2. If the resolutory condition agreement has been formalised in a public deed registered in the Land Registry, the provisions of this article apply to the termination. The agreement must provide that, for termination to take place, the unpaid part of the deferred price, including any agreed interest, must exceed 15 per cent of the full price plus interest. It may be established that the seller retains the amounts paid by the buyer, up to a maximum of half the total amount the seller should have received under the contract up to the date of termination. If interest has been agreed, the deed must include a repayment schedule, and the interest rate must be fixed, accrue monthly in arrears and not exceed the legal interest rate at the time the deed is executed increased by 50 per cent. The seller may not claim from the buyer any amount for future instalments not yet due.
3. (Annulled.)
4. Reacquisition by the seller entails a charge in rem on the property in favour of the buyer and the holders of later entries, as security for the amount, if any, to be paid to the buyer. This charge is recorded in the re-registration in the seller’s name, and its amount is the total amount the seller has received up to the date of termination, as determined by the notarial act.
5. The charge on the property does not arise, or is extinguished in whole or in part, for the following reasons:
a) Consent of the buyer and, where applicable, of the holders of later rights.
b) Judicial decision or arbitral award.
c) Notarial deposit of the amount secured or a bank guarantee for its amount.
d) Lapse, once one hundred and eighty days have passed from the date of re-registration in the seller’s name, unless there is an earlier entry of a claim opposing the termination or the liquidation.
6. The registry entries must be made in accordance with the Mortgage Act.
Subsection 8. Sale a carta de gracia
Article 621-55. Sale a carta de gracia
1. In a sale a carta de gracia, the seller reserves the right to redeem the property sold, on the conditions agreed.
2. The right to redeem the property sold must be exercised in accordance with articles 568-28 to 568-32.
Where this sits
The carta de gracia buy-back and the Catalan option and pre-emption rights are on the rights of acquisition page. Buying a flat in a Catalan building also brings the horizontal property rules, starting with the certificate of community debts. Outside Catalonia, the sale of property is governed by the Spanish Civil Code.
Related on voixa.es: Personal tax in Catalonia: both halves of the bill; Spain’s 100% property tax for non-EU buyers: what happened.
Nothing here is advice on your own position, and this reading is not the official text. Where the wording matters to a decision, read it against the Catalan or Spanish original linked above.